Language & Communication · Media & information literacy
Telling news from opinion and ads
Learn the test that separates a factual claim from an opinion, what the labels above a story promise, and how to spot an ad made to look like reporting.

What you will learn
- Sort a statement as factual or opinion by asking whether evidence could prove or disprove it
- Explain why a false claim can still be factual and a popular view is still an opinion
- Tell news, analysis and opinion apart by what each type of story is allowed to do
- Distinguish an editorial from an op-ed by whose view each one carries
Lesson 1 of 4 · 5 min
A false statement can still be a factual one
In 2018 the Pew Research Center showed 5,035 US adults a set of statements from the news and asked them to sort each one. Was it a factual statement or an opinion?
Two of them were "Democracy is the greatest form of government" and "Health care costs per person in the US are the highest in the developed world."
Pew's test is whether objective evidence could prove or disprove the statement. Spending figures could confirm the health care claim or knock it down, so it's factual. No measurement can settle what counts as greatest. That claim rests on values and beliefs, which makes it an opinion.
It sounds easy. Yet just 26% of people identified all five factual statements, and 35% got all five opinions. Most got at least three of five right in each set, which Pew called "only a little better than random guesses."
Notice what the test leaves out. It doesn't ask whether the statement is true. Pew told people to call a statement factual "whether you think it is accurate or not."
So a wrong number is still a factual claim. Say someone claims a town's library budget doubled when it rose by a tenth. Records can show the claim is false, and that's exactly what makes it factual. Calling a claim factual only says it can be checked.
This isn't the everyday meaning. In an argument, "that's a fact" usually means "that's true." Pew notes the difference. All five factual statements in its survey happened to be accurate, but the definition doesn't require it.
Popularity doesn't change the category either. Nearly everyone agrees that kindness is a virtue. The view still rests on values, so it's still an opinion.
Try to recallA friend says the claim "The Moon is larger than Earth" must be an opinion because it's false. Explain why it's a factual claim, and what makes a statement an opinion.
It's a factual claim because objective evidence, such as measurements of the two bodies, can prove or disprove it. Here the evidence disproves it, which makes it an inaccurate factual claim. A statement is an opinion when it rests on values and beliefs that no evidence could settle, however many people share them.
Before you decide whether you believe a statement, ask whether evidence could settle it. If it could, the statement is factual, and it may still be wrong. If it couldn't, it's an opinion, however many people hold it.
Lessons in this topic
A false statement can still be a factual one
A statement is factual if evidence could prove or disprove it. See why that makes some false claims factual and some popular views opinions.
What the label above a story promises
See what the labels news, analysis and opinion each promise, and why an editorial and an op-ed speak for different people.
Why your side's opinions can pass for facts
In a Pew survey, Republicans and Democrats were both more likely to call a statement factual when it favored their side.
When an ad is dressed as reporting
Find out why an ad formatted as news misleads even when its claims are true, and which labels readers do and don't understand.
Three quick stories from this topic
The fake torn-out review
A bookseller mailed ads disguised as a review torn from a magazine, ragged edge and all
Each copy was on glossy paper with a ripped left edge, a byline, page numbers and part of an unrelated article on the back. A stick-on note in fake handwriting said, "Try this. It works! J." In 1996 the FTC challenged the format as deceptive.
Every detail of a real page
It was printed on glossy stock with a ripped left edge. It had the header "REVIEW," a byline, a publication date and page numbers, and part of an unrelated article on the back. Taken together, the FTC said, these made it look like a published review of the book.
A note from a friend
Stuck to each copy was a small note in what looked like handwriting, with the recipient's first name and the message "Try this. It works! J." The FTC weighed that note too in judging what the ad told readers.
What op-ed stands for
The "op" in op-ed stands for opposite, because the page faced the newspaper's editorials
The term is short for "opposite the editorial page," the spot where guest writers ran in a printed paper. In 2021 The New York Times dropped it for "guest essay," since online there's no facing page. Its opinion editor called the name "a relic."
Editorial or op-ed
An editorial gives the view of the publication itself. An op-ed usually comes from an outside contributor, and papers often run ones that contradict their own editorials.
A page from 1970
The New York Times formally developed its modern op-ed page in 1970 under editor John B. Oakes. It retired the term 51 years later.
The five-statement test
Only 26% of US adults could pick out all five factual statements in a Pew news test
In 2018 Pew gave 5,035 adults five factual statements and five opinions to sort. A statement counted as factual if evidence could prove or disprove it. Most people got at least three of each five, which Pew called "only a little better than random guesses."
Factual doesn't mean true
Pew asked people to call a statement factual whether they thought it was accurate or not. A false claim that records could disprove is still a factual statement.
Politics tilts the sorting
89% of Democrats and 63% of Republicans classified "President Barack Obama was born in the United States" as factual. Both parties more often called statements factual when they favored their side.
Sources
- Distinguishing Between Factual and Opinion Statements in the News, Pew Research Center
- Overall, Americans identified more statements correctly than incorrectly, but sizable portions got most wrong, Pew Research Center
- Enforcement Policy Statement on Deceptively Formatted Advertisements, Federal Trade Commission
- Op-ed, Wikipedia
- Republicans and Democrats more likely to classify a news statement as factual if it favors their side, whether it is factual or opinion, Pew Research Center





