Religion & Worldviews · Secular worldviews
Freethought and the history of atheism
Doubt about the gods is as old as belief. Meet India's Charvaka materialists, Greek skeptics, the first open atheists of the 1700s, the freethinkers of the 1800s and the New Atheists.

What you will learn
- Describe how the Charvaka school of India argued against gods and an afterlife
- Explain how Greek thinkers questioned the gods and why "atheist" worked as an accusation
- Explain how blasphemy laws and the stigma of the word kept unbelief hidden in early modern Europe
- Describe how the first open atheists appeared in the 1700s and why Hume stayed cautious
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
Doubting the gods in ancient India and Greece
Smoke rises from behind a hill. Most people would say there's a fire. An ancient Indian school called the Charvakas said you can't be sure, because smoke can have other causes. Only what you perceive directly counts as sure knowledge.
From that strict rule they drew bold conclusions. You can't perceive gods, rebirth or karma, so there's no reason to believe in them. Everything that makes up a person lives in the body, and death ends it.
They mocked the priests too. India's sacred hymns, the Vedas, were incoherent, they said, and useful mainly as a living for priests. Opponents painted them as pleasure-seekers, a picture some modern scholars say the evidence doesn't support.
The school took shape in the first millennium BCE and may have lasted until the 1100s. Its own books are lost. Almost everything we know comes from rival schools that quoted the Charvakas in order to refute them.
Around 500 BCE the Greek thinker Xenophanes noticed that people make gods in their own image. If cows and horses had hands, he said, horses would draw gods like horses and cows like cows.
Others went further. Protagoras wrote that he couldn't say whether the gods exist or not. Diagoras of Melos, known in antiquity as "the Atheist", was charged with impiety in Athens and fled.
In early Greek, atheos meant ungodly, an insult more than a belief. Cities treated their gods as the foundation of the state, so rejecting them could be a capital crime. The charge made a handy weapon against enemies. Socrates, devout by every account, was executed partly for not believing in the city's gods.
The label kept moving. Romans called early Christians atheists because they refused to honor the Roman gods. Epicurus taught that the gods exist but ignore humans, and his critics still called his followers atheists.
Try to recallWhy was "atheist" more often an accusation than a self-description in the ancient Greek and Roman world?
Cities saw their gods as the foundation of the state, so rejecting them could be punished, even by death. The word atheos began as an insult meaning ungodly and was used against enemies, even devout people like Socrates and early Christians. Few would claim a label that could get them exiled or killed.
Indian Charvakas rejected gods and an afterlife because they couldn't be perceived, and Greek thinkers questioned the gods openly. Calling yourself an atheist, though, was risky, because the word began as a charge.
Lessons in this topic
Doubting the gods in ancient India and Greece
Meet the Charvaka thinkers of India who trusted only what they could perceive, and the Greek skeptics for whom "atheist" was a dangerous charge.
When denying God could cost your life
See how blasphemy laws kept unbelief hidden in early modern Europe, and how the first open atheists appeared in the 1700s while Hume kept a careful line.
Unbelief goes public in the 1800s
See how Marx explained religion, how Huxley gave doubters a new word, and how Bradlaugh and Ingersoll turned unbelief into a public cause.
The New Atheists and their critics
See what four bestselling authors argued against religion after 2001, and why both believers and fellow atheists pushed back.
Three quick stories from this topic
The last blasphemy execution
In 1697 Edinburgh executed a 20-year-old student for blasphemy
Fellow students testified that Thomas Aikenhead called theology "ill-invented nonsense" and mocked the Bible. No lawyer spoke for him at his trial. He was the last person in Britain put to death for blasphemy.
What a defense might have said
The prosecutor later said a defense lawyer could have argued these were rash words that he regretted, which might have saved him.
A changing century
Less than a century later, d'Holbach could deny God in print in France, though he still hid his name.
Elected but shut out
Voters re-elected the atheist Charles Bradlaugh four times while Parliament kept him out
Northampton first elected him in 1880. The Commons refused to let him affirm or swear the religious oath, and at one point held him in a cell under Big Ben. A new Speaker finally let him take the oath in 1886.
Why the oath mattered
Members had to swear an oath to God before taking their seats. Bradlaugh wanted to make a solemn promise instead.
His own law
Two years after taking his seat, his Oaths Act of 1888 gave every member of Parliament the right to affirm.
The atheist's turnips
A Greek poet called "the Atheist" reportedly cooked turnips over a chopped-up Heracles
Diagoras of Melos lived in the 400s BCE. The story says he broke up a wooden statue of the hero-god Heracles for firewood. Athens charged him with impiety, and he fled with a reward offered for his capture.
A story, not a record
Little is known for sure about what Diagoras believed. Anecdotes like this one show how ancient writers remembered him.
Politics too
Diagoras came from Melos, which Athens had conquered brutally in 416 BCE. Being a Melian may have made him a target as well.
Sources
- Charvaka, Wikipedia
- History of atheism, Wikipedia
- Diagoras of Melos, Wikipedia
- Thomas Aikenhead, Wikipedia
- Charles Bradlaugh, Wikipedia
- Our story, National Secular Society





