Philosophy & Ethics · Society & justice
The social contract
Why should anyone obey a government? Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau each answered with a story about people agreeing to be ruled. Compare their three versions and the objection that nobody ever signed.

What you will learn
- Explain why Hobbes thought life without government would be a war of all against all
- Explain why Hobbes wanted an absolute sovereign, and when he said obedience ends
- Explain why Locke's people leave a state of nature that already has rights and law
- Describe when Locke says the people may remove a government
Lesson 1 of 4 · 5 min
Hobbes and the war of all against all
Say the police, courts and army of your country vanished overnight. Thomas Hobbes, an English philosopher born in 1588, thought he knew what would happen next, and his answer still shapes arguments about why we obey governments.
Hobbes wrote Leviathan during the English Civil War, which ran from 1642 to 1651, and published it in 1651. In it he imagined a state of nature, his name for life with no government at all.
His starting point is that people are roughly equal. Nobody is so strong that others can't band together and kill him while he sleeps. So nobody can rely on strength alone to stay safe.
Now add scarce goods. Two neighbors want the same field, and each fears the other will take it. Even when nobody is fighting, both must stay on guard. Striking first starts to look sensible. Hobbes called the result a war of all against all.
In that condition, he wrote, there's no farming, trade or building, because nobody can count on keeping what they make. The life of man is "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short."
Hobbes's way out is a covenant, a binding agreement. Each person promises the others to give up their right to all things and to obey one sovereign. The sovereign can be a single ruler or an assembly. Fear drives the deal, and Hobbes saw nothing wrong with that.
The sovereign must be absolute, meaning undivided and unlimited. Hobbes argued that a government with divided power tends to collapse into civil war. Since almost any government beats civil war, people should accept even a harsh one.
The title names a sea monster from the Book of Job. On the book's front page, a giant crowned figure holds a sword and a bishop's staff. Its body is built from over 300 tiny people, which makes the point that the state is its subjects joined into one.
Try to recallWhy did Thomas Hobbes think the sovereign's power should be absolute, and when did he say a subject's duty to obey ends?
Hobbes thought divided power tends to collapse into civil war, which is worse than almost any government, so the sovereign should be undivided and unlimited. The duty to obey ends when the sovereign can no longer protect you, and you keep a right to resist when your own life is threatened.
Hobbes's contract trades freedom for safety. People agree out of fear to obey an absolute sovereign, and the deal holds as long as that sovereign protects them.
Lessons in this topic
Hobbes and the war of all against all
See why Thomas Hobbes thought life without government would be a constant war, and why he wanted one absolute ruler to end it.
Locke and the government you can replace
Learn why John Locke thought people have rights before any government, and when he said they may take power back.
Rousseau and the freedom of making your own laws
See how Jean-Jacques Rousseau tried to make obeying the law the same as obeying yourself, and why one of his lines still alarms readers.
Who signed the social contract
Weigh David Hume's objection that no real agreement founded any government, and later critics who ask who was left out of the deal.
Three quick stories from this topic
Hume's sleeping sailor
Hume compared staying in your country to staying on a ship you were carried onto asleep
Locke had argued that living in a country counts as quietly agreeing to its rule. Hume replied that a poor worker who speaks no foreign language can't really leave, any more than a sleeper aboard ship can leap into the ocean.
No signature anywhere
Hume also noted that almost all governments began in usurpation or conquest, with no fair consent from the people.
Why obey anyway
Hume still thought people should usually obey, because society could not otherwise survive. He just didn't think a promise was the reason.
The giant made of people
The giant on the front of Hobbes's Leviathan is built from over 300 tiny people
The 1651 image shows a crowned figure rising over a landscape with a sword in one hand and a bishop's staff in the other. Its torso and arms are packed with small people, all facing away. The state, Hobbes meant, is its subjects joined into one.
A monster from the Bible
The title names a sea monster from the Book of Job. A Latin line from Job above the giant says no power on earth compares with him.
Why one giant
Hobbes argued that only an undivided sovereign could keep people out of a war of all against all. One giant holding both sword and staff stands for that undivided power.
Free only at elections
Rousseau said the English were free only while they were electing parliament
As soon as the members are elected, he wrote, slavery overtakes the people. For Rousseau, any law the people hadn't ratified in person was null and void, so handing lawmaking to deputies meant giving up self-rule.
Born free, in chains
The Social Contract of 1762 opens by saying man is born free and everywhere in chains. Rousseau asked what could make those chains rightful.
Laws you make yourself
His answer was the general will. Obeying laws that citizens make together for everyone, he argued, is obeying yourself.
Sources
- Hobbes's Moral and Political Philosophy, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Leviathan (Hobbes book), Wikipedia
- Of the Original Contract, in Essays, Moral, Political, and Literary, Hume Texts Online
- Locke's Political Philosophy, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- The Social Contract and Discourses, translated by G. D. H. Cole, Project Gutenberg
- Jean Jacques Rousseau, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy





