Philosophy & Ethics · Ethics & moral choices
Judging right and wrong by results or by duties
Some moral arguments turn on what a choice brings about. Others turn on what you owe people, whatever the result. Learn to tell which one you're hearing, and see where each runs into trouble.

What you will learn
- Identify an argument that bases moral rightness on consequences
- Explain why counting supporters isn't the same as evaluating effects
- Identify a duty-based reason for keeping a promise
- Tell moral duties apart from simply obeying a rule or law
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
Judging a choice by what it brings about
Say a town has one spare room and two offers for it. A weekly film night would give sixty people a pleasant evening. A reading class would teach twelve adults to read. Which should get the room?
One way to answer is consequentialism. It says a choice is right or wrong because of what it brings about, and nothing else.
The film night helps more people a little. The class helps fewer people a lot. So to compare them you need a view about what counts as good.
Consequentialists disagree about that. The classic utilitarians, such as Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill, said pleasure is the only thing good in itself and pain the only thing bad.
Robert Nozick tested that with an imagined experience machine. Plugged in, you'd believe you were winning gold medals and spending time with friends. You'd feel the pleasure, and none of it would be real.
If only pleasure mattered, refusing the machine would be irrational. It doesn't seem irrational. So many consequentialists count other goods too, such as knowledge, freedom and real friendship.
Judging by results isn't the same as taking a vote. Picture ten people who mildly prefer an option that imposes a severe loss on someone else. A show of hands goes ten to one.
A vote counts heads. It doesn't record how much each person gains or loses. Someone weighing the outcome asks who is affected and by how much. Ten small gains don't automatically outweigh one large loss.
The ten also won't feel the loss, so a majority can overlook costs it doesn't bear.
Results are also hard to know in advance. Say Alice meets a runaway teenager who asks for money to get home. She buys a bus ticket. The bus crashes in a freak accident, and the teenager is killed.
Did Alice do wrong? If what counts is what actually happened, she did, though nobody would blame her. If what counts is what she could reasonably expect, she did right. Consequentialists are split.
Either way, wanting to help doesn't tell you what will help.
Try to recallMost people in a town support a policy. Why doesn't that show the policy has the best consequences?
A vote counts supporters. It doesn't show how much each person gains or loses, or who bears the losses. Many mild preferences can sit alongside one severe cost, and the majority may not be the ones paying it.
So an argument from results owes you two things. It has to say what it counts as good. And it needs evidence that the choice will deliver it. When you hear "this will be better for everyone," ask for both.
Lessons in this topic
Judging a choice by what it brings about
Consequentialism judges a choice by its results. You'll see why that needs a view of what counts as good, and why a show of hands can't stand in for it.
What a promise adds that results leave out
Duty-based ethics says some things are owed whatever the payoff. See what a constraint is, why a duty isn't the same as a law, and where results still count.
Agreeing on what to do but not on why
Two people can back the same rule for different reasons, and the difference shows when the case changes. Learn how to find it.
May you do one wrong to prevent two?
If broken promises are bad, why not break one to prevent two? See why many duty-based thinkers refuse, and the objection they still have to answer.
Three quick stories from this topic
The $100 shoes problem
On a strict utilitarian view, buying $100 shoes you don't need is morally wrong
The same $100 could go to a charity that would do more good with it, and strict utilitarianism counts anything short of the most good as wrong. Some utilitarians accept this. They conclude that most of what most people do is wrong.
Why that troubles many people
Giving to charity seems supererogatory, beyond the call of duty, rather than obligatory. Watching television rarely maximizes utility, and neither does teaching philosophy instead of working for a relief agency. A requirement to maximize would reach into personal decisions that most people think should be left to the individual.
Three utilitarian replies
Some utilitarians accept the demand and say most of what most people do is morally wrong. Mill held that an act is wrong only when its agent is liable to punishment for failing to maximize. Satisficing consequentialism says we must produce enough good, not the most possible.
The trolley and the surgeon
Killing one to save five seems allowed with a trolley and monstrous with a surgeon
A runaway trolley will kill five workers unless switched to a track where it kills one. Most people say switch it. A surgeon could save five patients with one healthy man's organs, and people condemn that. On one view, the patient is used as a means and the worker isn't.
Same count, different verdicts
In both cases one person dies and five live, so a simple tally of results can't tell them apart. Philosophers use the pair to test whether results are all that matter.
The rule against using people
On one duty-based view, the five patients couldn't be saved without the healthy man's body, so he is used. The five workers would be saved whether or not anyone stood on the side track.
What if everybody did that
If nobody had children humanity would die out, yet that doesn't make being childless wrong
It's the standard counterexample to the test "What would happen if everybody did that?" Philosophers who judge rules by their results now ask what would happen if everybody were permitted to do it. Enough people want children that nothing bad follows.
Judging rules by their results
Rule consequentialism makes the rightness of an act depend on the consequences of a rule. Theft is wrong, on this view, because it would be disastrous if everybody broke a rule against it.
Why the new question works
People are permitted to do whatever no accepted rule forbids. So asking what happens if everyone is permitted to do something is the same as asking what happens if people accept no rule against it.
Sources
- Consequentialism, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Deontological Ethics, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy





