Geography & the World · Borders & territories
What makes a country a country
There's no single official list of countries. Learn the four tests of a state, why the UN has 193 members while other lists run longer, and how a state, a nation and a country differ.

What you will learn
- Name the four tests of a state in the Montevideo Convention and say what each one asks
- Explain the difference between the declarative and constitutive views of recognition
- Explain how a state joins the United Nations and why some states stay outside it
- Explain why lists from the UN, ISO and FIFA give different numbers of countries
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
The four tests a state has to pass
Since 1967, a family has claimed a Second World War sea fort in the North Sea as the Principality of Sealand. It has a flag and a ruler. No country treats it as a state, and the reason is written into a treaty.
In 1933, American states meeting in Montevideo, Uruguay, signed the Montevideo Convention. Its first article lists what a state should have. Lawyers still use it as the standard test.
The four tests are a permanent population, a defined territory, a government, and the capacity to deal with other states. There's no minimum size or headcount. A territory's borders don't even need to be settled.
Each test has a meaning in practice. The government must actually control the land and people. The capacity to deal with others means the state is independent, so no outside power runs its foreign affairs.
Territory has to be real land. Built platforms and uninhabitable places don't count, which is where Sealand fails. The Order of Malta, a Catholic order, is a sovereign body with ties to 115 states. With no territory, it doesn't claim to be a state.
Article 3 of the convention says a state exists whether or not others recognize it. Lawyers call this the declarative theory. Passing the four tests makes you a state.
The older constitutive theory says a state exists only once other states recognize it. The trouble comes when some recognize a place and others don't. Is it then a state for some and not for others?
Real cases sit between the two. Somaliland has had elected governments since 1991. In December 2025, Israel became the only UN member to recognize it. Kosovo declared independence in 2008, and by 2025 it had 110 of 193 UN members' recognition.
Recognition is a political choice. No state has to recognize another, and each uses its own reasons.
Try to recallSomaliland has had its own elected governments since 1991 but almost no recognition. How would the declarative and constitutive theories each judge it?
The declarative theory looks only at the four tests, so a place with people, land, a working government and independence is a state whatever others say. The constitutive theory says a state exists only once others recognize it. With one recognition, Somaliland is barely a state under that view, or a state for Israel alone.
You can name the four Montevideo tests and spot why a sea fort fails them. You can also explain why recognition still splits places like Somaliland and Kosovo, since law and politics give different answers.
Lessons in this topic
The four tests a state has to pass
Learn the four tests international law uses for a state, and why other countries' recognition still decides so much.
193, 195 or 249 countries
Learn how a state joins the United Nations, and why other lists of countries come out longer.
Why so few states hold just one nation
Learn how a state, a nation and a nation-state differ, and why the Kurds are a nation without a state.
England, Britain and the United Kingdom
Learn how one state holds four countries, and why they play football apart but go to the Olympics as one team.
Three quick stories from this topic
The nation without a state
Up to 45 million Kurds live in a homeland split among four states
Their region crosses Turkey, Iran, Iraq and Syria. They are often called the largest ethnic group with no state, though they have self-rule inside Iraq.
A promise in 1920
The Treaty of Sevres made room for a Kurdish state after the Ottoman Empire was broken up. It was never ratified.
Replaced in 1923
The Treaty of Lausanne set Turkey's borders, and the Allies dropped the push for Kurdish statehood.
A sovereign without land
The Order of Malta has ties with 115 states and issues passports, but it has no land
This Catholic order is treated as a sovereign body under international law and keeps embassies abroad. With no territory, it fails one of the four tests of a state.
What it has
The order issues its own passports, coins and stamps. Its two headquarters buildings in Rome are treated as outside Italian control.
What it lacks
A state needs a permanent population, territory, a government and independence. The order has no land, so it doesn't claim to be a state.
Switzerland's late entry
Switzerland only became a full member of the United Nations in 2002
It had sent a permanent observer since 1946, the first state to do so. The observer system grew out of that Swiss arrangement, so it began with a state choosing to stay outside.
How joining works
A new member needs a Security Council recommendation without a veto, then a two-thirds vote in the General Assembly.
Still outside
The Holy See has been an observer state since 1964 and chose not to join. Palestine became an observer state in 2012.
Sources
- Principality of Sealand, Wikipedia
- Montevideo Convention, Wikipedia
- Sovereign state, Wikipedia
- Sovereign Military Order of Malta, Wikipedia
- List of sovereign states, Wikipedia
- Somaliland, Wikipedia
- Kosovo, Wikipedia
- Kurds, Wikipedia
- Member States, United Nations
- About Permanent Observers, United Nations





