Engineering & Inventions · Design & invention

The Tacoma Narrows collapse and what it taught

In 1940 the Tacoma Narrows Bridge twisted itself apart in a 42 mph wind. See what the famous film can't show, how a steady wind fed the twist, and how engineers tested the fix.

4 short lessons · about 15 minutes · 5 sources · updated November 2026

What you will learn

  • Distinguish an observation of motion from an explanation of its mechanism.
  • Explain why the Tacoma Narrows failure exposed a gap in how engineers treated wind and motion.
  • Describe how structural motion and aerodynamic force feed back on each other in flutter.
  • Tell that mechanism apart from simple forcing timed from outside.

Lesson 1 of 4 · 3 min

What the famous Tacoma Narrows film can't show

Before you readThe famous film of the Tacoma Narrows Bridge twisting apart in 1940 is often shown on video. By how much do most copies play the twisting too fast?

Correct.Not quite. The answer is About 50%.

Most copies play the twisting about 50% too fast. This lesson is about what the film shows and what it cannot.

The Tacoma Narrows Bridge opened in July 1940. Four months later, on November 7, it twisted itself apart and fell into Puget Sound. Photographers from a Tacoma camera shop caught it on film.

A film records motion, and it doesn't record forces. Most copies don't even get the motion right. They play the twisting about 50% too fast, because the film was later converted to video at the wrong speed. To explain the collapse, investigators had to work out what the wind and the steel were doing to each other.

The film shows two different motions. For months the deck had bounced in vertical waves, rising and falling along its length without rotating. Workers building it chewed lemons against the nausea.

At 10:03 on the morning of November 7, the motion changed. A cable band at mid-span slipped on the north cable, leaving that cable in two unequal segments. The thin deck began to twist, one edge rising as the other dropped. That's torsion. Within minutes the roadway was tilting as far as 45 degrees.

The investigating board called this switch the turning point. The film shows it. It can't show the slipped band or the air pressure behind it.

The explanation came from investigation and later analysis. Wind broke away at the deck's solid side and formed vortices, swirls of air that lifted and twisted it. Once the deck was twisting, its motion began to control the swirls. Each twist brought on a larger one. Engineers call that torsional flutter.

None of that is visible on film. People often say the bridge fell to "resonance," but that word only names a pattern of growing motion. It doesn't say what fed energy into the bridge.

Check yourselfWhich statement about the Tacoma Narrows collapse is an observation rather than an explanation of its mechanism?

Correct.Not quite. The answer is The deck developed large twisting motion before it fell..

Twisting describes what happened, and you can see it on film. The other two statements say why the motion grew. They're claims about mechanism, and they need evidence about aerodynamic forces and the structure's response, which the film alone doesn't supply.

The wreckage records the violence. The main cables were tossed 100 feet into the air. Where the band had loosened, the north cable broke more than 350 wires. The towers were left twisted and bent.

A federal panel, the Carmody Board, reported in March 1941. It named the principal cause as the bridge's "excessive flexibility." It also found that the solid girder and deck had acted like an airfoil, a wing shape, creating lift and drag in the wind.

The designer wasn't careless. Leon Moisseiff's plans fully met the accepted theory of the time. The trouble was a blind spot across the profession. The historian David Billington wrote that among suspension bridge engineers "there seemed to be almost no recognition that wind created vertical movement at all."

Designers stiffened bridges against traffic and treated wind as minor. Yet flexible spans had failed in wind in the 1800s. Four months after the collapse, a Columbia professor wrote that such failures "had simply been forgotten." So the useful question is which behavior the methods missed.

The collapse didn't make the earlier theory worthless. Engineers extended it to cover the way wind and motion affect each other. Since 1940 they've built suspension bridges that are streamlined, stiffened against twisting, or both.

Testing a model in a wind tunnel is now routine. Washington State's transportation department says the US government requires it for any bridge built with federal funds.

So the film is where an explanation starts. It tells you what moved and when. The reason came from the wreckage, the wind tunnel and the math.

Try to recallBefore 1940, suspension bridge designers stiffened decks against traffic and treated wind as minor. What did the Tacoma Narrows collapse show they had to study as well?

How wind and a moving deck act on each other. The flexible deck let the wind lift and twist it, and the twisting then changed the airflow. Designing for traffic loads didn't cover that.

Lessons in this topic

  1. What the famous Tacoma Narrows film can't show

    The 1940 collapse of the Tacoma Narrows Bridge is on film, yet the film can't say why the bridge fell. Learn to tell what was seen from what caused it.

    Essentials · 3 min

  2. How can a steady wind make a bridge twist harder?

    A steady wind has no rhythm, yet the Tacoma Narrows deck swung in one. See how a twisting deck shapes the force that twists it, and why that isn't resonance.

    Essentials · 4 min

  3. How engineers tested the fix for Tacoma Narrows

    A fix has to be tested against the failure it's meant to stop. See why the right test lets a model move, and how the 1950 replacement bridge was designed in a wind tunnel.

    Deeper · 3 min

  4. Why the Tacoma Narrows deck twisted so easily

    Read the proportions that made the 1940 bridge so flexible, then weigh the claim that a rival design would still be standing.

    Deeper · 5 min

Three quick stories from this topic

The film runs fast

Most copies of the Tacoma Narrows collapse film show the bridge twisting 50% too fast

The camera ran at 16 frames a second, but the film was later converted to video as if shot at 24. On screen the deck twists 18 times a minute. A professor timing it with a stopwatch that morning counted 12.

Noticed 75 years later

Physicists reported the mismatch in Physics Today in 2015, after comparing the swings on video with the stopwatch record from November 7, 1940.

What a film can't hold

Even at the right speed, footage records motion and no forces. The cause had to come from the wreckage, wind-tunnel models and analysis.

The warning from the model

A wind-tunnel model showed the Tacoma Narrows Bridge could twist apart days before it did

Professor F. B. Farquharson finished his model tests in early November 1940 and blamed the solid girders, which caught the wind. The state was drafting a contract for wind deflectors when the bridge fell on November 7.

Bouncing from the start

Workers noticed the deck bouncing in May 1940, before the bridge opened, and some chewed lemons against nausea. The roadway moved in winds as light as 4 miles an hour.

Why a wind tunnel

A model that's free to move in moving air can show wind and motion feeding each other. A motionless model loaded with weights can't.

Forgotten, not new

Engineers in 1940 had forgotten that wind had wrecked suspension bridges before

Four months after the Tacoma Narrows collapse, Columbia professor J. K. Finch reviewed over a century of suspension bridge failures. The bridge's wild motion looked new and strange to modern engineers, he wrote, but such troubles "had simply been forgotten."

A generation's blind spot

According to WSDOT, designers in the 1930s believed earlier failures came from heavy traffic and poor workmanship, and they treated wind as minor. Yet John Roebling had deliberately designed the 1883 Brooklyn Bridge to be stable against wind. The last major suspension bridge failure, the Niagara-Clifton Bridge, had fallen in 1889, five decades earlier.

Why memory is part of engineering

Finch's title spoke of the evolution and decay of the stiffening truss. Knowledge that isn't carried forward can be lost as designs grow lighter and more slender. The failure put aerodynamic stability back on the profession's checklist, alongside the deflection theory, which it supplemented without replacing.

Sources

This topic is part of Measure, design and learn from failure, a guided path through related topics.

  • Why a system with backups still fails

    Every defense has holes, and the holes move. See why an accident needs several of them to line up, how spare parts make failure look almost impossible on paper, and how a backup can leave a system less safe.

    4 lessons · 21 min

  • How engineers design things

    Engineering starts with a vague want and a list of limits. See how engineers turn it into testable requirements, weigh trade-offs, test and revise, and decide when a design is good enough.

    4 lessons · 16 min

  • Thomas Edison

    Edison didn't invent the light bulb alone, and his bigger invention was a lab that turned out inventions to order. See what his team built, how the bulb became a system, and where his fame overshoots.

    4 lessons · 16 min

  • Reinforced concrete and the steel hidden inside it

    Concrete cracks when it's pulled, and a little steel in the right place fixes that. See why the two materials work together, how a beam is made to sag before it fails, and what rust does in the end.

    4 lessons · 23 min

  • Why a rocket throws most of itself away

    Reaching orbit takes a speed no single tank can buy. The way around it is to build a rocket that turns into a smaller rocket, twice.

    4 lessons · 24 min

  • Why sampling too slowly creates signals that aren't there

    Measure a signal often enough and the samples hold all of it. Measure a little too slowly and its fast parts come back disguised as slow ones, with nothing in the data to give them away.

    4 lessons · 23 min

All engineering & inventions topics · Take the quiz