Philosophy & Ethics · Art & beauty
Can a copy have the same artistic value?
A copy can look exactly like an original without being the same artwork. Production history, performance and judgments of value all make the question harder than comparing how two objects look.

What you will learn
- Separate looking like an artwork from being that artwork
- Explain why production history can matter to an artwork's identity
- Explain why many performances can all be instances of one musical work
- Show why a work with many instances can still depend on its production history
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
Why a perfect copy isn't the same painting
In 1937 a museum in Rotterdam bought The Supper at Emmaus as an extraordinary painting by Vermeer. After the Second World War a living Dutch painter, Han van Meegeren, confessed that he had made it. The canvas looked exactly as it had the day before. It no longer counted as a Vermeer.
The philosopher Nelson Goodman explains why. For arts such as painting, he argues, the history of how a work was made is part of its identity, part of what makes it that particular work. A copy can look the same as an original and still lack the original canvas's connection to the artist.
That's a claim about which work an object is. It doesn't say which object is more enjoyable, skillful, expensive or useful for teaching. Those are further questions.
The Rotterdam museum still keeps The Supper at Emmaus, now under van Meegeren's name, and counts it among its visitors' favorites. Ceasing to be a Vermeer didn't settle what else the picture is worth.
Say a museum labels a copy accurately and lets students use it to study the composition. Now suppose someone presents that same copy as the artist's original. The object looks exactly as it did. What's changed is the claim made about it.
So copying and forging are different acts. An honest reproduction doesn't pretend to a history it lacks. Painting in Vermeer's manner wasn't van Meegeren's offense. Passing the result off as Vermeer's was.
Does history matter when you can't see any difference? Goodman says it does, even then. Once you know one canvas is the original and the other a copy, you look differently. You search for differences and train your eye to find ones you can't yet make out.
So looking carefully and checking provenance, the record of an object's origin and history, work together. What you learn about a picture's past changes what you see in it.
Try to recallHow can an honestly labeled copy of a painting differ from one passed off as the original, even if the two look the same?
What differs is the claim about their production history. The honest label identifies the object as a reproduction. The false attribution presents it as a work with an origin it doesn't have.
With any copy, ask three separate questions. What can you see? Which object is this, given its history? And what's being claimed about that history? The Supper at Emmaus looked the same before and after the confession. Only the last two answers changed.
Lessons in this topic
Why a perfect copy isn't the same painting
A museum's prized Vermeer became a forgery without a brushstroke changing. See why a painting's history is part of what it is, and why copying and forging are different acts.
Can an artwork exist more than once?
A symphony exists in every faithful performance, a print in every impression from the plate, and a painting in one canvas. See what decides which instances count.
One wrong note and it isn't the same piece
On Goodman's strict definition, a dull performance with every note right counts as the work and a brilliant one with a single slip doesn't. See why he drew the line there, and why it says nothing about which is better.
Which arts can be forged?
Goodman sorts the arts by whether a perfect duplicate counts as the real thing. Learn his terms autographic and allographic, and why prints and a molecule-perfect copier don't blur the line.
Three quick stories from this topic
One wrong note
By one philosopher's test, a brilliant performance with one wrong note isn't the piece
Nelson Goodman held that a performance counts as a musical work only if it complies with the score completely. A lifeless but accurate one passes. He wasn't ranking them. His point was that counting as the work and being good are separate questions.
Not a rule for concertgoers
Goodman didn't expect people to talk this way. "One hardly expects chemical purity outside the laboratory," he wrote.
An odd consequence
Because a score leaves tempo open, two performances that sound very different can be the same work, while two that sound almost alike may not be.
The Vermeer painted in 1937
The Vermeer a Rotterdam museum bought in 1937 had just been painted by a living Dutchman
The Supper at Emmaus hung as an extraordinary Vermeer until after the Second World War, when Han van Meegeren confessed. Nothing on the canvas had changed, only what people knew about its origin. The museum still keeps it, and counts it among its visitors' favorites.
Proof by painting
To back up his confession, van Meegeren offered to paint a new "Vermeer" of his own composition. In 1945 he did it in front of witnesses.
Why origin counts
The philosopher Nelson Goodman argued that a painting's history of production is part of its identity. However exact a duplicate looks, it doesn't count as the genuine work.
Forging a symphony
You can forge a painting but not a symphony, the philosopher Nelson Goodman argued
Only the canvas the artist painted is the painting, so even a perfect duplicate is a copy. A symphony has a score. Any performance that follows it is the real work, even one played from sheet music printed last week.
The perfect copier
In 1989 Gregory Currie imagined a machine that copies a painting molecule by molecule. On Goodman's terms its output would still be copies, judged by their history as prints are judged by their plate.
Two kinds of art
Goodman called arts like painting autographic and arts like music allographic. Architecture, he said, is a mixed and transitional case.
Sources
- Goodman's Aesthetics, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- The Supper at Emmaus, Han van Meegeren, Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen
- Han van Meegeren, werkend aan 'Christus temidden van de schriftgeleerden', om te bewijzen dat hij de Emmausgangers van Johannes Vermeer had vervalst, Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum




