Politics & Law · Courts, crime & justice

How sure a court has to be

Courts in the US and UK can't know for certain what happened, so the law sets how sure they must be, from more likely than not up to beyond a reasonable doubt for a conviction.

4 short lessons · about 20 minutes · 7 sources · updated November 2026

Three piles of folders growing taller from left to right beside a street stop, an arrest and a courtroom bench.

What you will learn

  • Explain what a burden of proof and a standard of proof are
  • Match the main US standards of proof to the decisions that use them
  • Explain what the US Supreme Court decided in In re Winship
  • Explain why US law sets a higher bar for criminal convictions than for civil cases

Lesson 1 of 4 · 5 min

Is being 60% sure enough for a US court?

Before you readA police officer has a feeling, from years of experience, that a man on the street is up to something. What does US law require before the officer can stop and search him?

Correct.Not quite. The answer is Specific suspicion the officer can put into words.

A hunch isn't enough. The officer needs specific, individualized suspicion that can be put into words. This lesson ranks the levels of proof US law uses, from stops up to convictions.

Say a jury comes away from a case 60% sure that something happened. Is that enough? In US courts, it depends on what's being decided.

A court has to rule on what happened without ever knowing for certain. So the law sets a standard of proof, the level of certainty a party must reach before a disputed fact counts as established. The burden of proof says which party has to reach it. In a criminal case that's the prosecution. In a civil case it's usually the plaintiff, the side that brought the suit.

Most civil cases, such as a lawsuit over money, use a preponderance of the evidence. The plaintiff wins on a disputed fact by showing it's more likely true than not, which means better than a 50% chance. A Pennsylvania court said in 2005 that it's enough "to tip a scale slightly." So 60% wins a civil case.

A criminal conviction needs proof beyond a reasonable doubt, the most demanding standard in law. The evidence must leave jurors firmly convinced of guilt. Being 60% sure is nowhere near that.

Between the two sits clear and convincing evidence. The US Supreme Court described it in 1984 as evidence that's highly and substantially more likely to be true than untrue. States differ on when they use it, but claims involving fraud, wills or withdrawing life support typically require it.

Check yourselfIn a typical US civil lawsuit over money, what must the plaintiff show to win on a disputed fact?

Correct.Not quite. The answer is That the fact is more likely true than not.

Most US civil cases use a preponderance of the evidence, which the plaintiff meets by tipping the scale past 50%. Leaving no reasonable doubt is the criminal standard for convictions. A highly probable fact belongs to the middle standard, clear and convincing evidence.

Some decisions can't wait for a trial. They're made early, while the evidence is still thin, so US law gives them lower bars.

A police stop and search needs reasonable suspicion. In Terry v. Ohio in 1968, the US Supreme Court said the suspicion has to be specific and individualized, meaning it's about this particular person, and the officer must be able to put it into words. A guess or a hunch isn't enough.

An arrest, a search warrant or a grand jury indictment needs probable cause, a higher bar. In 1989 the Court said that means "a fair probability that contraband or evidence of a crime will be found."

There are other rungs too. Child protection cases that need immediate action can run on a standard called some credible evidence. Higher up, clear and convincing evidence also covers high-stakes civil matters such as child custody and petitions to remove a person from life support.

Try to recallPut reasonable suspicion, probable cause and proof beyond a reasonable doubt in order from lowest to highest, and name a US decision each one governs.

Reasonable suspicion is the lowest and lets police stop and search someone. Probable cause comes next and is needed for an arrest, a search warrant or a grand jury indictment. Proof beyond a reasonable doubt is the highest and is needed for a criminal conviction.

So being 60% sure wins a US civil suit and falls well short of a criminal conviction. Each rung is set by what a mistake would cost. A wrong civil verdict usually costs money, and a wrong conviction can cost someone their liberty.

The US Supreme Court turned that reasoning into a constitutional rule in 1970, in a case about $112.

Lessons in this topic

  1. Is being 60% sure enough for a US court?

    A standard of proof sets how sure a court must be. See why 60% certainty wins a US civil suit and falls far short of a criminal conviction, and which lower bars govern police stops and arrests.

    Essentials · 5 min

  2. How a $112 theft made reasonable doubt a constitutional rule

    Follow a 1970 case about a stolen $112 that made proof beyond a reasonable doubt a US constitutional rule, and see why the justices set the bar so high.

    Essentials · 5 min

  3. The middle standard of proof, and why the UK rejects it

    Compare the US Supreme Court's 1979 demand for clear and convincing evidence in civil commitment cases with the UK House of Lords' 2008 rejection of any middle standard.

    Deeper · 5 min

  4. Can reasonable doubt be defined?

    See why judges struggle to explain reasonable doubt in words, and why Scotland dropped its third verdict, not proven, for new trials from 2026.

    Deeper · 5 min

Three quick stories from this topic

The $112 case

A case about $112 taken from a pocketbook made reasonable doubt a US constitutional rule

The words appear nowhere in the Constitution. In 1970 the Supreme Court read them into the Due Process Clause, after a New York judge sent 12-year-old Samuel Winship away for up to six years on proof he admitted might fall short.

The case

In 1967, a New York Family Court judge found that a 12-year-old had stolen $112 from a woman's pocketbook, while admitting the proof might fall short of reasonable doubt.

What changed

The Court ruled that juveniles charged with acts that would be crimes for adults get the same protection. Chief Justice Burger, dissenting, objected to turning juvenile courts into criminal courts.

The lion in Regent's Park

A UK judge used a lion in Regent's Park to explain how much evidence a claim needs

An animal seen on the park's dog-walking lawn is more likely a dog than a lion, Baroness Hale said in 2008. Beside the zoo's open lion enclosure, it may well be a lion. The standard of proof doesn't change. What changes is how likely the claim was to begin with.

Context counts

Seen in the zoo next to the lions' enclosure with the door open, she said, the same animal "may well be more likely to be a lion than a dog."

One standard

The House of Lords held that the civil standard stays the balance of probabilities, however serious the allegation or its consequences.

Scotland's third verdict

Until 2026 a Scottish jury could acquit in two ways, not guilty or not proven

Both verdicts set the accused free, with the same legal effect. A popular saying held that not proven meant "not guilty, but don't do it again." Scotland removed it for new trials from January 1, 2026, after mock-jury research found people confused about what it did.

Why it went

Mock-jury research in 2019 found people understood not proven inconsistently and were confused about its effect. Calls to scrap it went back to the middle of the 20th century.

The trade-off

Opponents of abolition feared more wrongful convictions. The 2025 law that removed the verdict also required a two-thirds jury majority to convict, where eight of 15 votes used to be enough.

Sources

This topic is part of From the rulebook to the courtroom, a guided path through related topics.

  • What a fair trial requires

    What the European Convention on Human Rights demands of a criminal trial, from a judge nobody could suspect of bias to a free interpreter, and what it leaves out, such as a jury.

    4 lessons · 17 min

  • How courts and appeals work

    Follow a case from its first hearing to the highest court. See who does what in a courtroom, what an appeal can and can't reopen, and what keeps judges free from pressure.

    4 lessons · 16 min

  • Criminal cases and civil cases

    The state prosecutes crimes and punishes. Private parties sue each other for compensation. See how the two tracks differ, how one event can lead to both, and where the line blurs.

    4 lessons · 17 min

  • How voting systems turn votes into seats

    See how first past the post, party lists and ranked ballots turn the same votes into different seats, with made-up districts and real results from the UK and Australia.

    4 lessons · 22 min

  • How federal countries split lawmaking power

    Federal constitutions split lawmaking between a national government and its regions, then need rules for powers no list mentions and for laws that clash.

    4 lessons · 20 min

  • How a bill becomes a US federal law

    Follow a made-up bill through the US Congress, from a wooden box in the House to committee work, agreement between the two chambers and the president's desk.

    4 lessons · 17 min

All politics & law topics · Take the quiz