Philosophy & Ethics · Reasoning & arguments
Logical fallacies
A fallacy is an argument that persuades without giving good support. Learn to name the common ones, from the straw man to the false dilemma, and to tell a real fallacy from a fair point that only looks like one.

What you will learn
- Explain why an attack on the person making a claim leaves the claim untouched
- Spot a straw man or a whataboutism and say what a fair reply would do instead
- Explain how begging the question and the false dilemma build the conclusion into a premise
- Explain how post hoc and slippery slope arguments claim causes the evidence hasn't shown
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
Arguments that hit the wrong target
Say a woman named Thompson proposes a plan to protect a local wetland. A rival tells the meeting to ignore it, because last year Thompson was arrested for hunting without a license. Heads nod. Did the rival just give a reason to reject the plan?
No. A fallacy is an argument that seems better than it really is. It persuades without giving good support. This one is an ad hominem, Latin for "to the person". It attacks the person who made the claim instead of the claim.
The arrest may be true. But a wetland plan works or fails because of its own details, so a fact about its author can't settle it. A fair reply names a flaw in the plan itself.
The neighbor who tells you to exercise but never does is a close cousin, called tu quoque, or "you too". Her advice is as good or bad as it would be from a marathon runner.
Two more moves dodge a claim by swapping in another one. A straw man restates someone's view in a weaker or exaggerated form, then knocks that down. The name suggests a figure stuffed with straw, which topples easily.
Say someone argues that industry is the main cause of global warming. An opponent replies that it's silly to blame industry for every human problem. Nobody said that. And even if the bigger claim were false, the original one would still stand.
Whataboutism meets an accusation with a counter-accusation, the reply "What about you?" The word whataboutery appeared in The Irish Times in 1974, in pieces about the conflict in Northern Ireland. The other side's wrongs may be real, but they don't answer the charge.
Try to recallCritics say a company polluted a river. The company replies that the critics' own town dumps sewage. Why doesn't that reply answer the criticism, and what would?
The reply is whataboutism. The town's sewage may be real, but it says nothing about whether the company polluted the river. A fair reply would deal with the river, by showing the company didn't pollute it or by saying how it will stop.
A personal attack, a straw man and a whataboutism all hit something other than the claim. Ask what was actually claimed, and whether the reply touches it.
Lessons in this topic
Arguments that hit the wrong target
See how a personal attack, a straw man and a whataboutism each answer something other than the claim, and what a fair reply does instead.
Arguments that quietly assume the hard part
Learn how begging the question, the false dilemma, the post hoc and the slippery slope hide their weakest step, and the one question that exposes each.
When a fallacy turns out to be a fair point
Trusting experts, questioning a witness and warning about a slope can all be good reasoning. Learn the test that separates the fair version from the fallacy.
Why naming a fallacy doesn't win the argument
A bad argument can still have a true conclusion. Learn why, how to answer a weak argument usefully, and where the lists of fallacies began.
Three quick stories from this topic
The 48 chromosomes
For more than 30 years, textbooks taught that humans have 48 chromosomes
Theophilus Painter reported 48 in 1923 from tangled, hard-to-read slides. Some scientists who counted 46 changed their data to match him, until Tjio and Levan counted 46 in 1955.
An expert's word
Painter was a leading zoologist, and his count went into textbooks. His standing made others doubt their own results.
Where trust went wrong
Relying on experts is usually reasonable. It became a mistake when his word was kept after the evidence turned against it.
Aristotle's 13 tricks
Aristotle sorted fake winning arguments into 13 kinds, six of them tricks of wording
His book On Sophistical Refutations is where the study of fallacies begins. He aimed it at the sophists, who he said made money from a wisdom that only looked real.
Tin that looks like silver
Aristotle said a sham argument fools people through its likeness to a real one. Inexperienced listeners see it only from a distance.
The list grew later
Many Latin names, like ad hominem, came centuries later. John Locke described them in 1690 without calling them fallacies.
The birth of whataboutery
The word whataboutery is traced to The Irish Times in 1974, during the Troubles
A letter complained about "the Whatabouts", people who met every IRA killing by pointing to the other side's wrongs. Three days later a columnist in the same paper named the habit "Whataboutery".
From Belfast to the Cold War
The term spread in writing about Northern Ireland. Later it became tied to Soviet replies to Western criticism of human rights.
Why it fails
A counter-accusation can be true and still leave the original charge unanswered. The other side's wrongs don't excuse your own.
Sources
- Fallacies, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Fallacies, Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Ad hominem, Wikipedia
- Straw man, Wikipedia
- Whataboutism, Wikipedia
- Argument from authority, Wikipedia
- Theophilus Painter, Wikipedia
- The art of counting chromosomes, Science History Institute
- On Sophistical Refutations, translated by W. A. Pickard-Cambridge, The Internet Classics Archive, MIT




