Philosophy & Ethics · Meaning & the good life
Stoicism and what is within our control
The Stoics separated your own choices from outcomes that depend on the world. That distinction doesn't tell you to do nothing, and its stronger claims about flourishing are philosophical positions you can question.

What you will learn
- Tell a chosen action apart from an external outcome
- Explain why limited control over an outcome doesn't mean doing nothing
- Explain what the Stoics meant by calling external things indifferent
- Describe how preferred externals could still guide appropriate action
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
What Epictetus said is up to you
Epictetus spent part of his life as a slave in Rome. After he was freed and began to teach philosophy, the emperor Domitian expelled him from the city along with other philosophers. He knew what it was to have no say over his own life.
His student Arrian wrote his lessons down, and the short handbook drawn from them, the Enchiridion, opens with a single distinction. "Some things are in our control and others not."
In our control, he says, are opinion, pursuit, desire and aversion, "in a word, whatever are our own actions." Outside it are "body, property, reputation, command."
Take a conversation you've prepared for. What you say, how honestly you say it and how well you listen are your own actions. Whether the other person agrees is theirs.
You can influence their answer, which is why you prepare. You can't decide it. Influence isn't control. Epictetus warns what happens when you treat what belongs to others as your own. "You will lament, you will be disturbed, and you will find fault both with gods and men."
None of this means doing nothing. Epictetus tells you to plan for the parts you can't command. His example is a visit to the baths. Before you go, he says, "picture to yourself the things which usually happen in the bath." Some people splash, some push, some shout abuse and some steal.
Then go, with two aims instead of one. You're there to bathe and to keep your own mind in order. If someone splashes you, the bath has gone a little worse. The second aim is untouched, and that was the one in your hands.
Say you're arranging an outdoor meeting and rain is possible. Booking a backup room and telling everyone the plan are your actions. The weather isn't. A Stoic does the first and judges the day by that.
Epictetus pushes the idea much further. "Lameness is a hindrance to the leg," he says, "but not to your ability to choose." He walked with a limp himself. You can use the everyday version without accepting that stronger claim, that nothing done to your body can reach your power to choose.
Try to recallWhy doesn't an uncertain outcome mean a Stoic has to give up the effort?
The Stoic line is about who controls the result. It leaves your reasons to act where they were. Preparing, being honest and making a backup plan are still up to you, and they still make a good result more likely. They can't guarantee it, because the result also depends on outside conditions.
Before something you care about, make Epictetus's two lists. Your preparation, your honesty and your effort go on the first. The other person's answer, the weather and the result go on the second. Work on the first list and judge yourself by it.
Lessons in this topic
What Epictetus said is up to you
A former slave drew a line between your own actions and everything else. See where the line falls, and why it's a reason to prepare well and no excuse to give up.
Why Stoics called health indifferent and still pursued it
The Stoics said only virtue makes a life go well, and that health and wealth make no difference to it. Learn what "indifferent" meant, and why a Stoic still chose health over illness.
Is it events that upset you, or your judgments?
Epictetus said people are disturbed by their judgments about things, and not by the things themselves. Try the idea on a small loss, then see how far he took it and where a critic can stop.
Did the Stoics want you to feel nothing?
The Stoics said the wise person has no passions. See what they meant by a passion, and which feelings their ideal sage was allowed to keep.
Three quick stories from this topic
Named after a porch
Stoicism is named after a painted porch in Athens where its first teachers lectured
The stoa poikile was a porch in the Athenian marketplace decorated with murals. Zeno of Citium founded the school there around 300 BCE. The philosophy long outlived the building and was still popular in the Roman period.
A school founded around 300 BCE
Zeno of Citium founded the school around 300 BCE. He was a voracious reader of Socratic dialogues and had studied under the Cynic Crates. Cleanthes of Assos succeeded him, and then came Chrysippus of Soli, the school's foremost theorist and systematizer, who led it from around 230 to 206 BCE.
The name outlived the building
The Stoa competed with the school Epicurus had founded in Athens a little earlier. The school of thought long outlived the physical porch and stayed popular in the Roman period and beyond, which is how a building's name became a philosophy's.
Happy on the rack
The Stoics held that a good person under torture is exactly as happy as before it began
They argued that virtue is the only thing that makes a life go well, so pain, illness and poverty can't subtract from it. Aristotle thought that conclusion was too much to accept. The Stoics accepted it.
What indifferent meant
Health, wealth and reputation were "indifferent" to happiness in Stoic ethics. Mainstream Stoics still thought them normally worth choosing over their opposites.
The ancient objection
Other schools replied that virtue is needed for happiness but isn't enough. A good person in severe pain and poverty, they said, can't be called happy.
The pale Stoic at sea
A Stoic philosopher who turned pale in a storm at sea said his school allowed for it
The Roman writer Aulus Gellius saw it and asked him why. The philosopher pulled out a book of Epictetus. A sudden fright strikes before reason can act, it said, and even the wise feel it. What counts is whether you then agree the danger is as dreadful as it looks.
No passions, still feelings
The Stoics said the wise person has no passions, meaning feelings that rest on a false judgment about what is good or bad. A first jolt of alarm involves no judgment at all.
Three good feelings
The Stoic sage was also allowed joy, caution and wishing. An ancient summary lists them as the rational counterparts of delight, fear and appetite.
Sources
- Stoicism, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- The Enchiridion, Epictetus, translated by Elizabeth Carter, Internet Classics Archive at MIT
- Epictetus, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Attic Nights, Book 19, chapter 1, translated by John C. Rolfe, Aulus Gellius, Perseus Digital Library, Tufts University
- Lives of the Eminent Philosophers, Book VII, translated by Robert Drew Hicks, Diogenes Laertius, Wikisource, Wikimedia Foundation




