Economics & Money · Taxes, public spending & inequality
Public goods and free riders
Lighthouses, defense and a stable climate help people whether or not they pay. See why markets supply too little of such goods, how taxes fix it, and where the line falls.

What you will learn
- Explain what it means for a good to be non-rival
- Explain what it means for a good to be non-excludable, and why a pure public good needs both traits
- Explain why voluntary payment falls short for a public good
- Explain how compulsory taxes solve the free-rider problem, and what they cost
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
Why a lighthouse isn't like a loaf of bread
A loaf of bread is simple. If you eat it, nobody else can. Economists call that rival, meaning one person's use leaves less for others.
A lighthouse is different. Its beam guides one ship past the rocks, and the next ship sees exactly the same light. That's non-rival. One more user costs nothing extra and takes nothing away.
Paul Samuelson put it formally in 1954. Each person's use of such a good, he wrote, "leads to no subtractions from any other individual's consumption." Knowledge works the same way. You can use the rules of multiplication without stopping anyone else from using them. Street lights are another case, since your view of the sidewalk takes nothing from mine.
The second trait is about fences. A good is non-excludable when you can't keep non-payers from using it, or doing so would cost too much. Say a firm puts on a fireworks show. People can watch from their windows and backyards, so the firm can't charge them.
National defense has both traits. Defending one person in an area defends their neighbors too, and nobody can be left out. A good with both traits is a pure public good, and pure public goods are rare.
Many goods have one trait without the other. A film in an uncrowded cinema is non-rival, because one more viewer costs nothing. The cinema can still sell tickets and turn away anyone without one.
Try to recallWhat two traits make national defense a pure public good?
Defense is non-rival, because protecting one person in an area doesn't leave less protection for the neighbor. It's also non-excludable, because there's no way to defend a city while leaving out the households that didn't pay.
A public good is non-rival, so one more user takes nothing away, and non-excludable, so nobody can be kept out. Bread has neither trait. National defense has both.
Lessons in this topic
Why a lighthouse isn't like a loaf of bread
Learn the two traits that make something a public good, and why so few goods have both.
Why nobody pays for the fireworks
See why voluntary payment falls short for goods nobody can be kept from, and how taxes and other tricks get them paid for.
Private, public, club and common goods
Use the two traits to sort any good into one of four boxes, and see how technology, law and crowding move goods between them.
Public goods with no world government to pay
See why ending a disease or slowing climate change is so hard to fund across nearly 200 countries, and why some global goods are easier than others.
Three quick stories from this topic
Britain's private lighthouses
Many of Britain's lighthouses were once built and run by private owners
Owners held rights from the crown to charge light dues, which ships paid when they called at port. In 1836 a law forced several private lighthouses to sell to Trinity House, which still oversees UK lighthouses.
Coase's challenge
Economists long used the lighthouse as the model public good. Ronald Coase argued in 1974 that charging at ports made private lighthouses work.
The critics' reply
The right to collect light dues came from the crown, so ships couldn't refuse to pay. Critics say that, not the market, is what made it work.
Smallpox's 26-day payback
The US earns back everything it gave to end smallpox every 26 days
The global campaign cost about $23 million a year from 1967 to 1979. Since smallpox is gone, the US no longer has to vaccinate against it or treat it, and by one estimate those savings repay its whole contribution every 26 days.
A weakest-link good
Smallpox survived as long as any country still had cases. The last natural case was in Somalia in 1977.
Why rich countries paid
Ending the disease freed every country from vaccinating, so even countries without cases gained.
Toll roads and golf clubs
To an economist, a quiet toll road and a golf club are the same kind of good
Both can charge a fee to keep people out, yet one more user costs almost nothing until crowding sets in. Economists call these club goods, a box between private goods like bread and public goods like defense.
Two traits, four boxes
Goods are sorted by whether one person's use leaves less for others, and by whether non-payers can be kept out.
Crowding changes the box
At rush hour each extra car slows everyone else, so a toll road starts to behave like a rival good.
Sources
- Public good (economics), Wikipedia
- The Economy 1.0, Unit 12: Markets, efficiency, and public policy, CORE Econ
- Public Goods, The Concise Encyclopedia of Economics, Tyler Cowen, Econlib (Liberty Fund)
- The Lighthouse in Economics, Wikipedia
- Organizations and efficiency in lighthouse provision: the English case revisited (2021 draft), Oliver Buxton Dunn, Dan Bogart, Eduard Alvarez-Palau and Leigh Shaw-Taylor, UC Irvine
- Case 1: Eradicating Smallpox, in Millions Saved, Center for Global Development
- Club good, Wikipedia





