Philosophy & Ethics · Reasoning & arguments
Socrates and the Socratic method
Socrates wrote nothing and claimed to know nothing, yet Athens put him to death for his questions. See how his cross-examination works, what it can prove, and why his trial still divides readers.

What you will learn
- Explain why Socrates is known only through other writers, and name the main ones
- Explain what Socrates meant by claiming to know nothing, and how he tested others' wisdom
- Describe the steps of a Socratic cross-examination, from a definition to a contradiction
- Explain why Socratic dialogues often end in puzzlement, using the Euthyphro
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
The thinker who wrote nothing and claimed to know nothing
Picture a barefoot man in the Athens marketplace around 420 BCE, stopping anyone who'd talk. He took no fees and said he wasn't a teacher. That was Socrates, born about 470 BCE, and he never wrote a word of philosophy.
So everything we know about him comes secondhand. Three people who knew him left the main accounts. The comic playwright Aristophanes mocked him on stage. Xenophon, a soldier and historian, wrote memoirs of a practical, helpful adviser.
Plato, who was about 25 when Socrates died, made him the star of most of his dialogues. These are written conversations, and they're where the famous Socrates lives. The three portraits don't match, so who Socrates really was is still argued over.
In Plato's account, a friend of Socrates named Chaerephon asked the oracle at Delphi, Apollo's shrine, whether anyone was wiser than Socrates. The answer was no. Socrates was baffled, since he didn't think himself wise.
So he set out to test the oracle. He questioned politicians, then poets, then craftsmen. Each believed he knew things he couldn't explain under questioning.
His conclusion is the line people quote. One such man "knows nothing, and thinks that he knows. I neither know nor think that I know." Socrates's only edge was knowing his limits. The popular version, "I know that I know nothing," never appears in Plato in that form.
Try to recallAccording to Plato's Apology, in what way did Socrates think he was wiser than the people he questioned?
They believed they knew things they didn't, while he didn't think he knew what he didn't know. His wisdom was knowing his own ignorance. He found this out by questioning politicians, poets and craftsmen after the oracle's answer.
Socrates wrote nothing, so we see him through Plato, Xenophon and Aristophanes. His claim of ignorance was a practical stance. He tested people who thought they were wise and found that knowing your limits was rarer than knowledge.
Lessons in this topic
The thinker who wrote nothing and claimed to know nothing
Learn who Socrates was, why we know him only through other people's writing, and what his famous ignorance meant in practice.
How a Socratic cross-examination works
Follow Socrates's method of questioning step by step, and see why his conversations so often end with nobody sure of the answer.
Why Athens put Socrates to death
Look at the charges against Socrates in 399 BCE, the politics behind them, and why he refused the chance to escape.
Can we ever find the real Socrates?
See how historians try to separate the real Socrates from Plato's character, and what a method that only refutes can and can't prove.
Three quick stories from this topic
Mocked on stage in 423
Aristophanes mocked Socrates on stage in 423 BCE, when Plato and Xenophon were infants
The comedy Clouds showed Socrates hanging in a basket and teaching tricks of argument. At his trial 24 years later, Plato's Socrates said the play had turned many jurors against him while they were young.
A blended villain
The scholar Kenneth Dover argued the stage Socrates bundles traits of several other thinkers of the time.
Why it matters
It's the only source from someone who knew Socrates in his prime, and it's a comedy.
The free meals penalty
Found guilty in 399 BCE, Socrates first proposed free meals for life as his penalty
Athens let a convicted man suggest his own sentence. Socrates proposed the honor given to Olympic victors, meals at public expense, since he said he'd done the city good. Then he offered a fine. The jury chose death.
A close verdict
In Plato's account, Socrates said that if thirty votes had gone the other way he'd have been acquitted.
Why he did it
He held that his questioning was a service to Athens, so a reward was the honest proposal.
The quote he never said
Socrates never says "I know that I know nothing" in any of Plato's works
The famous line is a later paraphrase. In Plato's Apology, Socrates says another man "knows nothing, and thinks that he knows," while he himself neither knows nor thinks he knows.
He claimed some knowledge
In the same speech Socrates says outright that he knows certain things, which the slogan leaves out.
Why the slogan stuck
Socrates wrote nothing, so a short, quotable version of Plato's longer passage took his place.
Sources
- Socrates, Debra Nails, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Socrates, Wikipedia
- Socratic problem, Wikipedia
- Apology, translated by Benjamin Jowett, Plato, Project Gutenberg
- I know that I know nothing, Wikipedia
- Trial of Socrates, Wikipedia




