Philosophy & Ethics · Mind, identity & free will
Could you have done otherwise?
Determinism says the past and the laws of nature settle everything you do, which makes it hard to see how you act freely or deserve blame. Weigh the leading arguments on each side and the replies they've drawn.

What you will learn
- Distinguish determinism from the mistaken idea that your choices make no difference
- Explain how the Consequence Argument moves from the fixed past and laws to your present acts
- Explain the classical compatibilist view that freedom is doing what you want without impediment
- Explain how Danielle's choice between two puppies counts against the conditional analysis of being able to do otherwise
Lesson 1 of 4 · 5 min
If the past settles everything, do your choices matter?
You raise your hand to ask a question. It feels as if you could have kept it down. Determinism says otherwise. On this view the laws of nature, together with the state of the world long ago, make everything that happens inevitable, your raised hand included. Given the actual past and the laws, only one future is possible.
A common first reaction is that your choices must then be pointless. In 1770 Baron d'Holbach wrote that a person resembles "a swimmer who is obliged to follow the current" that carries him along. The swimmer thinks he's free because he sometimes consents to glide with the stream, d'Holbach added, yet the stream "always hurries him forward."
Philosophers on both sides call this picture a mistake. Incompatibilists think freedom can't coexist with determinism. Compatibilists think it can. Neither side thinks determinism makes your choices idle.
Here's why. The current carries the swimmer along whatever he chooses. Your hand is different. If determinism is true, your choice had earlier causes that were enough to produce it, but the choice is still a cause of what you do. Your hand went up because you chose to raise it. Other things being equal, without the choice it would have stayed down.
Set the swimmer aside and two worries remain. If the distant past and the laws were enough to produce your choice, it seems you couldn't have chosen otherwise. And since they were in place long before you were born, it's hard to see how you're the source of the choice.
The Consequence Argument presses the first worry. Carl Ginet and Peter van Inwagen worked it out in the 1960s and 1970s. It rests on a simple pattern of reasoning about what's in your power.
Here's the pattern. Diamond Jim is playing poker and holds two pairs. Calamity Sam draws a straight flush. Jim has no power over Sam's draw, and none over the rule that a straight flush beats two pairs. So Jim has no power over the fact that he loses. Powerlessness passes from facts to their consequences.
Now apply it to your life. As van Inwagen puts it, "it is not up to us what went on before we were born," and the laws of nature aren't up to us either. If determinism is true, those two things entail, or guarantee, everything you'll ever do. So your acts are beyond your power too.
The argument shook compatibilists. Many of them are committed to thinking it goes wrong somewhere, and it set the agenda for their theories. A compatibilist now has to say which step fails.
Try to recallSet out the Consequence Argument against free will in three steps, and explain the principle about power that carries it from the distant past to your present acts.
First, the past and the laws of nature are beyond anyone's power. Second, so is the fact that together they entail every future fact. So the future, your own acts included, is beyond your power as well. The argument relies on a transfer principle. If you have no power over a fact, and none over its having a further fact as a consequence, you have no power over that consequence either.
So determinism doesn't make you a swimmer in a current. Your choices still cause your actions. The live question is whether a choice that was settled before you were born can be up to you.
Compatibilists answer in two ways. Some say you can still do otherwise in the sense that matters. Others say freedom never needed that ability in the first place.
Lessons in this topic
If the past settles everything, do your choices matter?
Determinism says the past and the laws of nature fix everything you'll ever do. See which fear about that is a mistake, and follow the Consequence Argument that makes the real worry precise.
Are you free whenever nothing stops you?
Hobbes and Hume said you're free when you do what you want and nothing gets in your way. See what that view gets right, and how a girl choosing between two puppies exposes its weak point.
Can you be to blame when you had no other option?
Harry Frankfurt told a story meant to show that you can be responsible for an act you couldn't have avoided. See how it works and the dilemma its critics pose.
Could a designed person act freely?
A goddess designs a person to make one choice 30 years later. Follow the argument from him to everyone in a deterministic world, and the reply that turns it around.
Three quick stories from this topic
Blame without a way out
A philosopher argued in 1969 that you can deserve blame for a choice you couldn't avoid
Harry Frankfurt imagined Jones, who makes a decision for his own reasons. Unknown to him, a man named Black stood ready to force that same decision if Jones wavered. Black never had to act. So Jones seems fully responsible, and yet he had no real alternative.
What it was aimed at
The target was the principle that you're responsible only if you could have done otherwise. If the principle is false, it doesn't matter whether determinism removes your alternatives.
The critics' dilemma
Black needs an advance sign of what Jones will decide. If the sign guarantees the decision, incompatibilists deny Jones is responsible. If it doesn't, Jones could still decide otherwise.
Holbach's swimmer
Philosophers on both sides agree that determinism wouldn't make your choices pointless
Determinism says the past and the laws of nature fix everything, your decisions included. In 1770 Baron d'Holbach pictured a person as a swimmer carried by a current. But a choice is one of the causes. Your hand goes up because you chose to raise it.
A mistake both sides reject
Incompatibilists and compatibilists widely agree the picture is a mistake. If determinism is true, your choices have earlier sufficient causes, and they still help cause what you do.
The worries that remain
If you raise your hand because you chose to, your choice made a difference. The arguments that remain ask whether you could have chosen otherwise and whether you're the source of your choices.
He did not make himself
In 1924 Clarence Darrow defended two murderers by arguing that nobody makes himself
His clients, Nathan Leopold and Richard Loeb, had killed a 14-year-old boy. "He was not his own father," Darrow said of one. "He did not make himself. And yet he is to be compelled to pay." Both got life in prison, though the judge cited their youth.
The argument
A person is responsible for a crime only if he made himself the kind of person he is. Nobody did that. So nobody is responsible.
The same idea with a goddess
Alfred Mele's zygote argument imagines a goddess who designs a person to do one thing 30 years later. Then it asks how an ordinary person in a deterministic world is any different.
Sources
- Compatibilism, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Arguments for Incompatibilism, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Moral Responsibility, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Free Will, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Leopold and Loeb - Wikipedia, Wikimedia Foundation





