Geography & the World · Borders & territories

Shared territories and the land nobody claims

Some territories are ruled by two states at once, and one patch of desert is claimed by none. See how shared rule works, why it rarely lasts, and why Egypt and Sudan both refuse Bir Tawil.

4 short lessons · about 20 minutes · 6 sources · updated November 2026

A valley divided by a line with two figures on either side, and the same valley undivided with both figures together.

What you will learn

  • Define a condominium and tell it apart from a divided territory
  • Explain why so few condominia have existed
  • Trace how the 1899 and 1902 boundaries together leave an area nobody claims
  • Explain why neither state simply claims the leftover land

Lesson 1 of 4 · 5 min

What happens when two countries share one territory

Before you readBritain and France ruled the islands now called Vanuatu together for 74 years. How were the police and prisons run?

Correct.Not quite. The answer is Each power ran its own.

The islands had two police forces and two prison systems, plus two currencies and two school systems. This lesson is about territories that two states rule together, and why they are rare.

For 74 years, the Pacific islands now called Vanuatu had two police forces, two currencies, two school systems and two prison systems. Britain and France ruled them together from 1906 to 1980. Cynics called the arrangement the Pandemonium.

Its proper name was a condominium. In international law, that's a territory over which two or more states formally agree to share power equally. They exercise their rights jointly, without dividing the land into national zones.

That's the opposite of a border. Picture a valley between two countries. Usually a line runs through it, and each state runs its own side. In a condominium there's no line, and both states run the whole valley.

They're rare, but some exist today. Germany and Luxembourg have shared the Moselle River, with its bridges and about 15 islands, since 1816. Bolivia and Peru jointly own the waters of Lake Titicaca. Colombia and Jamaica share a stretch of the Caribbean instead of drawing a sea boundary.

Check yourselfTwo neighboring states agree that each will run one half of a disputed island. Is that a condominium?

Correct.Not quite. The answer is No, because in a condominium both states run the whole island jointly.

A condominium means sharing power equally and exercising rights jointly over the whole territory. Splitting it into national zones gives you an ordinary border, however equal the halves. Canada and Denmark came close to declaring Hans Island a condominium in 2012, then in June 2022 divided the island in half instead.

So why are there so few? Because everything in a condominium needs the partners to agree. An ordinary border survives a bad relationship. Each side carries on running its own half and asks nobody.

A condominium has no such fallback. Every act of government needs a working agreement. When the agreement fails, the only way of getting anything done fails with it.

Many shared territories ended with a line. Britain and the United States shared the Oregon Country from 1818 to 1846, before it was divided between them. Britain and France shared Togoland for just over two years, then partitioned it in 1916.

A looser split of rights went worse. From 1878 Bosnia-Herzegovina stayed Ottoman on paper while Austria-Hungary ran it. When Austria-Hungary annexed it outright in 1908, the great powers protested, and the crisis helped lay the ground for the First World War.

Try to recallWhy is a condominium more fragile than an ordinary border between the same two states?

In a condominium, the states exercise their rights jointly over the whole territory, so every act of government depends on their continuing to cooperate. Once the understanding fails, nothing can be done. An ordinary border survives a bad relationship, because neither side needs the other to act on its own side of the line.

Remember a condominium as the opposite of a border. A border lets two neighbors ignore each other. A condominium makes them agree on everything, which is why they're rare and why many past ones ended in a line.

Lessons in this topic

  1. What happens when two countries share one territory

    A condominium is land that two or more states rule together without dividing it. See how that works in practice and why so few have lasted.

    Essentials · 5 min

  2. Why no country claims Bir Tawil

    Egypt and Sudan each back a different boundary line from colonial times. See how the two lines leave 2,060 square kilometers of desert that neither state will claim.

    Essentials · 5 min

  3. Shared territories, from Pheasant Island to Antarctica

    Compare an island that changes countries twice a year, a lake whose owners disagree about its status and a continent run by treaty. Then see what only looks like sharing.

    Deeper · 5 min

  4. Bir Tawil is unclaimed, but people are there

    No state claims Bir Tawil, yet herders cross it and miners dig it for gold. See why sovereignty and use of the land are separate questions, and how to weigh claims about the place.

    Deeper · 5 min

Three quick stories from this topic

The land neither country wants

Egypt and Sudan each insist that 2,060 square kilometers of desert belong to the other

Claiming Bir Tawil would mean accepting the boundary line that gives the neighbor the Halaib Triangle, which is ten times bigger and reaches the sea. So both countries claim Halaib, and neither claims Bir Tawil.

Each area goes with a different line

Both states claim the Halaib Triangle. Neither claims Bir Tawil, which is only a tenth the size and has no permanent settlements or access to the sea.

No legal basis for taking both

There's no basis in international law for either state to claim both territories, and neither will give up Halaib. So 2,060 square kilometers stay unclaimed.

Two of everything

For 74 years Britain and France ran one colony with two police forces and two currencies

The New Hebrides, now Vanuatu, were ruled jointly from 1906 to 1980. Each power kept its own administration, so the islands also had two school systems, two health services and two prison systems. Cynics called the arrangement the Pandemonium.

The name for shared rule

It was a condominium. In international law that's a territory where two or more states formally agree to share power equally and exercise their rights jointly, without splitting it into national zones.

Why condominia are rare

The problem is keeping the states cooperating. Once their understanding fails, the arrangement is likely to become untenable, and many past ones ended in partition.

The island that changes countries

France and Spain hand each other the same small river island every six months

Pheasant Island, in the Bidassoa River, is just over 200 meters long, and nobody lives on it. Spain runs it from February to July and France from August to January. The two kingdoms negotiated a peace treaty there in 1659 and have shared it since.

Lake Constance runs on a disagreement

Austria and Germany say they share a tripartite condominium with Switzerland, though on different grounds. Switzerland says the border runs through the middle, and no treaty settles it.

Antarctica runs on a treaty

It's a de facto condominium of a whole continent, governed by the 29 state parties to the Antarctic Treaty that have consulting status. Only seven of them have territorial claims.

Sources

This topic is part of Where the obvious answer falls short, a guided path through related topics.

  • Enclaves and the border at Baarle

    Baarle is one town made of 30 pieces of Belgium and the Netherlands. See how to read its map, where the patchwork came from, and how two mayors run one set of streets.

    4 lessons · 15 min

  • What makes a country a country

    There's no single official list of countries. Learn the four tests of a state, why the UN has 193 members while other lists run longer, and how a state, a nation and a country differ.

    4 lessons · 16 min

  • How borders are drawn

    Borders follow rivers, ridges, lines of latitude and old treaties. Learn how a line is agreed, marked on the ground and kept, why so many are straight, and what happens when a river border moves.

    4 lessons · 16 min

  • Why flat maps distort the world

    See why flattening a globe always costs something, and how to pick a projection that keeps what your question needs, whether that's area or angles.

    4 lessons · 15 min

  • The continents and regions of the world

    Learn the seven continents and five oceans, why other countries count the continents differently, and how labels like Middle East and Latin America group the world by more than geography.

    4 lessons · 16 min

  • Reading a population pyramid

    Read a chart of a population by age and sex, and follow a generation as it moves up the chart over time. The shape tells you who lives in a place, and other evidence has to explain why.

    4 lessons · 14 min

All geography & the world topics · Take the quiz