Geography & the World · Maps & navigation
Why flat maps distort the world
See why flattening a globe always costs something, and how to pick a projection that keeps what your question needs, whether that's area or angles.

What you will learn
- Explain why flattening a globe introduces distortion.
- Identify area, shape, distance and direction as different map properties.
- Explain what Mercator gains by keeping local angles and how it distorts areas at high latitudes.
- Choose an equal-area projection for comparing relative surface areas.
Lesson 1 of 4 · 3 min
Why every flat map of the world is wrong somewhere
Peel an orange and try to press the peel flat on a table. It tears, or it wrinkles, or it springs back up. Every world map ever drawn has had the same problem. Earth's surface is curved and paper isn't, so something has to stretch or split.
The rule a mapmaker uses to decide what stretches, and where, is called a projection.
Better technology won't solve this. In 1827 the mathematician Carl Friedrich Gauss proved that a sphere's surface can't be laid flat without changing some distances. A perfect flat map is impossible, even of a small region.
A modern projection is a set of equations, and each one moves the distortion somewhere else. None removes it.
A flat map can go wrong in four ways. It can misstate area, how much surface a region covers, or bend shape, the angles around each point. It can misstate the distance between places, or the direction from one to another.
A projection can keep one of these true but never all four. Area and angles even rule each other out. A map that keeps areas right must distort shapes, and a map that keeps angles right must distort areas.
Say you want to compare how much land two countries cover. You need a map that keeps area true, and you have to accept what it does to shapes. On one equal-area world map, Russia covers the right share of the page, but its outline is badly distorted.
And a map that draws every coastline the way you remember it can still get the sizes wrong.
Distortion also isn't spread evenly. A projection typically matches the globe along one or two chosen lines, or around one point, and the error grows as you move away.
So a map's outline tells you little. The projection's name and settings, which a good map states, tell you far more.
Try to recallWhy could a map projection that's useful for comparing areas be a poor choice for judging local shapes?
A projection can keep areas in proportion while distorting shapes or angles. Keeping one geometric property doesn't keep all the others.
Lessons in this topic
Why every flat map of the world is wrong somewhere
A sphere can't be flattened without stretching something. See what a mapmaker has to choose between, and why no equation gets around the choice.
Why Greenland looks as big as Africa on a map
The Mercator map keeps compass angles true and pays for it by inflating everything far from the equator. See how that happens, and what an equal-area map does instead.
Why the shortest flight looks curved on a map
A straight line on a Mercator map is a steady compass course, and it's usually longer than the curve beside it. See what a ruler line means on three kinds of map.
What the fine print on a map tells you
Atlases use world maps that get everything slightly wrong on purpose. See why, and how a map's label shows where it can be trusted.
Three quick stories from this topic
Greenland on the Mercator map
Greenland looks as big as Africa on a Mercator map, but Africa is 14 times larger
Gerardus Mercator drew the map in 1569 for sailors, and it keeps compass angles true. The price is that it stretches lands more and more toward the poles. Greenland's real area is close to that of the Democratic Republic of the Congo.
Equal-area maps make a different choice
They keep relative surface areas true and let shapes and angles distort instead.
Choose the property you need
A question about area needs a map that keeps area true. Familiar outlines don't guarantee that.
Pizza and flat maps
A folded pizza slice stays stiff for the same reason no flat map of Earth is perfect
In 1827 Carl Friedrich Gauss proved that a surface can't change its curvature without stretching. A flat slice bent one way can't also droop the other way. And a sphere can't be laid flat, so every map stretches something.
Gauss's theorem of 1827
Gauss's result is called the Theorema Egregium. It says that bending a surface without stretching it leaves its curvature unchanged.
What it means for maps
A sphere is curved and a page is flat, so flattening the globe must change some distances. A map projection is a choice about which ones.
National Geographic's compromise map
National Geographic chose a world map that gets area, shape and distance all a bit wrong
From 1988 to 1997 the society used the Robinson projection, then replaced it with the Winkel Tripel. Both are compromise projections. They keep no property exactly true, so that nothing ends up badly distorted.
What a compromise projection does
Instead of keeping area or angles exact, a compromise projection spreads the distortion so that nothing is badly wrong. Landmasses look closer in shape and size to the globe than they do on Mercator, which suits maps meant for looking at rather than measuring.
Why textbooks followed
The Winkel Tripel became common in textbooks after the switch. A compromise map is a choice about purpose. When measurements matter, mapmakers choose a projection that preserves the property being measured instead.
Sources
- What are map projections?, Penn State Department of Geography
- Projection properties, Penn State Department of Geography
- Theorema Egregium, Wikimedia Foundation
- Mercator projection, Wikimedia Foundation





