Economics & Money · Markets, prices & incentives
Capitalism, socialism and mixed economies
Who owns the farms and factories, and who decides what gets made? Compare markets, central planning and the mixes in between that almost every country runs today.

What you will learn
- Name the three questions every economy answers and the two features that sort economic systems
- Give the main case made for and against markets and for and against socialism
- Explain how market economies use the state and planned economies use markets
- Compare where countries sit today and tell a welfare state from a planned economy
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
Who decides what gets made
Every economy has to settle three questions. What gets made, and how much? How is it made, by whom and with what? And who gets what's made? Scarcity forces them, because there's never enough to make everything people want.
Economies answer in different ways, and two features sort them. One is who owns the farms, factories and machines, which economists call the means of production. Private owners, the state or the workers can own them. The other is who coordinates, markets or planners.
In capitalism, private owners produce for profit and decide what to make by watching prices. In a planned economy, the state owns most of the means of production and planners tell each factory what to make. Both answer the three questions. Different people do the answering.
The systems split most sharply on who gets what. Markets hand out goods by willingness to pay, so what you get depends on your income. Planners hand them out by decision, through set prices, rationing and queues.
Defenders of markets, like Friedrich Hayek and Milton Friedman, argue that markets settle what to make without coercion, because each trade is voluntary. Critics answer that markets also bring booms and busts, unemployment and wide inequality. Economist Thomas Piketty argues that inequality is built into capitalist growth.
Socialists want social ownership of the means of production. They hope to end the crises and inequality they link to the profit system. Critics point to the record of planned economies. Robert Heilbroner, a socialist for most of his life, called Soviet-style planning the tragic failure of the twentieth century.
The word socialism covers two different things. It can mean a centrally planned economy like the Soviet Union's. It can also mean the welfare states of Western Europe, which are more usually called social democracy.
Try to recallWhat is one main argument for markets and one main argument against them?
For markets, defenders like Hayek and Friedman argue they decide what to make without coercion, because every trade is voluntary. Against them, critics say markets bring booms and busts, unemployment and wide inequality, which Piketty argues grows with capitalism itself.
Every economy decides what to make, how and for whom. You can now place a system by who owns production and who coordinates it, and say which meaning of socialism someone has in mind.
Lessons in this topic
Who decides what gets made
Every economy has to decide what to make, how, and for whom. See how markets and planners answer those questions, and the strongest case for and against each.
Why every real economy is a mix
Market economies run schools and roads, and planned ones let farmers keep private plots. See how the mix works and where countries sit today.
How the Soviet plan worked and why shelves stayed bare
Follow a Soviet plan from Gosplan down to the factory floor, see what it built, and find out why shortages never went away.
Can planners run an economy without prices
Mises said socialism couldn't calculate, Lange said planners could set prices by trial and error, and Hayek said prices carry knowledge no board can gather.
Three quick stories from this topic
24 million prices
Soviet price setters had some 24 million prices to keep track of
In 1982 the state raised what it paid for moleskins from 20 to 50 kopecks. Pelts flooded in and rotted in warehouses, but the committee had no time to cut the price again.
The signal arrived
Full warehouses showed the price was too high. Two Soviet economists told the story in their book The Turning Point to show how slowly planners responded.
A question of motive
Robert Heilbroner concluded that the missing piece was less information than a reason to act on it.
The giant nail cartoon
A famous Soviet cartoon showed a factory's record output as one giant nail
Soviet plans set targets by weight or length, so managers chased tonnage instead of quality. The satirical magazine Krokodil drew a manager proudly displaying a single enormous nail hanging from a crane.
Why weight mattered
Managers earned bonuses for overfulfilling their targets, and the targets were physical. A target set in tons rewards weight, whatever the nails are good for.
A wider problem
János Kornai argued that shortages in planned economies came from the system itself, not from planners' mistakes.
Xiaogang's secret deal
Eighteen Chinese farm households secretly split their village's land in 1978
In Xiaogang, the families signed an illegal agreement to farm separate plots, hand the state its share and keep the rest. Their next harvest was reportedly bigger than the previous five years combined.
From crime to policy
Within a few years the idea became the household responsibility system, adopted from 1979 and made official in 1982.
Still public land
The land stayed publicly owned. Families met state quotas, chose their crops and sold what was left over.
Sources
- Economic system, Wikipedia
- Capitalism, Wikipedia
- Socialism, Wikipedia
- Mixed economy, Wikipedia
- Socialism, by Robert Heilbroner, Econlib, The Concise Encyclopedia of Economics
- Xiaogang Village, Wikipedia
- Household responsibility system, Wikipedia





