Politics & Law · Public policy & regulation
Regulation and the agencies that enforce it
Why governments check drugs, utilities, banks and airlines, how an agency turns a law into rules and inspections, and how an industry can end up steering its own watchdog.

What you will learn
- Explain why risks buyers can't see give governments a reason to approve products before sale, using drug approval
- Explain why a natural monopoly, such as a water or power network, is usually regulated
- Describe how an agency turns a broad law into detailed rules through public notice and comment
- Explain how an enforcement pyramid uses escalating responses to get compliance
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
Why a government checks your medicine before you can buy it
In 1960 a new reviewer at the US Food and Drug Administration, Frances Kelsey, got an application to sell thalidomide. The drug was already approved in Canada and more than 20 European and African countries. It was marketed as a sedative and for morning sickness in pregnancy.
The law then let the FDA hold an application only 60 days at a time. Kelsey found the company's evidence thin, so she kept asking for more data every 60 days for over a year. In November 1961, doctors linked thalidomide to birth defects. Because of her, it never went on general sale in the US.
Your water reaches you through one set of pipes. Building a second network beside it would cost far more than it could earn. Economists call this a natural monopoly, where one firm can serve the whole market more cheaply than several could. Electricity grids and water systems are classic cases.
With no rival, the owner faces a captive market. People can't stop buying water or power, so an unchecked firm could raise prices or let service slide. That's why governments either run these networks themselves or regulate their prices and service.
A third common reason to regulate is harm to people outside the deal, such as pollution. Limits on what factories may release are among the most common rules there are.
Try to recallWhy is a water or electricity network usually regulated or run by the government?
It's a natural monopoly, because one network can serve everyone more cheaply than two. With no competitor and customers who can't go without, an unchecked owner could overcharge or let service slip. Regulation of prices and service, or public ownership, stands in for the missing competition.
Governments regulate where markets alone protect people badly, as with risks buyers can't see or a single network everyone depends on. Approval before sale and rules on monopoly prices are the two answers you've now seen.
Lessons in this topic
Why a government checks your medicine before you can buy it
See how the thalidomide disaster showed the danger of risks buyers can't see, and why water and power networks get special rules.
From a law to a rule to an inspector at the door
Follow how a US agency turns a broad law into detailed rules, and how regulators use a ladder of penalties to get firms to comply.
When the watchdog starts working for the industry
Learn George Stigler's theory of why regulated industries gain influence over their regulators, see two cases that fit, and weigh the theory's limits.
Too many rules or too few
See how US airline deregulation in 1978 cut fares, and how weak bank oversight fed the 2008 crisis, a cause still argued over.
Three quick stories from this topic
The 60-day stall
One FDA reviewer kept thalidomide off US shelves by asking for more data every 60 days
The FDA could hold a drug application only 60 days at a time, so Frances Kelsey kept renewing her requests for over a year. Thalidomide was already sold in Canada and more than 20 European and African countries.
What she prevented
Thalidomide caused severe birth defects in more than 10,000 babies across 46 countries. In the US, 17 malformed births were tied to sample pills handed out to doctors.
What changed
In 1962 Congress passed the Kefauver-Harris Amendment. Drug makers now had to prove a drug safe and effective before approval.
Reports written in pencil
US drilling inspectors let oil firms fill in their own inspection reports in pencil
A 2010 inspector general report found that the inspectors then traced over the pencil in pen and filed the reports. Staff at the Minerals Management Service had also accepted meals, sports tickets and gifts from the companies.
Two jobs in one agency
The agency collected oil and gas lease money and also policed drilling safety. After the Deepwater Horizon spill in 2010, the government split it into three.
A name for it
Economists call this regulatory capture, when a watchdog starts serving the industry it oversees. Firms with big stakes watch a regulator far more closely than the public does.
The six-year wait
A US airline waited over six years for a ruling on cheap New York to Los Angeles fares
World Airways applied to the Civil Aeronautics Board in 1967. The board studied the request for more than six years, then dismissed it because the record had gone "stale." Delays like this fed the push for the 1978 deregulation act.
Regulated like a utility
From 1938 the board set US interstate airline fares, routes and schedules. Most major airlines, with profits close to guaranteed, favored the system.
After the change
A 1996 government audit found average fares per passenger mile about 9% lower in 1994 than in 1979. Busy long routes gained more than short ones.
Sources
- Thalidomide scandal, Wikipedia
- Frances Oldham Kelsey, Wikipedia
- Information asymmetry, Wikipedia
- Regulation, Wikipedia
- Kefauver-Harris Amendment, Wikipedia
- Natural monopoly, Wikipedia
- Minerals Management Service, Wikipedia
- Airline Deregulation Act, Wikipedia





