Language & Communication · How language works
Grammar and where its rules come from
Every language has grammar, and its speakers follow it without being taught. Tell the rules that make a language work from the rules of style taught at school, and see how far grammars differ.

What you will learn
- Explain how native speakers follow grammar rules they can't state, using adjective order
- Explain what the wug test showed about how children learn grammar
- Explain why defining a noun as a person, place or thing fails
- Sort a word into a part of speech by how it behaves in a sentence
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
The grammar rules nobody taught you
Picture a nice little old white brick house. Now try a white brick little nice old house. It sounds like a mistake, though you'd struggle to say why.
English adjectives come in a fixed order. The writer Mark Forsyth listed it as opinion, size, age, shape, color, origin, material, purpose, then the noun. Some guides swap shape and age.
Native speakers follow this order and most don't know they do. A red big dog sounds wrong to them anyway. Linguists still argue about why the order exists. A popular idea is that adjectives closest in meaning to the noun sit next to it.
In 1958 a researcher named Jean Berko showed children a drawing of a small made-up creature. "This is a wug," she said. Then she showed two. "Now there are two of them. There are two..."
Most children aged 4 to 5 said wugs. They couldn't have heard the word before, because Berko invented it. So they weren't repeating anything. They were applying a rule for making plurals.
The test worked for past tenses too. Told about a man who likes to spow, children said that yesterday he spowed. Younger children could add endings to real words before made-up ones, which suggests they first memorize pairs and then pull out the pattern.
Try to recallChildren who had never heard the made-up word wug still said there were two wugs. What does that show about how children learn grammar?
They can't have copied the word, so they must be applying a rule they worked out themselves. Nobody taught them the plural rule. They pulled it from the speech around them and used it on a new word.
Grammar, to a linguist, is the system you already carry. You follow its adjective order and its endings without being told, because you worked them out as a child.
Lessons in this topic
The grammar rules nobody taught you
See how English speakers follow an exact order for adjectives they can't explain, and what a 1958 test with made-up words showed about children.
What really makes a word a noun
Find out why the school definition of a noun breaks down, and how linguists sort words by what they do in a sentence.
Where the bans on split infinitives came from
Tell the rules that describe a language from the rules of style taught at school, and trace two famous school rules back to their sources.
What your language makes you say
Compare how languages show who did what to whom, and see grammars that make speakers mark a noun's gender or how they know a fact.
Three quick stories from this topic
Lowth's own preposition
The grammarian often blamed for the preposition rule ended his own sentence with one
In his 1762 grammar, Robert Lowth wrote that this was an idiom English is strongly inclined to. He said it suited conversation and familiar writing, and only advised against it in solemn style.
The real source
The objection took off after 1672, when John Dryden tested his English by translating it into Latin, which can't end a clause that way.
A superstition
By the 19th century schools taught it as a ban. In 1926 H. W. Fowler called it a cherished superstition.
A language with three verbs
Jingulu, a language of Australia's Northern Territory, has only three verbs
To say more, speakers pair one of the verbs with another root, so cry plus do means it's crying. English, by contrast, adds new verbs all the time.
A closed class
A word class that rarely gains members is called closed. In English that's pronouns, but in Jingulu it's verbs.
An endangered language
Jingulu is spoken on the Barkly Tableland and has very few speakers left.
The wug test
In 1958, children shown a made-up creature called a wug knew that two were wugs
Jean Berko invented the word, so no child could have heard it. Most 4 and 5 year olds still added the plural ending, which showed they were using a rule they had worked out for themselves.
Past tenses too
Told about a man who likes to spow, children said that yesterday he spowed.
Rules nobody taught
Children pull grammar from the speech around them. Younger ones manage real words first, then extend the pattern to new ones.
Sources
- Beware the 'bad big wolf': why you need to put your adjectives in the right order (Simon Horobin), The Conversation
- Adjective, Wikipedia
- Grammar, Wikipedia
- Jean Berko Gleason, Wikipedia
- Preposition stranding, Wikipedia
- Robert Lowth, Wikipedia
- Part of speech, Wikipedia
- Jingulu language, Wikipedia





