Mind & Psychology · Perception & attention
Multitasking, distraction and the limits of attention
Why doing two things at once usually means switching between them, what each switch costs, and what the evidence says about phones, driving and shrinking attention spans.

What you will learn
- Explain how a bottleneck in choosing actions makes two demanding tasks take turns
- Explain why practice lets a task run alongside another and where that stops
- Describe the switch cost and what makes it bigger or smaller
- Explain how attention picks out one voice and what still gets through from the others
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
Why two hard tasks have to take turns in your head
Psychologists test multitasking with two tiny tasks. A light flashes and you press a key. A moment later a digit appears and you press a different key. When the second signal comes 150 milliseconds after the first, people answer it more slowly than when the gap is a full second.
This delay is the psychological refractory period. Each task runs through three steps. You perceive the signal, you choose a response, and you make it. Perceiving and moving can overlap across two tasks. Choosing can't.
Harold Pashler's 1994 review called this a stubborn bottleneck in choosing actions, and probably in pulling facts from memory too. So the second task sits and waits while the first one is decided.
Practice changes the picture. In a classic experiment by Schneider and Shiffrin, people searched fast-moving frames for target items. At first they found the target 55% of the time.
After 900 rounds they found it 90% of the time. After about 600 rounds, they said the search had become automatic. They could respond without thinking about it.
An automatic task needs little of the choosing step, so it can run beside another task. How well you divide attention depends on practice and difficulty. A new or hard task still has to queue, however skilled you are at something else.
Try to recallWhy can a well-practiced task run alongside another task when a new one can't?
A practiced task becomes automatic, so it needs little of the step where responses are chosen. That frees the bottleneck for the other task. A new or hard task still needs that step and has to wait its turn.
Two demanding tasks take turns at the step where you choose what to do, so one always waits. Practice can make a task automatic enough to slip past that queue, but anything new or hard still lines up.
Lessons in this topic
Why two hard tasks have to take turns in your head
Why your mind can see and move for two tasks at once but can only decide for one, and how practice gets a task out of the queue.
What each switch between tasks costs you
Why your first move after switching tasks is slower and sloppier, why warning doesn't erase the cost, and how you pick one voice out of a noisy room.
Why a hands-free call still slows your driving
Why it's the conversation, not the phone in your hand, that slows a driver, why a passenger is different, and how rare true multitaskers are.
Are attention spans really shrinking
Trace the famous goldfish statistic back to its missing source, then see what studies of mind wandering and media multitasking actually show.
Three quick stories from this topic
The goldfish myth
The claim that goldfish outlast human attention spans traces back to no real study
The 8-second human and 9-second goldfish figures came from a 2015 report that cited a website. The website's listed sources had no record of the research. Goldfish, meanwhile, are a model for studying memory.
How it spread
Major newspapers and magazines repeated the numbers before the BBC program More or Less traced them in 2017.
Why one number fails
Researchers say attention depends on the task and the person, so a single average attention span isn't something they'd measure.
Hearing your own name
Only about a third of people catch their name in a conversation they're ignoring
In a 1995 study, 34.6% of 34 students recalled hearing their name in the ear they'd been told to ignore. The rest missed it, because attention filters out almost all of an ignored message.
The cocktail party effect
You can follow one voice in a noisy room. In headset studies, people could report almost nothing from the message they ignored.
What the filter lets through
Personally important items like a name sometimes break through. Those who caught it kept listening to that ear for a moment.
The rare supertasker
In a 2010 driving test, only 2.5% of people handled a hard mental task with no loss
Researchers had 200 people drive a simulator while doing a demanding memory task by ear. The vast majority did worse at driving, the task or both. Just 1 in 40 showed no drop at all.
Why most people slip
Thinking tasks and driving compete for the same step of choosing what to do, so one has to wait.
Phones in cars
Hands-free calls carried no safety advantage over handheld ones in a large 1997 crash study, because the conversation is what distracts.
Sources
- Psychological refractory period, Wikipedia
- Dual-task interference in simple tasks: data and theory (Pashler, 1994), Psychological Bulletin, via PubMed
- Human multitasking, Wikipedia
- Busting the attention span myth (More or Less, 2017), BBC News
- The cocktail party phenomenon revisited (Wood and Cowan, 1995), Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, via PubMed
- Cocktail party effect, Wikipedia
- Supertaskers: profiles in extraordinary multitasking ability (Watson and Strayer, 2010), Psychonomic Bulletin and Review, via PubMed





