Philosophy & Ethics · Society & justice
Karl Marx
Marx argued that how a society produces things shapes its laws, ideas and conflicts. See his account of history, of work under capitalism and of class, and how to tell his ideas from the regimes that claimed them.

What you will learn
- Explain Marx's claim that how a society produces things shapes its laws and beliefs
- Explain why Marx thought one economic system eventually gives way to another
- Describe the ways Marx said wage workers are alienated from their work
- Explain how Marx's theory of surplus value accounts for profit
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
How making a living shapes everything else
Karl Marx was born in Trier, in Prussia, on 5 May 1818. He became a radical journalist, and in 1843 the government banned his newspaper after the Russian tsar complained about it.
Then came years on the move. Marx lived in Paris and Brussels, was ordered out of Cologne in 1849 and was expelled from Paris again. In June 1849 he reached London, where he stayed for the rest of his life. His family lived in deep poverty while he studied in the British Museum's reading room. He died there in 1883, a man without citizenship of any country.
His central idea starts with how people make a living. Marx called the tools, land and human skill a society works with its productive forces. Around them grows an economic structure, the set of relations that decides who owns things and who works for whom.
On top of that structure sit a society's laws and political institutions, which he called the superstructure. Its religious, moral and philosophical beliefs follow the economic structure too. "The hand-mill gives you society with the feudal lord," Marx wrote, and "the steam-mill, society with the industrial capitalist."
Why do systems change? Marx thought productive forces tend to grow over time, as people find better tools and skills. An economic structure lasts as long as it helps them grow.
When it starts to hold them back, he said it fetters them, like a chain on a growing limb. Then it gets overthrown and replaced by a structure better suited to the new forces. That's how he read the end of feudalism, the system of lords and serfs, and the rise of capitalism.
Scholars still argue over how to read this theory. The careful reconstruction above comes from the philosopher G. A. Cohen, and his critics say it leaves too little room for class struggle, which many readers see as central to Marx.
Try to recallAccording to Karl Marx, why does one economic system, such as feudalism, eventually give way to another?
Productive forces tend to grow over time. An economic system survives while it helps them grow, but once it fetters that growth it is overthrown. A system suited to the new forces replaces it, as capitalism replaced feudalism.
For Marx, how people make a living shapes their laws and beliefs. A society's economic system lasts only as long as it helps production grow.
Lessons in this topic
How making a living shapes everything else
Follow Marx from Prussia into London exile, and learn his claim that the way people produce things explains their politics and beliefs.
What Marx thought was wrong with wage work
Learn what Marx meant by alienation, and how his theory of surplus value claims to show where profit comes from.
The Communist Manifesto and the revolution that didn't come
See what the Communist Manifesto predicted about class struggle, what happened instead, and how Marx's followers changed the theory.
Marx and the states built in his name
Learn how little Marx said about a communist future, and weigh the debate over his responsibility for twentieth-century communist states.
Three quick stories from this topic
The Manifesto's praise
The Communist Manifesto praises capitalism as the most productive force in history
In scarcely 100 years, it says, the bourgeoisie created more productive power than all earlier generations together. Marx and Engels thought that very power would gather workers in factories and bring about capitalism's fall.
All that is solid
The pamphlet says old customs and fixed relations are swept away, and that all that is solid melts into air.
Its own grave-diggers
Factories pack workers together, so they organize. That's why the Manifesto says the bourgeoisie produces its own grave-diggers.
Marx, not a Marxist
Karl Marx once said that if anything was certain, it was that he wasn't a Marxist
He said it to his son-in-law Paul Lafargue, about what was being called Marxism in France. Engels passed the line on in an 1882 letter. Marx was disowning followers whose version of his ideas he didn't recognize.
A theory with many owners
In the twentieth century, revolutions in dozens of countries called themselves Marxist, each claiming to read him correctly.
The blame question
Opponents blame Marx for those states' crimes. Others separate his ideas from the people who reshaped them.
Profit as unpaid hours
Marx argued that every bit of profit comes from hours workers aren't paid for
An employer buys your ability to work for a day at the cost of keeping you alive. If that takes four hours of labor to cover, everything you make after those four hours is surplus value, and the employer keeps it.
The only commodity that grows
Marx held that labor power is the one thing an employer buys that produces more value than it costs.
Still contested
Critics say real prices don't follow labor time. If the labor theory of value fails, Robert Nozick argued, so does Marx's idea of exploitation.
Sources
- Karl Marx, Wikipedia
- Karl Marx, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- The Poverty of Philosophy, chapter 2, Marxists Internet Archive
- The Communist Manifesto, by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, Project Gutenberg
- Letter from Engels to Eduard Bernstein, 2 to 3 November 1882, Marxists Internet Archive




