Philosophy & Ethics · Reasoning & arguments
When is an analogy a good argument?
An argument from analogy carries a known feature from one case to a similar one. Learn which similarities count, why one difference can sink a comparison, and how the method fares on other minds and on the design of the world.
What you will learn
- Identify the source, the target and the inferred feature in an argument from analogy
- Explain why an argument from analogy can make a conclusion plausible without guaranteeing it
- Explain why the number of similarities alone doesn't make an analogy strong
- Use a relevant difference to criticize an argument from analogy
Lesson 1 of 4 · 6 min
How an analogy argued for life on other planets
In 1785 the philosopher Thomas Reid made a case for life on other planets. He named five, Saturn, Jupiter, Mars, Venus and Mercury. Like Earth, he noted, they all orbit the sun and take their light from it. Several were known to turn on an axis, which gives them day and night. Some have moons.
Earth supports living things. So, he concluded, it's "not unreasonable to think, that those planets may, like our earth, be the habitation of various orders of living creatures."
That's an argument from analogy, and its parts have names. The case you already know well is the source, here Earth. The case you're reasoning about is the target, the other planets. The argument lists known similarities between them, points to one more feature of the source, and concludes that the target probably has it too.
The same shape turns up far from astronomy. Reid pointed out that doctors prescribe by analogy, since what makes one human body well will probably do the same for another. Whenever someone says a new case is like a familiar one, ask three things. Which is the source? Which is the target? And what exactly is being carried across?
An argument from analogy can have true premises and a false conclusion. Everything Reid said about orbits, light and moons could be right, and the planets could still be lifeless. Nothing in the premises rules that out. So the most an analogy offers is support of some degree.
How much? One answer is that it raises the probability of its conclusion. John Stuart Mill held that every resemblance adds some, unless it's known to be irrelevant. If two things agree in 9 of 10 known properties, he reasoned, the probability is 0.9 that they'll agree in the next.
Another answer is more modest. An analogy shows that an idea is worth testing. In 1934 the pharmacologist Schaumann saw that a new compound, meperidine, bent the tails of mice into an S. Only morphine was known to do that. He guessed the compound might dull pain as morphine does, and tests on animals and then people showed it did.
Benjamin Franklin's 1749 list of twelve resemblances between lightning and laboratory electricity ended in the same spirit. "Let the experiment be made."
Support also depends on how much is claimed. Reid said only that it's "not unreasonable" to think the planets "may" be inhabited. In a 1933 logic textbook, L. S. Stebbing found the argument suggestive for exactly that reason, since a modest conclusion needs less support.
Mill seems to have rejected it. We know very little about which properties matter for life on another planet, and ignorance weakens an analogy. Both points are standard guidelines. On Reid's argument, they pull in opposite directions.
Try to recallThomas Reid concluded only that it's "not unreasonable" to think other planets "may" be inhabited. How does that cautious wording help his argument from analogy, and what still counts against the argument?
A weak conclusion is easier to support, so claiming only that life is possible asks less of the similarities. That's why Stebbing found the argument suggestive. Against it, we know very little about which properties matter for life on another planet, and the less we know about the two cases, the weaker the analogy. That's why Mill seems to have rejected it. Here the two guidelines point in opposite directions.
So when someone argues from a comparison, name the source, the target and the feature being carried across. Then remember what you're getting. At best, the conclusion becomes more likely. Often the analogy is only a reason to run the test, as it was for the mice and the lightning.
Lessons in this topic
How an analogy argued for life on other planets
In 1785 Thomas Reid argued that the planets may be inhabited because they resemble Earth. Name the three parts of an argument from analogy, and see why it can make a conclusion plausible without ever guaranteeing it.
Why more similarities don't make a better analogy
A long list of resemblances proves little. See why a strong analogy needs similarities connected to the feature being inferred, and how one relevant difference can sink it.
How do you know others have minds?
You feel your own pain but only see other people's behavior. Follow John Stuart Mill's argument that an analogy with your own case bridges the gap, and the objection that it rests on a sample of one.
Does a world like a machine need a maker?
In Hume's Dialogues, Cleanthes argues from the world's machine-like order to a designing mind. See how the skeptic Philo uses the rules of analogy to show how little that argument can deliver.
Three quick stories from this topic
Franklin's twelve resemblances
From a list of 12 resemblances, Franklin predicted that pointed rods would draw lightning
In 1749 he noted that lightning and laboratory electricity agree in their light, crooked path, noise and nine more ways. Laboratory electricity is attracted by metal points, so he reasoned that lightning probably is too. His note ends, "Let the experiment be made."
An argument from analogy
Laboratory electricity was the source and lightning the target. The shared features included light, a crooked path, being conducted by metals and a crack when exploding. Attraction to points was the feature carried across.
A reason to run the test
Franklin knew of no causal link between the twelve features and attraction to points, only a strong correlation. His list ended, "Let the experiment be made."
Hume's infant god
Hume's skeptic said the world might be the botched first attempt of an infant god
In Hume's Dialogues, published in 1779, Philo accepts that the world may come from something like design. But a flawed world is no evidence of a perfect maker. It could be the work of "some infant Deity, who afterwards abandoned it, ashamed of his lame performance."
The argument he was answering
Cleanthes calls the world one great machine and infers, by the rules of analogy, that its cause resembles a human mind with far greater powers.
A cause proportioned to its effect
Philo's rule is to credit a cause only with what's needed to produce what we observe. A finite, imperfect world can't show a maker who is infinite, perfect or even single.
The mouse-tail painkiller
A painkiller was discovered because it curled the tails of mice the way morphine does
In 1934 the pharmacologist Schaumann was testing compounds for use against spasms. One, meperidine, bent mouse tails into an S, an effect seen before only with morphine. He guessed it might also dull pain, and tests on animals and then people showed it did.
An argument from analogy
Morphine was the source and the new compound the target. They had a similar chemical structure and shared one odd effect on mice. The feature carried across was pain relief.
A reason to test, not a proof
The resemblance didn't show the drug would work. It made the idea worth trying on rats, rabbits, dogs and eventually humans. Meperidine is also known as Demerol.
Sources
- Analogy and Analogical Reasoning, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Essays on the Intellectual Powers of Man, J. Bell and G.G.J. & J. Robinson
- Hume on Religion, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy





