Philosophy & Ethics · Art & beauty
What is beauty?
For two thousand years beauty meant proportion and order in the object. Then it moved into the eye of the beholder. See both views, what Darwin's peacock adds, and why the golden ratio explains less than you've heard.

What you will learn
- Describe the classical view that beauty is proportion and order among a thing's parts
- Explain why older thinkers placed beauty in the object, and what that view explains well
- Explain how Burke's objections and the turn to pleasure moved beauty into the viewer
- Explain why calling beauty subjective doesn't make every judgment of beauty equally good
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
When beauty meant proportion and order
Around 2,400 years ago the Greek sculptor Polykleitos made a statue of a man and wrote a treatise to go with it. He called both the Canon. The treatise is lost. The doctor Galen said it set out the proportions of finger to finger, fingers to wrist, forearm to arm, "of everything to everything."
Students and masters copied the statue, because it promised that beauty could be reliably achieved by reproducing the right proportions. That's the classical view. Beauty is parts arranged into a coherent whole by proportion, harmony and symmetry. Aristotle named "order and symmetry and definiteness."
To the Greeks, symmetry meant more than a mirror image. It meant measurable proportions that fit the parts to the whole, and it carried moral weight. Plato described virtuous souls as symmetrical. Centuries later, Thomas Aquinas named three requirements for beauty, integrity, due proportion and clarity.
The early Christian thinker Augustine asked whether things are beautiful because they delight us, or delight us because they're beautiful. He chose the second. Plato went further and placed beauty itself among the Forms, the perfect patterns behind things. Beautiful things are beautiful because they share in it.
This view explains a lot. Our judgments coincide very widely, and it would be odd to deny that a perfect rose or a dramatic sunset is beautiful. You can argue about beauty and be taught to see it. And if beauty is proportion, you can make it on purpose by following a canon.
Try to recallWhat does the view that beauty lies in the object explain well?
It explains why people agree so widely, about a rose or a sunset for example. It explains why we argue about beauty and can be taught to see it. And it explains why artists could aim at beauty by following rules of proportion.
For most of history, beauty meant order and proportion in the thing itself. Your delight was a response to that order.
Lessons in this topic
When beauty meant proportion and order
See why the Greeks and medieval thinkers placed beauty in the object itself, as order and proportion, and what that view explains well.
When beauty moved into the eye of the beholder
Follow the eighteenth-century turn that placed beauty in our response, and see why "it's all subjective" doesn't follow.
Did evolution shape what we find beautiful?
See how Darwin explained the peacock's tail through the peahen's taste, then weigh the evidence for an evolved human taste in landscapes.
Beautiful proofs, good souls and the golden ratio myth
See how beauty is claimed for mathematics and for character, and why the golden ratio doesn't explain it.
Three quick stories from this topic
Darwin's peacock problem
The sight of a peacock's tail feather made Charles Darwin feel sick
He wrote so to Asa Gray in 1860. A huge, impractical tail seemed to defy natural selection, because it doesn't help a bird survive. His answer, sexual selection, said generations of peahens choosing showy mates had built the tail.
Beauty as evidence
Critics such as the Duke of Argyll pointed to beauty in nature as a sign of a designer.
Taste shapes beauty
Darwin argued the peahens' standard of beauty did the shaping, step by small step. He published the idea in The Descent of Man in 1871.
The Parthenon myth
Measurements don't support the claim that the Parthenon was built on the golden ratio
The golden rectangles drawn on photos of the temple are placed wherever they fit. Euclid, who described the ratio, called it the extreme and mean ratio and said nothing about beauty. Tests since the 1870s found no rectangle most people prefer.
A real number
The golden ratio, about 1.618, is real and does turn up in how some plants grow.
A stubborn myth
The mathematician Keith Devlin called it the myth that will not go away. Claims about the nautilus shell fail too.
The sculptor's rulebook
A Greek sculptor wrote a rulebook for beauty and named it after a statue he made
Polykleitos called both the statue and the treatise the Canon. The doctor Galen said it set the proportion of finger to finger, fingers to wrist and forearm to arm, of everything to everything. Students copied it to make beauty on purpose.
A lost text
The treatise hasn't survived. We know it mainly through later writers like Galen, who described its measurements.
Beauty as proportion
The Canon stands for the classical view that beauty is order and proportion among parts, a view later attacked by Edmund Burke.
Sources
- Beauty, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Letter to Asa Gray, 3 April 1860, Darwin Correspondence Project, University of Cambridge
- Sexual selection, Darwin Correspondence Project, University of Cambridge
- The Myth That Will Not Go Away (May 2007), Keith Devlin, Mathematical Association of America
- Golden ratio, Wikipedia




