Philosophy & Ethics · Art & beauty
Can one person's taste be better than another's?
People disagree about beauty, yet some judgments seem better than others. Hume and Kant each tried to explain how that can be, and each account faces a serious objection.

What you will learn
- Explain why Hume thought the proverb that tastes can't be disputed breaks down in some comparisons
- Name the five qualities Hume said a true critic needs, and explain what delicacy of taste is
- Distinguish Kant's judgments of the agreeable, of beauty and of the good, using his idea of disinterested pleasure
- Explain what Kant meant by saying a judgment of beauty claims universal validity yet can't be proved
Lesson 1 of 4 · 7 min
Why Hume thought some tastes are better
"There's no disputing about tastes," the proverb says. Yet hardly anyone thinks a clumsy rhyme is as good as a great poem. In 1757 David Hume wrote an essay, "Of the Standard of Taste," to work out how both thoughts can hold.
He started from the variety. People differ in taste even when they grew up under one government and absorbed the same prejudices. We're quick to call anything far from our own taste barbarous, he noted, and soon hear the insult thrown back. So it's natural to look for a Standard of Taste, "a rule, by which the various sentiments of men may be reconciled."
One school of philosophy, Hume reported, thinks the search is hopeless. A judgment about how things are can be true or false, because it answers to the facts. A feeling points to nothing beyond itself, so "All sentiment is right." Beauty, on this view, "is no quality in things themselves." Hunting for real beauty is as pointless as settling what's really sweet or really bitter.
Hume granted that the proverb has common sense on its side. Then he pointed to another kind of common sense that pushes back. Say someone claimed John Ogilby wrote with as much genius as John Milton. That, Hume wrote, is as extravagant as calling a pond as extensive as the ocean. A few people may prefer the lesser writer, but "no one pays attention to such a taste," and we call it "absurd and ridiculous."
So we treat tastes as equal only when the works are close in quality. Hume agreed that beauty belongs to feeling. But he held that there are "certain qualities in objects, which are fitted by nature to produce those particular feelings." Some people are better than others at picking those qualities up.
Why do some people miss a beauty that others feel? One reason, Hume thought, is that they lack delicacy of imagination. To show what he meant, he borrowed "a noted story in Don Quixote."
Sancho says good judgment in wine is "a quality hereditary in our family," and he tells a story to prove it. Two of his kinsmen were once asked to judge a barrel that was supposed to be excellent, being old and of a good vintage. One pronounced the wine good except for a small taste of leather. The other agreed, except for a taste of iron he could easily pick out. Both were ridiculed.
Then the barrel was emptied. At the bottom lay "an old key with a leathern thong tied to it."
A delicate taste, for Hume, is one fine enough "to allow nothing to escape" it, and exact enough to pick out every ingredient in a mixture. The key plays the part of the general rules of beauty, which are drawn from long-admired works and from noticing what pleases. Show a bad critic such a rule, prove it applies to the case in front of him, and he must conclude "that the fault lies in himself."
Even if the barrel had never been emptied, the kinsmen's taste would have been just as delicate and their mockers' just as dull. The key only made it easier to prove who was right.
Delicacy is one of five qualities a true judge needs. The others are practice, comparison across many works, freedom from prejudice and good sense. Without practice, a verdict is confused and hesitant. Without comparison, a judge admires trivial charms that are really defects. Prejudice warps his feeling, and without good sense he misses the design of a work. Most people fall short somewhere, so a true judge is "so rare a character."
Try to recallHume said a true judge of art needs five qualities. Name them, and explain how the wine-tasting story Hume took from Don Quixote illustrates one of them.
Hume's five qualities are delicacy of taste, practice, comparison, freedom from prejudice and good sense. The wine story illustrates delicacy. Two tasters praised a wine, but one noticed a faint taste of leather and the other a taste of iron. They were mocked until an old key on a leather thong turned up at the bottom of the barrel. A delicate taste picks up small ingredients that others miss. The key stands for the general rules of beauty, which let you prove to a doubter that the flaw was really there.
Hume summed up his true judge in a single sentence. "Strong sense, united to delicate sentiment, improved by practice, perfected by comparison, and cleared of all prejudice, can alone entitle critics to this valuable character."
He concluded that the joint verdict of such critics is the true standard of taste and beauty. So Hume's answer to the proverb is that you can dispute about taste, because some judges notice more than others. When two verdicts clash, ask who gave each one, and how much practice, comparison and freedom from prejudice stood behind it.
Lessons in this topic
Why Hume thought some tastes are better
Hume thought some judgments of beauty really are better than others, and he named five qualities that make a good judge.
What you claim when you call something beautiful
Liking a wine and calling a sonnet beautiful are different judgments for Kant, and only the second claims everyone's agreement.
How would you recognize a true judge of art?
Test Hume's standard against the charge that it runs in a circle, and find out which disagreements he thought no standard can settle.
Can a feeling speak for everyone?
Kant argued that pleasure in beauty comes from a state of mind everyone can share. Follow the argument, then weigh the dilemma that some of his readers think defeats it.
Three quick stories from this topic
Beauty demands agreement
Kant held that calling a thing beautiful is a demand that everyone else agree
Liking a wine is personal, and nobody thinks you're wrong if you don't. But someone who calls a thing beautiful, Kant wrote, "judges not merely for himself, but for everyone." He rebukes people who disagree, though no rule exists that could prove him right.
Wine and sonnets
Kant's example of a mere preference was Canary wine. A modern philosopher adds that if you get no pleasure from Shakespeare's Sonnets, he'll think you're in error.
The Big Question
How can a judgment based on your own pleasure claim to be correct? One philosopher calls that the Big Question in aesthetics, and says Kant asked it rightly even if his answer fails.
Homer and the test of time
Hume's test of a great writer was admiration that outlasts centuries and crosses borders
"The same Homer, who pleased at Athens and Rome two thousand years ago, is still admired at Paris and at London," he wrote in 1757. Authority or prejudice can make a bad poet fashionable for a while, he argued, but that fame never lasts or spreads.
Philosophers come and go
Hume thought theories of philosophy rise and fall with chance and fashion. In eloquence and poetry, he held, writing that truly captures passion and nature soon wins lasting applause. Aristotle, Plato, Epicurus and Descartes may each yield to the next, he wrote, but Terence and Virgil hold "an universal, undisputed empire over the minds of men."
Nations and their poets
Cicero's philosophy had fallen out of favor, Hume observed, while the force of his oratory was still admired. A civilized nation can easily pick the wrong philosopher to admire, he wrote, but it has never stayed wrong for long about "a favourite epic or tragic author."
The key in the barrel
In a story Hume took from Don Quixote, a key in the barrel proved two wine tasters right
One taster found a hint of leather in the wine and the other a hint of iron, and both were laughed at. When the barrel was emptied, an old key on a leather thong lay at the bottom. Hume used the story to show that a finer taste detects what's really there.
Where the story comes from
Hume retold it in his 1757 essay "Of the Standard of Taste," calling it "a noted story in Don Quixote." In it Sancho claims that a judgment in wine is "a quality hereditary in our family."
What the key stands for
Hume compared the key to the general rules of beauty. Even if the barrel had never been emptied, he said, the tasters would have been just as delicate. The key only made it easier to convince every bystander.
Sources
- Of the Standard of Taste, Hume Texts Online
- Hume's Aesthetics, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Aesthetic Judgment, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Kant's Aesthetics and Teleology, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy





