Philosophy & Ethics · Meaning & the good life
Friedrich Nietzsche
Nietzsche announced that "God is dead" and asked what would hold up morality afterwards. Learn what he meant, his story of where good and evil came from, and how his sister and the Nazis distorted him.

What you will learn
- Explain why Nietzsche's madman brings the news that God is dead to people who already disbelieve
- Explain why Nietzsche saw the death of God as a danger to European morality
- Distinguish Nietzsche's noble values of good and bad from the values of good and evil
- Explain how Nietzsche's slave revolt in morality turns ressentiment into new values
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
Why Nietzsche's madman said God is dead
On a bright morning, a madman lights a lantern and runs into a busy market shouting "I seek God!" Most of the people standing around don't believe in God, so they laugh. Has God got lost, they joke, or emigrated?
Nietzsche told this story in section 125 of The Gay Science, first published in 1882. The madman turns on the crowd. "We have killed him, you and I," he says. Then comes the line that made Nietzsche famous. "God is dead."
Look at who hears the news. The crowd are already unbelievers, so the madman isn't arguing that atheism is true. Nietzsche meant a change in a whole culture. Belief in the Christian God, he wrote later in the book, had become unbelievable to Europe.
The madman asks who gave us the sponge to wipe away the horizon, and whether there's still an up and a down. Then he smashes his lantern and says "I come too early." The news is still on its way, he says, like light from a distant star.
Nietzsche explained the fear in section 343. Much had been built on this faith, he wrote, "for example, our entire European morality." Caring for strangers, guilt for wrongdoing and the equal worth of every person had leaned on God for their authority. Take away the support and, sooner or later, they lose their hold.
Most thinkers of his day assumed reason would give morality a new footing. Nietzsche thought that hope was naive. He feared nihilism, a state where your highest values lose their worth by their own standard, so nothing seems worth wanting.
Try to recallWhy did Nietzsche think the death of God was a danger, and not just the end of churchgoing?
Nietzsche thought European morality rested on belief in the Christian God. Once that belief became unbelievable, values like guilt, compassion and equal worth would lose their support, even if people kept them for a while. That could end in nihilism, where nothing seems worth wanting.
"God is dead" means a culture has stopped believing. Nietzsche's fear was that the morality resting on that belief would quietly fall with it.
Lessons in this topic
Why Nietzsche's madman said God is dead
See what Nietzsche meant by the death of God, and why he thought the news put morality itself at risk.
Where good and evil came from, according to Nietzsche
Follow Nietzsche's story of how a noble morality of good and bad gave way to good and evil, and why he told it.
Would you live your life again, forever?
Try Nietzsche's test of living your life over endlessly, then see what he meant by the Übermensch and the will to power.
How Nietzsche's sister and the Nazis remade him
Learn what happened to Nietzsche's work after his collapse, how the Nazis used him, and which harsh views were really his own.
Three quick stories from this topic
The madman's audience
Nietzsche's madman announced the death of God to a crowd of unbelievers
In section 125 of The Gay Science, published in 1882, the listeners already disbelieve and laugh at him. Nietzsche wasn't arguing for atheism. He was warning that Europe hadn't grasped what losing its faith would do to its morality.
A lantern in daylight
The madman lights a lantern on a bright morning and runs into the market crying that he seeks God. Then he tells the crowd "We have killed him, you and I."
Why he came too early
He smashes the lantern and says the news hasn't reached people yet. Nietzsche thought values like guilt and equal worth rested on the faith Europe was losing.
Where Superman came from
Nietzsche's Superman got its English name from a 1903 play by George Bernard Shaw
Nietzsche's German word is Übermensch, over-human. A 1909 English translation of Thus Spoke Zarathustra borrowed Superman from Shaw's Man and Superman. Walter Kaufmann later preferred overman, partly so readers wouldn't confuse it with comic-book heroes.
What the word means
Mensch means a human being of any sex. Zarathustra uses Übermensch for a goal that humans should surpass themselves toward.
A name that misled
The Nazis later read the figure as a racially superior type. Nietzsche presented it as a goal for people making values for this earthly life.
A book he didn't write
The Will to Power was assembled by Nietzsche's sister from his notebooks
Elisabeth Förster-Nietzsche published it in 1901, the year after he died, in an order his surviving plans don't support. Mazzino Montinari, who later helped publish the notebooks in the order Nietzsche wrote them, called the book a forgery.
Who held the papers
After his 1889 breakdown Nietzsche never wrote again. His sister ran the Nietzsche Archive in Weimar and controlled what readers saw.
Why she did it
Scholars still argue. Some blame her nationalism and antisemitism, while others say she mostly wanted to protect him and her place beside him.
Sources
- The Joyful Wisdom (The Gay Science), translated by Thomas Common, Project Gutenberg
- Friedrich Nietzsche, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- God is dead, Wikipedia
- Übermensch, Wikipedia
- Friedrich Nietzsche, Wikipedia
- Elisabeth Förster-Nietzsche, Wikipedia





