Politics & Law · Political ideas & systems
What makes a democracy democratic?
How meaningful participation, rights, and accountability work together, and why no single design of government is the only democratic one.

What you will learn
- Explain why holding a vote doesn't, by itself, establish democratic participation.
- Identify freedoms that help people make and express an informed political choice.
- Distinguish electoral selection from continuing accountability.
- Explain why majority support doesn't remove the need to protect political rights.
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
What makes a vote meaningful?
Say a town holds an election with two names on the ballot. On election day every vote is counted honestly. But for months beforehand, one candidate was blocked from meeting supporters or explaining her plans.
The count was accurate, and it couldn't undo what came earlier. So whether a vote means much depends on what people could do before election day.
The United Nations treats democracy the same way. When its founders wrote the UN Charter in 1945, they left the word out. Many member states at the time didn't endorse democracy or practice it.
Today the UN describes democracy as an environment in which people have a say in decisions and can hold decision makers to account.
In 2002 a UN human rights body listed ten essential elements of democracy. Free elections by secret ballot are one of the ten. The other nine include freedom of expression, freedom of association, free media and an independent judiciary.
Some of this is binding law. The European Convention on Human Rights gives elections one sentence, in Article 3 of its First Protocol. The countries bound by it undertake to hold free elections at reasonable intervals by secret ballot.
The sentence doesn't stop there. The elections have to be held under conditions that ensure the free expression of the people's opinion in choosing the legislature. So the conditions around the vote are part of the legal duty.
The treaty binds only the countries that have joined it, so it doesn't describe every country's election rules.
An election needs two kinds of protection. The first covers forming a choice. People need to hear competing arguments, discuss their concerns and organize with others. Freedom of expression, assembly and association protect that.
The second covers making the choice. A secret ballot keeps each person's vote private, so the decision is theirs alone.
The two do different jobs, so one can't stand in for the other. Open debate followed by a vote that isn't private falls short. So does a private vote that follows months of silence.
Try to recallWhy do freedom of association and a secret ballot play different roles in an election?
Association lets people organize and pursue shared political views before the vote. Ballot secrecy protects the privacy of each person's final choice. One can't do the other's job.
Lessons in this topic
What makes a vote meaningful?
See why an honest count isn't enough, and which freedoms have to be in place before a vote gives people a real choice.
What keeps power in check between elections
Separate choosing officials from holding them to account, and see why winning a majority doesn't put a government beyond challenge.
Why democracies don't all look alike
Compare the United States and Israel to tell a democratic principle from a way of arranging government, then judge a parliament by what it can do.
When an unelected ruler can overrule the voters
Learn to spot a hybrid regime, where real elections sit beneath an authority voters can't remove, using Morocco's constitution as the example.
Three quick stories from this topic
The Charter's missing word
The UN Charter of 1945 never uses the word democracy
When the Charter was drafted, many member states didn't endorse democracy or practice it. The UN now calls democracy a core value, and it finds the principle in the Charter's opening words, "We the Peoples."
What the UN means by democracy
The UN describes an environment in which people have a say in decisions and can hold decision makers to account, with human rights and fundamental freedoms respected.
No single model
The UN says it doesn't advocate a specific model of government. It promotes democratic governance as a set of values and principles.
A democratic name
North Korea's official name calls it democratic, and it holds elections for a legislature
Members of the Supreme People's Assembly are elected through a tightly controlled process in which voters have no real choice of candidates, and the assembly has no real power. A country's name and its election days say little about who rules.
Hard authoritarianism
Political scientists use the term for regimes that act without consulting the broad majority of their citizens. North Korea is one example.
Ask what the institution can do
A parliament matters when voters can choose its members freely and those members can scrutinize the government and remove it.
Elections under a king
Moroccans elect their parliament, and the king keeps the power to dissolve it
Reforms after the Arab Spring gave the elected legislature more authority. The 2011 constitution still lets the king disband parliament and issue binding decrees, so an authority voters can't remove keeps the last word.
A hybrid regime
Political scientists call this soft authoritarianism, a hybrid in which elected bodies hold limited power and an unaccountable authority can usually override them.
The override question
To judge a system, ask whether an authority the voters can't remove can overrule the body they elected.
Sources
- Democracy | United Nations, United Nations
- European Convention on Human Rights, Council of Europe
- 13.2 Categorizing Contemporary Regimes - Introduction to Political Science | OpenStax, OpenStax
- Morocco's Constitution of 2011, Constitute Project





