Politics & Law · Public policy & regulation
How public policy is made
How a problem finally gets a government's attention, which tools officials can reach for, why a funded program can stall on the ground, and why policies are so hard to undo.

What you will learn
- Explain why a problem reaches a government's agenda only when a problem, a solution and political support line up
- Describe how a policy entrepreneur joins the three streams when a policy window opens
- Describe the four resources governments use as policy tools in Christopher Hood's scheme
- Explain why the UK soft drinks levy changed recipes by aiming at drink makers instead of shoppers
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
Why a known problem can wait years for action
In 2002, a national survey found that 47% of men working in Irish pubs and clubs often breathed secondhand smoke on the job. Smoking was already banned on buses, in cinemas and in schools. So why did pubs wait until 2004?
The political scientist John Kingdon offered an answer in 1984. He described three streams that flow through government, each on its own schedule. The problem stream holds the conditions people come to see as problems. The policy stream holds the solutions experts work up. The politics stream is the public mood, elections and who holds power.
Because the streams run separately, a solution can sit on a shelf for years with no problem anyone cares about. A problem can be obvious with no workable fix. Action comes when all three meet, a moment Kingdon called a policy window. Windows stay open only a short time, so a missed one can mean years more waiting.
Someone has to join the streams. Kingdon called these people policy entrepreneurs. They push a favored solution for years, then tie it to a problem and a political moment when a window opens.
Luke Clancy, a doctor who campaigned for Ireland's ban, later told its story in Kingdon's terms. The problem was workers breathing smoke. The solution was the comprehensive ban that the campaign group ASH Ireland demanded. The politics came from cross-party support led by the health minister, Micheál Martin.
Opponents called the ban an attack on smokers' freedom. Mandate, the union for Dublin bar workers, answered that bar staff deserved the same protection as office workers. The ban took effect on 29 March 2004, with on-the-spot fines of up to 3,000 euros.
Try to recallWhat does a policy entrepreneur do in John Kingdon's model, and how did Ireland's 2004 smoking ban show it?
A policy entrepreneur pushes a favored solution and joins the streams when a window opens. In Ireland, campaigners tied a full workplace ban to the problem of workers breathing smoke. Cross-party support led by health minister Micheál Martin supplied the politics.
A problem gets action when it's recognized, a workable solution is ready and the politics allow it, all at once. Policy entrepreneurs watch for that moment and join the pieces before the window shuts.
Lessons in this topic
Why a known problem can wait years for action
Learn John Kingdon's three streams, and see how Ireland's 2004 workplace smoking ban got through when they lined up.
The four tools every government reaches for
Sort what governments do into informing, ordering, paying and providing, and see how a UK sugar levy changed drinks by targeting their makers.
Why a funded program can stall on the ground
Follow a 1960s jobs program in Oakland that had money and support but barely moved, and meet the front-line workers who turn rules into real policy.
Why policies are so hard to undo
See how a wartime decision still shapes US health insurance, and how Social Security built the voters who defend it.
Three quick stories from this topic
Seniors who learned to vote
American seniors went from the least politically active age group to the most
By the early 1980s older Americans out-voted younger adults, gave more to campaigns and contacted officials more. Political scientist Andrea Campbell traces the change to Social Security. The program gave seniors income, free time and a clear stake in what government did.
Put to the test
In 1981 the Reagan administration tried to trim early-retirement benefits. Seniors wrote to Congress in waves, and the proposals were dropped.
A program that makes voters
Low-income seniors, who rely on Social Security most, are more active than wealthy ones when it's at stake. That narrows the usual gap between rich and poor voters.
Seventy sign-offs
A program needing 70 approvals, each 99% likely, has only coin-flip odds
Jeffrey Pressman and Aaron Wildavsky counted about 70 clearances behind a 1960s jobs program in Oakland. Multiply 0.99 by itself 70 times and you get 0.49. Three years in, only $3 million of $23 million had been spent.
The Oakland case
The federal government announced the money in 1966 for public works meant to create jobs. Most of what got spent went on a freeway overpass and architects' fees.
Why it matters
Every extra sign-off adds another chance of a stall. The authors subtitled their 1973 book "Why It's Amazing that Federal Programs Work at All."
The sugar that vanished
UK soft drinks lost 43.7% of their sugar per 100ml after a tax on their makers
Public Health England measured the drinks covered by the levy between 2015 and 2019. Sales by volume rose 14.9% in the same years. The tax only applied above 5 grams of sugar per 100ml, so companies cut sugar to escape it.
Aimed at makers
Producers and importers paid the levy from April 2018, not shoppers. That gave companies a direct reason to change their recipes.
A line to get under
Drinks with 8 grams of sugar or more per 100ml paid the higher rate. Getting below 5 grams meant paying nothing at all.
Sources
- 2004, A new beginning for Smokefree Ireland, Luke Clancy, via the Health Research Board National Drugs Library (Ireland)
- Smoking in Ireland, Wikipedia
- Multiple streams framework, Wikipedia
- John W. Kingdon, Wikipedia
- How Social Security encourages older Americans to be active citizens, Andrea Louise Campbell, Scholars Strategy Network
- Pressman and Wildavsky's implementation model, Atlas of Public Management (Ian D. Clark)
- The EDA in Oakland: A Case That Catalyzed a Field, Laurence J. O'Toole Jr., Public Administration Review (2011), via vLex
- Sugar reduction: report on progress between 2015 and 2019, Public Health England, GOV.UK
- Check if your drink is liable for the Soft Drinks Industry Levy, HM Revenue and Customs, GOV.UK





