Politics & Law · Everyday & business law
What makes a contract enforceable?
What turns a promise into a contract under US law, from offer and acceptance to the exchange each side must make, and when a deal has to be in writing.

What you will learn
- Distinguish an offer and acceptance from an unresolved negotiation.
- Explain why assent is judged by communicated words or conduct rather than by an unspoken intention alone.
- Identify consideration in a straightforward service-for-payment exchange.
- Explain why the law may treat a gift promise differently from a contract exchange.
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
When a conversation becomes an agreement
A gardener says, "I can clear the courtyard on Friday for $120." The owner replies, "I'll pay you 90." Have they agreed?
Not yet. Contract law asks something narrow. Did one side make an offer, and did the other accept it? These are the common rules in US law, and states vary in the details.
Start with the offer. It has to be made in a way that would lead a reasonable person to expect a binding deal if they say yes. The gardener's sentence does that. It names the job, the day and the price.
Casual talk doesn't. "I might be free on Friday" commits the speaker to nothing, so there's nothing to accept.
Acceptance means agreeing to the offer's terms as they stand. The owner didn't do that. Naming $90 is a counteroffer, a new offer going the other way.
A counteroffer also rejects the original offer, and a rejected offer can't be accepted later. So if the gardener says no to $90, the owner can't just say "fine, $120" and have a deal. The gardener would have to agree again.
Offers can be withdrawn too. Until the other side accepts, the person who made an offer can usually take it back by telling them.
Courts judge agreement from the outside, by what a person says and does. So silently thinking "I accept" forms no contract. Acceptance has to reach the other side, in words or through conduct.
It works the other way too. In 1952 a Virginia man, A. H. Zehmer, wrote on the back of a restaurant check that he'd sell his farm to W. O. Lucy for $50,000. He and his wife signed it. He later said he'd been drinking and the whole thing was a joke.
Virginia's Supreme Court made him sell. The law looks to a person's "outward expression," it said, and not to a "secret and unexpressed intention."
Try to recallUnder basic US contract principles, why might silently deciding to accept an offer not be enough to form an agreement?
Courts judge acceptance by what a person communicates, in words or through conduct. A private thought tells the other party nothing, so it forms no agreement.
Lessons in this topic
When a conversation becomes an agreement
See what turns a conversation into an agreement under US contract law, why a counteroffer kills the original offer, and how a man who said he was joking ended up selling his farm.
Why a promise needs something in return
Meet consideration, the exchange that separates a contract from a gift promise, through a gardening job and an uncle who offered $5,000 for clean living.
Does a contract have to be in writing?
See why a handshake can bind and a signature can fail under US law, and which deals, such as a land sale, must be in writing.
When a broken promise costs you money
See how US courts can enforce a promise that isn't a contract when someone relied on it, and why the award may cover what you spent and not what you were promised.
Three quick stories from this topic
The farm on a restaurant check
A note on the back of a restaurant check forced a Virginia man to sell his farm
A. H. Zehmer said he'd been drinking and was only bluffing when he and his wife signed a note selling their farm for $50,000 in 1952. Virginia's Supreme Court enforced it. Contract law reads what you say and do, and a secret intention doesn't count.
What the note said
"We hereby agree to sell to W. O. Lucy the Ferguson Farm complete for $50,000.00, title satisfactory to buyer." Both Zehmers signed it.
Why the joke failed
The court said the law looks to "the outward expression of a person as manifesting his intention rather than to his secret and unexpressed intention."
$5,000 for clean living
A New York court ruled in 1891 that giving up drink and swearing paid for a $5,000 promise
William Story promised his nephew $5,000 to stay off liquor, tobacco, swearing and gambling until he turned 21. The uncle's estate argued the nephew had given nothing in return. The court disagreed, because he had given up things he had a legal right to do.
The test the court applied
A contract needs consideration, meaning each side gives or promises something in exchange for the other's promise. It doesn't have to be money.
The uncle's benefit didn't matter
The nephew had "restricted his lawful freedom of action" on the faith of the promise. The court said it was "of no moment" whether that benefited the uncle.
A counteroffer kills the offer
A counteroffer kills the original offer in US law, so you can't go back and accept it
Say a seller offers a car for $5,000 and you reply, "I'll give you $4,500." Your reply counts as a rejection and as a new offer of your own. If the seller says no, the $5,000 offer is gone unless the seller chooses to make it again.
What the rule says
Once the person receiving an offer rejects it, they can no longer accept it. A counteroffer acts as a rejection and creates an entirely new offer.
Offers can be pulled too
The person who made an offer can usually withdraw it any time before acceptance by telling the other side, unless the two have made an enforceable option contract.
Sources
- contract | Wex | US Law | LII / Legal Information Institute, Cornell Legal Information Institute
- offer | Wex | US Law | LII / Legal Information Institute, Cornell Legal Information Institute
- acceptance | Wex | US Law | LII / Legal Information Institute, Cornell Legal Information Institute
- Lucy v. Zehmer, 196 Va. 493 (1954), Caselaw Access Project, Harvard Law School Library
- Hamer v. Sidway, 124 N.Y. 538 (1891), Caselaw Access Project, Harvard Law School Library
- Hamer v. Sidway, Wikipedia
- consideration | Wex | US Law | LII / Legal Information Institute, Cornell Legal Information Institute





