Philosophy & Ethics · Ethics & moral choices
Utilitarianism
Utilitarians say the right act is the one that brings the most well-being to everyone it affects. See how Bentham and Mill built the theory, how it handles hard cases, and what it should count as good.

What you will learn
- Explain Bentham's principle of utility and why it made acts right or wrong only by their effects
- Describe how Bentham proposed to measure pleasure and pain, with each person counting for one
- Explain the objection that Bentham's theory suited pigs, and how Mill's higher pleasures answer it
- Explain Mill's test of asking people who know both pleasures, and the doubts it faces
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
Bentham's plan to judge every law by happiness
Near the entrance of a student center in London sits a wooden case holding Jeremy Bentham. It's his skeleton, padded with hay, dressed in his clothes and topped with a wax head. He asked for this in his will before he died in 1832. What had this man proposed that his followers wanted to keep him around?
Bentham's 1789 book opens with a famous line. "Nature has placed mankind under the governance of two sovereign masters, pain and pleasure." He meant they drive what we do, and they also set what we ought to do.
His principle of utility judges every action by whether it tends to increase or reduce the happiness of those it affects. By happiness he meant pleasure and the absence of pain. The test covers private acts and every measure of government.
Bentham wanted the test to be usable, so he listed ways to measure a pleasure or pain. How strong is it, and how long does it last? How certain is it, and how soon will it come? Will it lead to more pleasures, and is it free of pain that follows? Last comes extent, the number of people affected.
He didn't expect anyone to run these numbers before every choice. Experience shows that kicking someone causes more pain than it gives pleasure, so a rule of thumb does the job.
Extent is what makes the theory about everyone and not just you. Mill later summed up Bentham's view as "everybody to count for one, nobody for more than one." A duke's toothache weighs exactly as much as a farmhand's.
Try to recallIn Bentham's way of measuring happiness, what does "everybody to count for one, nobody for more than one" change about a decision?
Each person's pleasure and pain gets the same weight, whoever they are. So you can't favor yourself, your friends or the powerful. A choice is judged by its effects on everyone it reaches, which is why extent, the number affected, matters.
You can now state Bentham's single test for acts and laws, list the ways he measured pleasure and pain, and say why everyone's happiness counts the same in the sum.
Lessons in this topic
Bentham's plan to judge every law by happiness
See how Jeremy Bentham proposed one test for every act and every law, how he meant to measure pleasure and pain, and why everyone's counted the same.
Is it better to be Socrates or a happy fool?
See why critics called Bentham's theory a philosophy fit for pigs, and how John Stuart Mill tried to fix it by ranking some pleasures above others.
The surgeon with five patients
Test utilitarianism against a surgeon who could save five by killing one, and against the demand to give until it hurts. Then see how following the best rules is meant to help.
What counts as a good life, and the pleasure machine
Compare the three main accounts of well-being that a utilitarian could try to maximize, then test them against a machine that fakes a perfect life.
Three quick stories from this topic
Bentham on display
Jeremy Bentham's skeleton, dressed in his own clothes, sits on show at a London university
Bentham left his body to be dissected and then kept as an auto-icon. His skeleton was padded with hay and given a wax head. The real head was locked away after repeated student pranks.
Where he sits
Since 2020 the auto-icon has been on public display at the entrance of University College London's Student Centre.
Useful even dead
Bentham wrote an essay on the further uses of the dead to the living. Preserving himself fit his view that things should be judged by their use.
Can they suffer?
In 1789 Jeremy Bentham said the test for moral concern was suffering, not reason or speech
He wrote that "the question is not, Can they reason? nor, Can they talk? but, Can they suffer?" Because he counted every pleasure and pain by amount alone, an animal's pain had to count too.
Amount, not kind
Bentham saw no difference in kind between pleasures, so a pig's pain weighed the same as a person's of the same size.
Mill's change
John Stuart Mill later ranked pleasures by quality, putting pleasures of the intellect above bodily ones.
Staying in the machine
Told their real life was in prison, only 13% of students chose to quit a pleasure machine
In a 2010 study, Felipe de Brigard told 72 US students to imagine they were already living inside an experience machine. With no details about real life, 54% chose to leave. The prison detail cut that to 13%.
Nozick's original
Robert Nozick argued in 1974 that refusing to plug into such a machine shows pleasure isn't all we care about.
The bias reply
De Brigard argued the refusal reflects status quo bias, a preference for what we already have, more than a love of reality.
Sources
- Jeremy Bentham, Wikipedia
- An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation, Chapter I, Wikisource
- Utilitarianism, Wikipedia
- The History of Utilitarianism, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Utilitarianism, by John Stuart Mill (7th edition, 1879), Project Gutenberg
- Experience machine, Wikipedia





