Philosophy & Ethics · Reality & existence
Does time really pass?
Events seem to slide from future to present to past. Compare the theories that say time really passes with those that say it only seems to, and test each against the objections it faces.

What you will learn
- Distinguish McTaggart's A-series of past, present and future from his B-series of earlier and later
- Explain how A-theorists and B-theorists each describe an autumn leaf changing color
- Compare presentism, eternalism and the growing block theory on whether past and future things exist
- Explain why relations to past people, like admiring Marie Curie, pose a problem for presentism
Lesson 1 of 4 · 5 min
Past, present and future, or just earlier and later?
This morning, your lunch is in the future. By tonight it'll be in the past. Yet all day long, it's earlier than your dinner. Those are two different ways of placing an event in time.
The Cambridge philosopher J. M. E. McTaggart drew the distinction in a 1908 paper called "The Unreality of Time." He used it to argue that time doesn't exist. His distinction has stuck, and philosophers still use it to sort theories of time.
One way orders times by properties such as being present, being one day past or being two days future. McTaggart called this the A-series. The other orders them by relations such as earlier than and simultaneous with. That's the B-series.
The two behave differently. Breakfast is earlier than lunch at every moment, whichever moment is present. B-series facts are fixed. A-series positions keep changing. Your lunch is future in the morning, present at noon and past by evening.
McTaggart assumed that change is essential to time. Nothing in the B-series ever changes, so he held that time needs the A-series.
McTaggart's two series gave their names to two families of theories. B-theorists hold that earlier and later are enough to describe all change. They usually picture time as laid out like space, one stretched-out whole in which events sit at different locations.
On this view, an autumn leaf's turning red just means it's green at an earlier location and red at a later one. Tenseless statements such as "The leaf is red at October 7, 2019" capture the facts, and they're always true or always false.
A-theorists think that leaves something out. For them, some change takes tensed statements like "The leaf is red," which are true at one time and false at another. Reality is one complete way now. It was different before and will be different later.
Their evidence includes how much you care. Say you need a painful operation. You'd much rather it were behind you than ahead of you. Philosophers call this the temporal value asymmetry, and A-theorists say tensed facts explain it.
B-theorists reply with physics. Special relativity removes the distinction between past, present and future from its models of space and time. J. J. C. Smart and Huw Mellor compared "now" to "here." "Here" picks out wherever it's said, and "now" picks out whenever it's said.
Nobody thinks physics is incomplete for leaving out hereness. Smart called our sense of time flowing "an illusion which prevents us seeing the world as it really is."
Try to recallAn autumn leaf turns from green to red. How would a B-theorist describe that change, and what would an A-theorist say the description leaves out?
A B-theorist says the leaf is green at an earlier time and red at a later one, and tenseless statements like "The leaf is red at October 7, 2019" capture everything important about the change. An A-theorist says that leaves out tensed facts, such as the leaf now being red when it was green before, which change truth value as time goes on. The A-theorist adds that tensed facts explain why we care whether a bad event is past or still to come.
So B-theorists say earlier and later are all there is, and A-theorists say one moment really is present. Einstein felt the pull of both. The philosopher Rudolf Carnap recalled him saying that the problem of the Now worried him seriously. The Now means something special to us, Einstein explained, yet that difference "does not and cannot occur within physics."
Lessons in this topic
Past, present and future, or just earlier and later?
Whether an event is past, present or future keeps changing, but whether it's earlier or later than another never does. See how that difference splits philosophers of time into two camps.
Does only the present exist?
Presentism, eternalism and the growing block theory disagree about whether Socrates and dinosaurs exist. See why admiring Marie Curie is a puzzle for the view that only the present is real.
McTaggart's argument that time isn't real
Follow McTaggart's argument that time is unreal, and find the premise that each side of the debate rejects.
Is there one present for everyone?
Two people walking past each other can disagree by days about what's happening now in a distant galaxy. See why that threatens the view that only the present exists, and what it costs to save it.
Three quick stories from this topic
Dinosaurs still exist
On the eternalist theory of time, dinosaurs still exist and just aren't present
Eternalism says past and future things are as real as present ones, the way distant places are as real as the one you're in. Its rival, presentism, says only present things exist. That leaves presentists explaining what makes "there were dinosaurs" true.
Three lists of what exists
Presentism lists only present things. The growing block theory adds past things. Eternalism adds future things too, such as Martian outposts that haven't been built.
Why anyone believes it
Eternalists point to special relativity, which removes the distinction between past, present and future from physical models of space and time.
One second per second
Time would have to flow at one second per second, which may not be a rate at all
Huw Price argued that a quantity can't change with respect to itself. Tim Maudlin answered with money. The fair exchange rate for dollars into dollars is one dollar per dollar, he wrote, and you'd object to an offer at any other rate.
Maudlin's exchange rate
Tim Maudlin replied in 2007 that one second per second is a perfectly good rate. When you swap US dollars for US dollars, the only fair rate is one dollar per dollar. If that sounds meaningless, he wrote, "imagine your reaction to an offer of exchange at any other rate."
Price's answer
Price replied in 2011 that Maudlin's example compares dollars offered with dollars returned. One second per second, like one mile per mile, compares a quantity with itself, and he held that neither can be a rate.
Now in Andromeda
Two walkers passing in the street can differ by days on what is happening now in Andromeda
Each strolls at about 4 km per hour, one toward the galaxy and one away from it. In special relativity, which distant events count as simultaneous with you depends on how you're moving. Across the distance to another galaxy, that small difference adds up to more than five days.
Penrose's invasion fleet
Roger Penrose imagined Andromedans launching a space fleet during that gap. For one walker the fleet has already set off. For the other, the decision to launch has not yet been made.
Why philosophers care
If physics offers no single now, it's hard to hold that only present things exist. Presentists have to add a privileged present that no experiment can detect.
Sources
- Time, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- John M. E. McTaggart, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Being and Becoming in Modern Physics, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy





