Politics & Law · Rights & constitutions
How written and unwritten constitutions differ
Compare the UK's uncodified constitution with codified ones in Germany, Ireland and the US, and see what happens when key rules are only conventions.

What you will learn
- Tell a codified constitution apart from an uncodified one
- Name the main sources of the UK's uncodified constitution
- Explain what a constitutional convention is, with UK examples
- Explain why the UK Supreme Court wouldn't enforce the Sewel convention in 2017
Lesson 1 of 4 · 5 min
What makes a constitution codified
You can go and look at the US Constitution. The handwritten parchment is on display at the National Archives in Washington. Ask to see the United Kingdom's constitution and there's nothing to show you.
Most countries are like the US. Their core rules sit in one document that ranks above every other law. Germany has had its Basic Law since 1949 and Ireland its constitution since 1937. A constitution like these is called codified.
The UK is one of the exceptions, and New Zealand and Israel have no single constitutional text either. In 2017 the UK Supreme Court said that, unlike most countries, the UK has no constitution "in the sense of a single coherent code of fundamental law which prevails over all other sources of law."
People often call the UK's constitution unwritten, but that's misleading. Most of its rules are written down, in Acts of Parliament and court judgments. What's missing is one master text that gathers the main rules and outranks the rest. So the precise word is uncodified.
So where do the UK's rules live? The Cabinet Manual, the government's own guide to how it works, lists the kinds of source. First come statutes, such as Magna Carta in 1215, the Bill of Rights 1689 and the Human Rights Act 1998. Next are judicial decisions by the senior courts.
The royal prerogative, the leftover power of the Crown, is now exercised mostly by ministers or on their advice. Then there are conventions, which the manual defines as "rules of constitutional practice that are regarded as binding in operation but not in law." European and international law also "inform and influence" the constitution.
These sources don't carry equal weight. Statute sits on top because of parliamentary sovereignty, the principle that Acts of Parliament are the supreme source of UK law. Judges can't develop the common law in a way that contradicts an Act, the Supreme Court said in 2017. And Acts have cut back or abolished most of the Crown's old prerogative powers.
Try to recallName three kinds of source that make up the UK's uncodified constitution, according to the Cabinet Manual.
The Cabinet Manual lists statutes such as the Bill of Rights 1689 and the Human Rights Act 1998, judicial decisions by the senior courts, and conventions, which are rules regarded as binding in practice but not in law. The royal prerogative and European and international law count too.
So the UK does have a constitution, and nearly all of it is written down. It just isn't in one place, and no part of it outranks an Act of Parliament. The oddest pieces are the conventions, which everyone follows and no court enforces.
Lessons in this topic
What makes a constitution codified
A codified constitution keeps a country's core rules in one supreme text, which the UK lacks, so its constitutional rules come from several other sources.
What happens when a convention isn't law
Some of the UK's most important rules are conventions that bind only in practice, and in 2017 the UK Supreme Court refused to enforce one of them, the Sewel convention.
How hard it is to change a constitution
The US, Germany and Ireland all make their constitutions hard to amend, while the UK Parliament can change constitutional rules like any other law.
Should the UK write down its constitution?
Weigh the arguments for and against giving the UK a codified constitution, including the middle path the Human Rights Act 1998 takes.
Three quick stories from this topic
Germany's unamendable clause
Parts of Germany's constitution can't be changed even if every lawmaker votes for it
Article 79 of the Basic Law calls "inadmissible" any amendment touching human dignity, the democratic and federal state, or the division of the country into states. Other changes need two-thirds of both chambers. For these, no majority is big enough.
Everything else
Other amendments need a law that expressly changes the text, backed by two-thirds of Bundestag members and two-thirds of Bundesrat votes.
The protected core
Article 1 opens with "Human dignity shall be inviolable." Article 20 declares Germany "a democratic and social federal state."
The unwritten prime minister rule
No Act of Parliament says who gets to be the UK's prime minister
By convention, the job goes to the leader of the party with a majority in the House of Commons, and the Sovereign makes the appointment. The government's own Cabinet Manual describes conventions as rules that are binding "in operation but not in law."
More rules like it
No monarch has refused royal assent to a bill since the Scottish Militia Bill in 1708. That's a convention too, and nothing in statute requires it.
No court will enforce one
In 2017 the UK Supreme Court said judges are "neither the parents nor the guardians of political conventions." A convention's force is political.
The promise that wasn't binding
The UK Parliament wrote a promise into law in 2016, and judges ruled it wasn't binding
The promise was that Westminster "will not normally" pass laws on Scottish matters without the Scottish Parliament's consent. In 2017 all 11 Supreme Court justices held that those cautious words kept it a political convention, which judges don't enforce.
What it says
Since May 23, 2016, the Scotland Act 1998 has said the UK Parliament "will not normally legislate with regard to devolved matters without the consent of the Scottish Parliament."
Why courts stay out
The court said the words "it is recognised" and "will not normally" showed Parliament meant to keep it a political convention, which judges don't police.
Sources
- The Constitution of the United States: A Transcription | National Archives, US National Archives
- Basic Law for the Federal Republic of Germany, Gesetze im Internet, translation in cooperation with the Language Service of the German Bundestag
- Constitution of Ireland, Irish Statute Book
- R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union [2017] UKSC 5, judgment, The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom
- The Cabinet Manual: A guide to laws, conventions and rules on the operation of government, UK Cabinet Office, GOV.UK
- Uncodified constitution - Wikipedia, Wikipedia
- Constitution of the United Kingdom - Wikipedia, Wikipedia
- R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union [2017] UKSC 5, press summary, The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom
- Scotland Act 1998, section 28, legislation.gov.uk





