Politics & Law · Political ideas & systems
How federal countries split lawmaking power
Federal constitutions split lawmaking between a national government and its regions, then need rules for powers no list mentions and for laws that clash.

What you will learn
- Explain what makes a federation different from a unitary state that delegates power
- Distinguish a federation from a confederation by how the center reaches citizens
- Identify which level holds undelegated powers under the US Tenth Amendment
- Explain how Canada's Constitution Act, 1867 gives unlisted powers to the federal Parliament
Lesson 1 of 4 · 5 min
What makes a country a federation
A resident of Quebec lives under two sets of lawmakers at once. Canada's Parliament makes laws for the whole country, Quebec's legislature makes laws for the province, and both bind the same person.
Countries built this way are federations. Power is divided between a common government and member units, which may be called provinces, states or cantons. Each level has the final say over some issues, and both act directly on citizens. Scholars sum it up as shared rule combined with self-rule.
Plenty of countries hand power to regions, though. What makes the division federal is how secure it is. In a federation the split is typically written into a constitution that neither level can change on its own.
A unitary state can give its regions or cities real power too, but its central legislature can typically take that power back at will. So here's a test. Could the center strip the regions of their powers by passing an ordinary law? If it could, the country isn't a federation.
Federations come about in two ways. In coming together federations such as the United States, Canada, Switzerland and Australia, separate units pooled their power and built in limits on the center. In holding together federations such as India, Belgium and Spain, a unitary state handed authority to its regions to ease the threat of unrest or secession.
A confederation sits at the other end, with a weaker center that depends on its member units. Typically the members may legally leave, and the center has only the authority they delegate. Members can veto many decisions, and the center often has no tax or electoral base of its own.
The practical difference is whom a decision binds. A confederal decision binds the member governments, and it reaches you only through what your government does next. A federal law can bind you directly, without passing through your state or province.
The United States has been both. Many would count the North American states between 1776 and 1787 as a confederation. The Constitution that replaced the arrangement even names it. Article VI promises that earlier debts stay "as valid against the United States under this Constitution, as under the Confederation."
The new common government would operate, in the words of Federalist Paper 39, "on the individual citizens composing the nation." Switzerland from 1291 to 1847 is often counted as a confederation too. So is today's European Union, though it has several federal features.
Try to recallHow does a federation differ from a confederation in the way the central government's decisions reach citizens, and what does that suggest about which center is stronger?
In a federation, the common government acts directly on individual citizens, so its laws bind people without passing through the member units. In a typical confederation, the center's decisions bind the member governments, not citizens directly. The confederal center also exercises only the authority its members delegate, and members may veto many decisions and may legally leave, so it's weaker and depends on its members. The North American states between 1776 and 1787 are often counted as a confederation, while the United States under its Constitution is a federation.
So two tests sort most countries. If the center can take back the regions' powers by ordinary law, it's a unitary state. If the center's decisions bind only governments, it's a confederation. In a federation neither level can rewrite the split alone, and both make laws that bind you directly.
That still leaves a gap. A federal constitution has to say which level gets a power it never mentions, and federations answer that differently.
Lessons in this topic
What makes a country a federation
See what separates a federation from a unitary state that lends power to its regions, and from a confederation whose center can't reach citizens directly.
Where the leftover powers go
Compare the United States and Canada to see which level gets the powers a constitution never lists.
When national and state laws collide
When state and national laws clash, the constitution says which one wins, and a court decides where each level's powers end.
Is federalism good for democracy?
Weigh the case that states make useful policy laboratories against critics' worries about accountability, unequal voting weight and social protection.
Three quick stories from this topic
A laboratory, and an ice plant
Justice Brandeis called a state a laboratory in a 1932 dissent about selling ice
Oklahoma required a state license to make or sell ice, and the Supreme Court ruled against the law. Brandeis disagreed. A single courageous state, he wrote, may "try novel social and economic experiments without risk to the rest of the country."
The learning argument
When member units try different answers to the same problem, others can compare the results and copy what works. Local decision-makers may also know local preferences better than a distant center.
The case against
Critics say federal systems blur accountability, give citizens of small units extra voting weight, and can leave some groups with weaker social protection than unitary states provide.
Two senators each
California had over 68 times Wyoming's population in 2020, and each state has two senators
California counted about 39.6 million people and Wyoming about 578,000. Many federations give small member units extra weight like this, and critics say it sits badly with the principle of one person, one vote.
Why federations do it
Federations formed by separate states coming together are typically arranged to constrain the center and to stop majorities from overriding a member unit.
The cost critics name
Extra voting weight for citizens of small units looks like a breach of political equality, and more so when member units differ in size.
Marriage, split in two
Canada's Parliament makes divorce law, and its provinces regulate the wedding ceremony
The Constitution Act, 1867 puts "Marriage and Divorce" on the federal list and "The Solemnization of Marriage in the Province" on the provincial one. Federal constitutions divide lawmaking subject by subject, and sometimes one subject gets cut in half.
Two lists
Section 91 names federal subjects such as banking and criminal law. Section 92 gives each province subjects such as hospitals and municipal institutions.
And the leftovers
Anything on neither list goes to the federal Parliament in Canada. The US Tenth Amendment does the reverse and reserves undelegated powers to the states or the people.
Sources
- Federalism (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy), Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- The Constitution Acts, 1867 to 1982, Government of Canada, Justice Laws Website
- The Constitution of the United States: A Transcription | National Archives, US National Archives
- New State Ice Co. v. Liebmann, 285 U.S. 262 (1932) | LII, Cornell Legal Information Institute
- Table 1. Apportionment Population and Number of Representatives by State: 2020 Census, US Census Bureau
- The Bill of Rights: A Transcription | National Archives, US National Archives




