Politics & Law · International relations & law
How international courts try war crimes
Follow international criminal justice from the Nuremberg trial to today's International Criminal Court, a permanent court that still depends on states to make its arrests.
What you will learn
- Explain why the Allies put Nazi leaders on trial and how the Nuremberg tribunal was set up
- Describe the crimes the Nuremberg tribunal tried, its verdicts and its legacy
- Distinguish the International Court of Justice from the International Criminal Court
- Describe the four crimes the International Criminal Court can try and who can be tried for them
Lesson 1 of 4 · 6 min
Why the Allies put the Nazi leaders on trial
On November 20, 1945, 21 leaders of Nazi Germany sat in a courtroom in Nuremberg. Some Allied leaders had wanted them executed without a trial. The United States proposed a trial instead.
The reason was what people would believe afterward. US Secretary of State Cordell Hull made the case. A condemnation after a trial, he said, "will meet the judgment of history, so that the Germans will not be able to claim that an admission of war guilt was extracted from them under duress." Duress means force or threats.
The court was the International Military Tribunal. France, the Soviet Union, the United Kingdom and the United States created it on August 8, 1945, by signing the Nuremberg Charter. Each power supplied one judge, one alternate judge and a prosecution team. Britain's Geoffrey Lawrence presided, and a conviction needed a majority of the four judges.
Prosecutors indicted 24 men, chosen as a cross-section of Nazi diplomatic, economic, political and military leadership. Adolf Hitler, Heinrich Himmler and Joseph Goebbels weren't among them, because they'd killed themselves. In the end 22 were tried. One of those, Martin Bormann, couldn't be found and was tried in his absence.
The defendants had rights. They could present evidence and witnesses, and they could cross-examine the prosecution's witnesses.
The Nuremberg Charter defined three crimes. Crimes against peace meant planning or waging a war of aggression, or conspiring to. The other two were war crimes and crimes against humanity.
The indictment also used a new word. Genocide had been coined just a year earlier by Raphael Lemkin, a Polish-Jewish expert in international law. Prosecutors used it again and again in court. The judges didn't adopt it in their verdict.
Most defendants admitted that the crimes had happened and denied personal responsibility. The Charter had closed one way out in advance. A defendant couldn't claim innocence because he'd simply followed orders.
On October 1, 1946, the judges convicted 19 of the 22 and acquitted three. They sentenced 12 to death. Ten were hanged on October 16. Hermann Göring killed himself the night before, and Bormann was later proved to have died in Berlin in the war's last days. The tribunal also declared four Nazi organizations criminal, including the Gestapo and the SS.
The trial established crimes against humanity as crimes under international law. It had limits. The judges considered only crimes against humanity committed during the war, so the defendants weren't judged for prewar crimes such as the persecution of Jews.
Try to recallWhat crimes did the Nuremberg Charter define, and what did the tribunal decide about the defendants it tried?
The Charter defined crimes against peace, including conspiracy to commit them, war crimes and crimes against humanity. Of the 22 defendants tried, the judges convicted 19 and acquitted three, and 12 were sentenced to death. Defendants couldn't escape guilt by saying they'd simply followed orders.
Nuremberg left two ideas that later courts kept. Leaders can be tried as individuals for crimes under international law, and following orders doesn't clear them. But four victors built that tribunal for one war. A permanent court for such crimes didn't open until 2002.
Lessons in this topic
Why the Allies put the Nazi leaders on trial
Some Allied leaders wanted the top Nazis executed without a trial. See why they were tried at Nuremberg instead, what the judges decided and what the trial left behind.
The Hague has two world courts, and only one tries people
One court in The Hague settles disputes between countries. The other tries individuals for four crimes. Learn to tell them apart, and what the four crimes are.
How a case reaches the ICC, and who gets to try it first
The ICC issued a warrant for Russia's president although Russia never joined the court. See the three routes a case can take, and why national courts get the first chance.
Does the ICC work?
The ICC can charge a president and still fail to put him on trial. Weigh the main criticisms of the court, from unserved warrants to charges of bias, against the case its supporters make.
Three quick stories from this topic
A former president in The Hague
The Philippines quit the ICC in 2019, and an ICC warrant still caught its ex-president
Rodrigo Duterte was arrested in Manila on March 11, 2025, and flown to The Hague over his role in the Philippine drug war. Quitting the court doesn't erase the past. The ICC keeps jurisdiction over the years a country was a member.
Why the court could act
The ICC said it kept jurisdiction over the period when the Philippines was a party, from November 2011 to March 2019. It issued the warrant on March 7, 2025, four days before his arrest.
Where the case stands
As of September 2026, Duterte was in ICC custody with charges confirmed on April 23, 2026, and his trial was scheduled to begin on November 30, 2026.
Genocide, a one-year-old word
The word genocide was a year old at Nuremberg, and the judges left it out of the verdict
Raphael Lemkin, a Polish-Jewish expert in international law, had coined the term just a year before the 1945 indictment. Prosecutors used it again and again during the trial. The judges convicted 19 defendants and didn't adopt the word in their verdict.
Where the word appeared
The indictment described the murder and ill-treatment of civilians as "deliberate and systematic genocide," under the charge of war crimes.
A crime of its own today
The Rome Statute lists genocide as one of the four crimes the International Criminal Court can try, defined by the intent to destroy a national, ethnical, racial or religious group.
A wanted president on tour
Wanted by the ICC, Sudan's president visited at least nine countries and none arrested him
The court issued its first warrant for Omar al-Bashir in 2009. It relies on governments to make its arrests, and its treaty says the accused must be present at trial. So a warrant is only as strong as the countries a suspect visits.
Members are supposed to help
States that joined the Rome Statute must "cooperate fully" with the court. South Africa, a member, failed in its obligation to arrest Bashir when he visited in June 2015.
Still the pattern
By late 2026 the court had publicly charged 76 people, and 34 of them were still at large.
Sources
- International Military Tribunal at Nuremberg | Holocaust Encyclopedia, United States Holocaust Memorial Museum
- Charter of the International Military Tribunal, The Avalon Project, Lillian Goldman Law Library, Yale Law School
- Nuremberg Trial Proceedings Vol. 22 - Saturday, 31 August 1946, The Avalon Project, Lillian Goldman Law Library, Yale Law School
- International Criminal Court - Wikipedia, Wikipedia
- Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, United Nations Office of Legal Affairs





