Language & Communication · Media & information literacy
Checking a claim beyond its website
See why professional fact checkers leave a web page to judge it, how to follow a citation back to what it shows, and why five sites that agree can still be one source.

What you will learn
- Tell lateral reading apart from staying on one website
- Explain why a polished page or a domain ending can't show that a source is credible
- Compare a headline claim with the scope of its cited evidence
- Spot the missing information you'd need to judge whether a source supports a claim
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
Why fact checkers leave a website to judge it
Researchers at Stanford filmed three groups judging websites they'd never seen. One group was history professors. One was undergraduates at an elite university. The third was professional fact checkers.
The professors and students mostly stayed put. They read from the top of the screen to the bottom, studied the web address and clicked through to the About page. The fact checkers left almost immediately and opened new tabs to see what other sources said about the site.
The fact checkers judged the sites faster and more accurately than either other group.
The researchers named the two habits. Vertical reading means staying on the page and examining its features, such as a logo that looks official or an About section listing impressive goals. Every one of those details comes from the organization you're trying to evaluate.
Lateral reading means consulting other sources. You open new tabs side by side, which gives the habit its name, and search for reporting or reference material about the publisher. The question you're answering is who's behind the information.
In 2020 the Stanford group tested 87 college students. Each had to judge a website that disputes the scientific consensus on climate change. They were told they could open a new tab and search.
A search turns up several sources reporting that the site gets funding from fossil fuel companies. Only 3 of the 87 left the site to look. Of the rest, 23 took its .org address as a sign of reliability. Others went by its layout or its links to other sites.
None of these is hard to arrange. A .org ending doesn't certify that a page is accurate. A link to a respected institution doesn't mean the institution backs the claim.
Leaving the site isn't a magic filter either. Whatever you find needs evaluating too, and a high place in the search results doesn't make a source trustworthy. Look for named authors, relevant expertise and evidence you can inspect.
Say you learn that a publisher has money riding on a claim. That's a reason to look more closely. It doesn't prove the claim false, so check the claim as well as the source.
Try to recallWhy can't a professional design and a .org address show that a web page's claim is true?
Both come from the publisher, and neither is hard to arrange. They don't tell you who's behind the page or what evidence it has. To judge the claim I'd need outside sources on the publisher and support I can check.
So do what fact checkers do. When a site is new to you, open a second tab and find out who's behind it from sources it doesn't control. After four one-hour lessons, 67 of the 87 students did.
Lessons in this topic
Why fact checkers leave a website to judge it
See how professional fact checkers judged unfamiliar sites better than history professors did, and why a polished page or a .org address proves nothing.
Follow the citation all the way to the claim
Compare what a cited study measured with what the headline claims, and see what to say when you can't reach the evidence.
Five websites can still be one source
See how one teenager's joke reached four newspapers, and how to tell repeated reporting from independent evidence.
Scan the search results before you click
Practice click restraint on a search results page, then use a Wikipedia entry to find sources instead of treating it as a verdict.
Three quick stories from this topic
The video from Russia
Over half of 3,446 US teens called a video from Russia strong evidence of US voter fraud
The Facebook video claimed to show ballot stuffing in the 2016 Democratic primaries. In a 2019 national survey, 52% of high school students called it strong evidence. Searching a few words about the video would have shown where it came from.
Nine in ten had no good reason to doubt it
Nine of ten students couldn't give a sound reason for rejecting the video. Across the survey, students judged sources by surface features and rarely left the page to check them.
The fix is a second tab
Lateral reading means leaving a source to see what others say about it. Here a search for the video's subject was enough to show where it came from.
Fact checkers leave first
Fact checkers judged unfamiliar websites better than history professors by leaving them
Stanford researchers filmed both groups. The professors read each page from top to bottom and rarely left it. The fact checkers left almost immediately and opened new tabs to find out who was behind the site, which made them faster and more accurate.
Reading sideways
The researchers call the habit lateral reading, after the new tabs fact checkers opened across the browser. Staying on one page and reading down it is vertical reading.
Why a page can't vouch for itself
The logo, the About page and the web address all come from the publisher. Other sources are the ones it doesn't control.
The Brazilian aardvark
Four newspapers called the coati a "Brazilian aardvark", a name invented on Wikipedia
A 17-year-old added the nickname as a joke in July 2008 and gave no source. On one day in June 2010 four British papers printed it. By 2014 Wikipedia cited one of those articles as its source for the name.
One sentence, many copies
The coati is a member of the raccoon family. Every newspaper mention of the nickname led back to the same unsourced line.
Five copies, one source
Five pages that repeat one account are still one account. Ask where each one got its information and what it adds.
Sources
- Teaching Lateral Reading, Digital Inquiry Group
- Lateral reading: College students learn to critically evaluate internet sources in an online course, Breakstone et al., Harvard Kennedy School Misinformation Review, 2021
- How a Raccoon Became an Aardvark, The New Yorker
- Circular reporting, Wikimedia Foundation





