Religion & Worldviews · Secular worldviews
Is the world becoming less religious?
Sociologists once expected modern life to make religion fade. See why, where the forecast came true, where it failed, and what goes first when faith does fade.

What you will learn
- Explain why early sociologists expected science and modern institutions to shrink religion
- Describe why many sociologists thought religious variety would weaken faith
- Describe the evidence that Western Europe has become much less religious
- Explain why sub-Saharan Africa and the United States complicate the forecast
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
Why sociologists expected religion to fade
In 1919 the German sociologist Max Weber gave a lecture in Munich called Science as a Vocation. Modern people, he said, believe they can in principle master all things by calculation. He called the result the disenchantment of the world.
Say a storm flattens your wheat. A farmer centuries ago might ask what he'd done to anger heaven. A farmer today checks the forecast and calls the insurer. Weber's point was that each new explanation leaves less room for mysterious forces.
Karl Marx, Sigmund Freud and Émile Durkheim also expected modern societies to grow less religious. The secularization thesis is the name for this forecast. As a society modernizes, religion loses its hold on public life and on people's minds.
A second force is called differentiation. Over time, schooling and help for the poor moved from churches and families to the state. Religion had fewer jobs to do. Harvard began as a mainly religious college and became a secular university, with its religious side kept in a divinity school.
A third idea concerns pluralism, many faiths living side by side. In a village with one church, its teaching can feel like plain fact. Everyone you know shares it, so no one has to defend it.
The American sociologist Peter Berger argued that modern life breaks this up. With many faiths and secular views around you, no belief system is simply given. You have to choose your own, and a chosen belief feels less certain than one nobody questions.
For decades this was the standard view. Pluralism undermines faith, it said. Science, the state and religious variety all pushed in the same direction, toward less religion.
Try to recallWhy did many sociologists think that living among many faiths would weaken religious belief?
When everyone around you shares one faith, it feels like plain fact and no one has to defend it. Among many faiths and secular views, belief becomes a personal choice. A chosen belief feels less certain, so faith was expected to weaken.
The secularization thesis rested on three forces. Science explained the world, the state took over the church's jobs, and pluralism turned faith into a choice. Together they predicted steadily less religious modern societies.
Lessons in this topic
Why sociologists expected religion to fade
See the forces that early sociologists thought would shrink religion in modern societies, from science to the welfare state to a crowd of competing faiths.
Where the forecast came true and where it didn't
Compare emptying churches in Western Europe with booming faith in sub-Saharan Africa, and see why the United States has puzzled sociologists for decades.
Why religion holds on in some places
Weigh two explanations for faith that refused to fade, competition between churches and the insecurity of daily life, and see how birth rates keep the world religious.
Can you believe without belonging?
Separate believing, belonging and practicing, test the idea that belief outlasts the pews, and see why religious change runs through generations.
Three quick stories from this topic
Churchgoing in 1776
Only about 17% of Americans belonged to a church in 1776, by one estimate
Sociologists Roger Finke and Rodney Stark built the figure from historical records. By their count, membership rose to 34% by 1850 and 59% by 1952, climbing as the country grew richer.
Rising, not falling
Membership climbed while the country modernized, the opposite of what the secularization thesis predicted.
The market explanation
Finke and Stark credit competition between churches. A 2001 review found weak evidence that religious variety raises churchgoing in general.
Africa's Christian boom
Sub-Saharan Africa went from about 7 million Christians in 1900 to 470 million in 2010
That's almost a 70-fold rise by the Pew Research Center's estimate, and Muslims there grew more than 20-fold. By 2020 the region held 30.7% of the world's Christians, more than Europe's 22.3%.
Small minorities in 1900
At the start of the century, both Christians and Muslims were relatively small minorities in the region.
Against the forecast
Religion grew fastest in the century when sociologists expected modern life to make it fade.
Britain's empty pews
In Britain, Christians who rarely go to church outnumber churchgoers three to one
In a 2017 Pew survey, 55% of British adults were Christians who attend a few times a year at most, against 18% who attend monthly. Across Western Europe, most such Christians still say they believe in God.
Across Western Europe
Non-practicing Christians were the largest group in every country Pew surveyed except Italy.
Believing without belonging?
Grace Davie named this pattern in 1994. Later British research found belief falling about as fast as churchgoing.
Sources
- Max Weber, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Secularization, Wikipedia
- Peter L. Berger, Wikipedia
- Religious Pluralism and Religious Participation, Annual Review of Sociology (Chaves and Gorski, 2001), via Duke Scholars
- History of religion in the United States, Wikipedia
- Theory of religious economy, Wikipedia
- Tolerance and Tension: Islam and Christianity in Sub-Saharan Africa, executive summary, Pew Research Center
- The World's Religious Groups: How Their Sizes Changed from 2010 to 2020 | Pew Research Center, Pew Research Center
- Being Christian in Western Europe, Pew Research Center





