Business & Organizations · Sales & pricing
Negotiation
What decides who gets the better deal. See why your best option without a deal sets your power, how to find trades that leave both sides better off, and what experiments say about the first offer.

What you will learn
- Explain what a best alternative to a negotiated agreement is and how it sets a walk-away point
- Find the zone where a deal is possible and explain why a better alternative beats clever tactics
- Distinguish a negotiating position from the interest behind it
- Explain how trading across issues that each side values differently creates value
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
Your best option without a deal is your real power
A dealer offers you a used car for $7,500. Across town, another dealer has a better one for $6,500. You now know something the first dealer may not, and it changes everything about the talk.
Negotiation researchers Roger Fisher and William Ury named this idea in 1981. Your BATNA is your best alternative to a negotiated agreement. It's the best you can do if the other side says no and you walk away.
Here the $6,500 car is your BATNA. It sets your walk-away point. Unless the first dealer beats it, you leave and buy the other car.
The rule is simple. Take a deal that's better than your BATNA. If it isn't, push for more or walk. Your BATNA isn't your dream outcome. It's what you can get without them.
Each side has a walk-away point. Say a job candidate won't take less than $70,000, and the employer won't pay more than $75,000. Any salary between those works for both. That overlap is the zone of possible agreement.
Now say the employer's limit is $65,000. There's no overlap, so no salary satisfies both. Both are better off taking their alternatives, and no amount of clever talk changes that.
Salary isn't the only thing in play. Vacation time and work assignments belong in the zone too, which a later lesson builds on.
Try to recallWhy does improving your best alternative to a deal usually strengthen your position more than a clever bargaining tactic?
Your alternative sets your walk-away point, so a better one means you can refuse more deals. Knowing you can leave, you concede less and push harder. A tactic changes how you talk, but not what happens if the talks fail.
Before any negotiation, work out your best option without a deal and guess at theirs. That tells you where you'd walk, whether a deal can exist, and how hard you can push.
Lessons in this topic
Your best option without a deal is your real power
Learn what your walk-away point is, how to tell whether a deal is possible at all, and why a better fallback beats any bargaining trick.
Two sisters, one orange and what each really wanted
Tell what someone demands from why they demand it, and see how trading across issues that each side values differently can leave both better off.
Should you make the first offer
See why the first number on the table drags the final price toward it, how to keep the other side's opening from steering you, and when going first backfires.
When the deal has an audience and a next round
See how bargaining changes when the same sides meet again, when agents bargain on someone's behalf, and when a deal has to be approved back home.
Three quick stories from this topic
Agents' own homes
Real estate agents sold their own homes for about 3.7% more than similar client homes
They also kept their own homes on the market about 9.5 days longer. An agent earns only a small cut of any extra price, so holding out for more pays the agent little when it's a client's house.
Who gains from waiting
Waiting for a better offer is extra work for the agent, while nearly all the extra money goes to the seller.
Bargaining through someone
Whenever an agent negotiates for you, ask how their pay changes if they push harder.
Go first, do better
In bargaining experiments, whoever made the first offer got the better deal
That held whether the buyer or the seller went first. Across three experiments, the opening number also strongly predicted the final price. The first offer becomes the anchor that every later number is measured against.
The antidote
The edge vanished when the other negotiator thought about the opener's alternatives or held a target of their own.
Not always
Later studies found going first can backfire, for instance when the opening reveals what you'd gladly agree to anyway.
The Sinai deal
Israel and Egypt both wanted the Sinai, but one for security and the other for sovereignty
The 1979 peace treaty returned the Sinai to Egypt, and Egypt agreed to keep it demilitarized. Behind the same demand for the land were two different needs, and one deal could meet both.
Positions and interests
Getting to Yes uses the case to show the gap between what each side demands and why it demands it.
Why it worked
Handing back the land met Egypt's interest. Keeping it free of troops met Israel's.
Sources
- Best alternative to a negotiated agreement, Wikipedia
- BATNA, Beyond Intractability, University of Colorado (Spangler, updated by Burgess, 2012)
- Zone of possible agreement (ZOPA), Beyond Intractability, University of Colorado (Spangler, updated by Burgess, 2013)
- How to find the ZOPA in business negotiations, Program on Negotiation, Harvard Law School (Shonk, 2020)
- Market distortions when agents are better informed: the value of information in real estate transactions, Review of Economics and Statistics (Levitt and Syverson, 2008), on EconPapers and NBER
- First offers as anchors: the role of perspective-taking and negotiator focus, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (Galinsky and Mussweiler, 2001), abstract via Europe PMC
- Getting to Yes, Wikipedia
- Egypt-Israel peace treaty, Wikipedia





