Politics & Law · Rights & constitutions
Freedom of speech and its limits
Why free expression is protected, where the US, Europe and other legal systems draw the line on incitement and hate speech, and why they draw it in different places.

What you will learn
- Describe what the First Amendment and Article 19 of the Universal Declaration protect, including expression that isn't words
- Explain the main reasons philosophers and courts give for protecting speech
- Apply the Brandenburg test to decide whether speech counts as punishable incitement in the US
- Explain why "shouting fire in a crowded theater" is a misleading summary of US law
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
What free speech protects, and why bother
In August 1984, outside Dallas City Hall, Gregory Lee Johnson poured kerosene on an American flag and set it alight. Texas convicted him of flag desecration. He got a year in jail and a $2,000 fine.
The First Amendment, adopted in 1791, says "Congress shall make no law" abridging "the freedom of speech, or of the press". Johnson said no words a court objected to. So why did the Supreme Court side with him in 1989?
Because courts read speech as expression of an idea, and Johnson's act carried a political message. Lawyers call this symbolic speech. Students wearing black armbands against the Vietnam War won the same protection in 1969.
Justice William Brennan stated the core rule. Government "may not prohibit the expression of an idea simply because society finds the idea offensive or disagreeable."
Why protect speech that offends people? Philosophers give a few different answers, and they lead to different limits.
The truth argument comes from John Stuart Mill's On Liberty in 1859. Anyone can be wrong, so a view that looks false may hold some truth. Even a plainly false view helps, because answering it shows why you believe what you do.
The democracy argument says citizens can't govern themselves without debating the laws they live under. Restricting political speech partly switches democracy off.
The autonomy argument says expressing your views is part of being the author of your own life. The distrust argument says any power to censor will be abused. Wartime bans on sedition, meaning speech against the state, were used again and again to silence legitimate protest against wars.
Try to recallGive two different reasons for protecting free speech and say what each one guards against.
The truth argument says we can all be wrong, so silencing a view risks silencing something true, and arguing with false views sharpens our grasp of true ones. The distrust argument says a government with power to censor will use it against its critics, as wartime sedition bans did.
Free speech covers ideas in words and in symbolic acts, and in the US it binds government, not private bodies. Courts and philosophers protect it to find truth, run a democracy, respect people's own voices and keep censors in check.
Lessons in this topic
What free speech protects, and why bother
See what the First Amendment and the Universal Declaration actually protect, why burning a flag can count as speech, and the four main reasons given for protecting speech at all.
Where US law draws the line on incitement
Learn the three-part test US courts have used since 1969 to decide when words become punishable incitement, and why the famous line about shouting fire in a theater misleads.
Hate speech in Germany, Strasbourg and the US
Compare how Germany punishes speech that attacks groups, how the European Court of Human Rights judges such cases, and why the US protects it.
Blasphemy, sedition and insulting the king
See how Pakistan punishes blasphemy, how Thailand punishes insults to the monarchy, and how India's colonial sedition law was narrowed, suspended and finally replaced.
Three quick stories from this topic
The fire-in-a-theater origin
The famous line about shouting fire in a theater came from a case about anti-war leaflets
In 1919 Justice Holmes used it while upholding Charles Schenck's conviction for mailing over 15,000 fliers urging men to resist the draft. He wrote "falsely" shouting fire, a word the popular version drops.
An aside, not a rule
The theater line was a comparison, not the ruling. The test it supported was "clear and present danger".
Overturned in 1969
Brandenburg v. Ohio replaced that test. Speech can now be punished only when it aims at imminent, likely lawbreaking.
The protected funeral picket
The US Supreme Court ruled 8 to 1 that a church could picket a Marine's funeral
Westboro Baptist Church members stood about 1,000 feet from the 2006 funeral holding signs like "Thank God for Dead Soldiers". A jury awarded the father $10.9 million, but the Court said speech on public issues in a public place is protected.
Hateful but legal
US law protects hate speech. Threats, incitement and crimes motivated by bias are what it punishes.
Germany would differ
German law can jail people for speech that incites hatred against a group or attacks its dignity.
87 years for sharing videos
A Thai court sentenced a woman to 87 years in prison for sharing videos about the monarchy
Anchan Preelerd's guilty plea in 2021 halved the term to 43.5 years. Thailand's law gives three to fifteen years for each insult to the king, queen, heir or regent, so many posts mean many counts.
Anyone can complain
Any person can file a complaint under Section 112, and police must investigate every one.
Harsher over time
The 1908 maximum was seven years. Insult was added in 1957, and the range rose to three to fifteen after a 1976 coup.
Sources
- Texas v. Johnson, Wikipedia
- First Amendment to the United States Constitution, Wikipedia
- Universal Declaration of Human Rights, text, United Nations
- Freedom of Speech, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Schenck v. United States, Wikipedia
- Shouting fire in a crowded theater, Wikipedia
- Snyder v. Phelps, Wikipedia
- Lèse-majesté in Thailand, Wikipedia





