Politics & Law · Everyday & business law
When carelessness becomes negligence
Find out what negligence means in law, from a snail in a Scottish bottle of ginger beer to a US judge's formula, and see how US states split the blame when both sides were careless.

What you will learn
- Explain how US law defines negligence and what the reasonable-person standard asks
- Name the five elements usually needed to prove negligence in the US
- Explain what happened in Donoghue v Stevenson and what the House of Lords decided
- Explain Lord Atkin's test for who is owed a duty of care and why two judges dissented
Lesson 1 of 4 · 5 min
When is an accident someone's legal fault?
A driver glances at a phone and hits a cyclist. A shop leaves a spill on its floor, and a customer falls. Nobody meant any harm. Does the law make them pay anyway?
In the United States the answer usually runs through negligence, a central idea in tort law. Tort law lets an injured person, the plaintiff, sue the person responsible, the defendant, for damages, which means money for the harm.
Negligence is failing to act with the level of care that a reasonable person would have used in the same circumstances. So a jury doesn't ask whether the defendant meant well. It asks what a reasonable person would have done in the defendant's situation.
Failing to act can count too, but only when you had a duty to act. Your own earlier conduct, for example, can give you a duty to help someone.
To decide whether conduct fell short, courts weigh how likely the harm was and how severe it could be against the burden of the precautions that would have reduced the risk. A small chance of minor harm may not justify a costly precaution. A likely and serious danger calls for more care.
So a person can cause an accident without being negligent at all.
Carelessness alone doesn't win a lawsuit. A plaintiff typically has to prove five elements, and failing on any one usually ends the claim.
The first is a legal duty owed to the plaintiff. A duty can arise when you create a risk, volunteer to protect someone, or know your conduct will harm them. Some relationships carry one too, such as a business and its customers or a doctor and a patient. The second element is breach, which means falling short of the care the duty requires.
The third is harm. It usually has to be bodily injury or damage to property. Purely economic harm usually isn't enough, though some states also recognize emotional distress.
The last two are about causation. Cause-in-fact is a but-for test, which asks whether the harm would have happened without the defendant's conduct. It's often the easiest element to prove.
Proximate cause is usually judged by foreseeability. Someone who throws a rock off a high-rise balcony without looking should have foreseen hitting a person on the sidewalk below. If a third party steps in, or the plaintiff's own risky conduct adds to the danger, the defendant may not be liable.
Try to recallWhat five elements does a plaintiff typically have to prove to win a negligence claim in the US?
The defendant owed the plaintiff a legal duty of care and breached it. The plaintiff suffered harm, usually bodily injury or property damage. The defendant's conduct was the cause-in-fact of the harm, meaning the harm wouldn't have happened without it, and also the proximate cause, usually meaning the harm was a foreseeable result.
So an accident becomes negligence only when all five line up. The defendant owed a duty and breached it, the plaintiff suffered real harm, and the breach caused that harm in a way someone should have foreseen.
The first element, duty, was once much narrower. In much of the common-law world, the modern rule on when a stranger is owed a duty of care took shape in 1932, in a Scottish case about a snail in a bottle of ginger beer.
Lessons in this topic
When is an accident someone's legal fault?
US law calls it negligence when you fall short of the care a reasonable person would take. See how courts weigh risk against precaution, and the five things an injured person has to prove.
The snail in the ginger beer bottle
See how a 1932 case about a snail in a bottle of ginger beer gave Scots and English law a general duty of care, and why two of the five judges objected.
The sunken barge and the formula for reasonable care
In a 1947 US case about a runaway barge, Judge Learned Hand turned the standard of care into a formula that weighs the same things as the reasonable-person test.
What happens when the injured person was careless too
Compare how US states treat an injured person who was partly to blame, from the all-or-nothing rule of contributory negligence to pure and modified comparative negligence.
Three quick stories from this topic
A formula for carelessness
A sunken barge in New York Harbor gave US negligence law an algebraic formula
The barge's keeper had been ashore for 21 hours when it sank in 1944. Judge Learned Hand ruled that a precaution is owed when its burden, B, is less than the probability of harm, P, times the loss, L. So the owner owed a man aboard in daylight.
The letters
B is the burden of adequate precautions. P is the probability of the loss, and L is the gravity of the resulting injury.
The ruling
The court ruled that leaving a barge unattended in daylight posed a significant risk, so it was fair to require a crew member aboard. Absence without an excuse was negligent.
Why 1% of the blame can cost everything
In four US states, being 1% to blame for your own injury can cost you the whole claim
As of a 2022 review, Alabama, Maryland, North Carolina, Virginia and Washington, DC, followed contributory negligence. Under that rule an injured person who was careless at all recovers nothing, even from someone 99% at fault. Most states reduce the award by the injured person's share instead.
Elsewhere in the US
Other states use comparative negligence, which cuts damages by the plaintiff's share of the fault. A plaintiff 40% at fault would recover 60% of their damages.
Both sides
The all-or-nothing rule spares courts from measuring each side's share of the blame. Cornell notes it can also produce outcomes society deems inequitable.
The snail nobody proved
The snail that reshaped negligence law was never proved to have been in the bottle
May Donoghue said a decomposed snail slid out of her ginger beer in a Scottish café in 1928. In 1932 the House of Lords ruled that the maker owed her a duty of care if her account was true. He died before any trial, and the claim was settled.
What the case decided
By 3 votes to 2, the House of Lords held that a manufacturer owes a duty of care to the ultimate consumers of its products, even with no contract between them.
Why it was never tested
The manufacturer, David Stevenson, died in November 1932. The claim was settled out of court in 1934, so no court ever heard evidence about what was in the bottle.
Sources
- negligence | Wex | US Law | LII / Legal Information Institute, Cornell Legal Information Institute
- Donoghue v Stevenson - Wikipedia, Wikipedia
- United States v. Carroll Towing Co. - Wikipedia, Wikipedia
- United States v. Carroll Towing Co., 159 F.2d 169 (2d Cir. 1947), Caselaw Access Project, Harvard Law School Library
- comparative negligence | Wex | US Law | LII / Legal Information Institute, Cornell Legal Information Institute
- contributory negligence | Wex | US Law | LII / Legal Information Institute, Cornell Legal Information Institute
- Comparative negligence, Wikipedia





