Business & Organizations · Sales & pricing

Why subscriptions live on retention

A subscription earns its money from the people who stay. Work out how a few points of retention change what each subscriber is worth, and where keeping customers turns into trapping them.

4 short lessons · about 20 minutes · 3 sources · updated November 2026

A ring of five customers; later three remain inside, two walk away, and two new customers stand outside the ring.

What you will learn

  • Calculate retention and churn rates from counts of subscribers
  • Multiply retention rates to find the share of a group that's still subscribed
  • Calculate a subscriber's lifetime value from margin, retention and a discount rate
  • Explain why small gains in retention raise lifetime value so sharply

Lesson 1 of 4 · 5 min

How 5% monthly churn loses nearly half your subscribers

Before you readA streaming service starts with 1,000 subscribers. It keeps 80% of them through year one, then 85% of the remaining ones through year two, then 90% of those through year three. How many of the 1,000 are still paying?

Correct.Not quite. The answer is 612 subscribers.

612 are left. Each year's rate applies only to the customers still there, so the rates multiply. This lesson is about how that makes a group shrink.

A streaming service that keeps 95% of its subscribers every month sounds healthy. Twelve months later, nearly half the people it started with are gone. To see why, you need the two rates every subscription business tracks.

A subscription business can track them because it sees each customer leave. Someone has to contact the company to cancel a phone contract, and a theater company can tell when a patron hasn't renewed.

The retention rate for a period is the share of customers active at the end of the last period who are still active at the end of this one. The churn rate is the share of those same customers who dropped out. The two always add up to 100%.

Say a streaming service has 1,000 subscribers at the start of a year, and 800 of them are still paying at the end. Its retention rate for the year is 80%, and its churn rate is 20%.

People who sign up during the year aren't part of that calculation. Both rates follow only the customers who were there at the start. That's how a service can grow in total while losing a large share of the people it already had.

Check yourselfA gym starts the year with 500 members on annual contracts. By the end of the year, 400 of them are still paying and 150 new members have joined. What's the gym's churn rate for the year?

Correct.Not quite. The answer is 20%, since 100 of the original 500 left.

Churn is measured against the members who were there at the start. Of those 500, 100 left, so churn is 20% and retention is 80%. The 150 new members make the total grow, and dividing by the year-end total mixes them into a rate that should follow only the starting group.

Retention compounds. Each period's rate applies only to the customers left after the period before, so the rates multiply.

Say the streaming service keeps 80% of its 1,000 subscribers through the first year, 85% of the remaining ones through the second and 90% through the third. The share still paying is 0.80 times 0.85 times 0.90, or 0.612. So 612 of the original 1,000 are left, and 388 have gone.

The marketing professors Peter Fader and Bruce Hardie call that share the survivor function. It's the probability that a customer is still active at a given time.

Now the monthly case. Keeping 95% of subscribers every month means multiplying 0.95 by itself 12 times, which gives about 0.54. So 46% of the group, nearly half, is gone within a year.

Try to recallA software company keeps 70% of a group of new subscribers through the first year and 90% of the remaining ones through the second. What share of the original group is still subscribed after two years?

The share still subscribed is 63%. The first year leaves 70% of the group, and the second year keeps 90% of those, so the share is 0.70 times 0.90, or 0.63.

So never read a churn rate without its time period. Losing 5% a year leaves 95% of a group after twelve months. Losing 5% a month leaves about 54%.

To see what a group of subscribers will look like later, multiply its retention rates. That projection is how a business estimates how long its customers will stay and what they're worth.

Lessons in this topic

  1. How 5% monthly churn loses nearly half your subscribers

    Work out retention and churn from subscriber counts, and see how losing 5% of subscribers a month adds up to nearly half within a year.

    Essentials · 5 min

  2. What a subscriber is worth

    Put a dollar value on a subscriber with a simple formula, and see why a few points of retention move it so much.

    Essentials · 5 min

  3. Why retention climbs without anyone getting more loyal

    Work out yearly retention from a real survival table, and see why a group's retention can climb even when no customer grows more loyal.

    Deeper · 5 min

  4. Keeping customers or trapping them

    See how much sellers can gain when canceling is a hassle, what the FTC alleged about Amazon Prime and what the settlement requires.

    Deeper · 5 min

Three quick stories from this topic

How monthly churn adds up

A service that keeps 95% of its subscribers each month loses almost half in a year

Each month's 95% applies only to the people left after the month before, so the losses pile up. After twelve months about 54 of every 100 subscribers remain. A loss that looks small on a monthly report has taken the other 46.

Why rates multiply

Each month's rate applies only to the subscribers who stayed through the month before. The marketing professors Peter Fader and Bruce Hardie call the result the survivor function.

Rates can move

A steady rate is a simplification. In one group of subscribers that Fader and Hardie reanalyzed, the yearly retention rate rose every year for 12 years.

Amazon's "Iliad" process

Inside Amazon, the process for canceling Prime was called Iliad, like Homer's war epic

The Federal Trade Commission reported the name in 2023, when it charged that the process was built to stop subscribers from leaving. They had to find it, then click through pages of offers to stay. Amazon settled in 2025 for $2.5 billion.

What the settlement requires

Amazon must pay a $1 billion civil penalty and $1.5 billion in refunds. It must also let people cancel Prime by the same method they used to sign up.

What the order settled

The FTC describes the order as settling allegations. It took on the force of law when a federal judge in Seattle approved and signed it in September 2025.

Retention that climbs

In one subscriber group, 37% left in the first year and only about 5% in the twelfth

It looks like loyalty growing with time. Yet a model in which no customer's chance of leaving ever changes fits the data closely. The likeliest leavers go first, so each year's survivors are harder to lose.

The likeliest leavers go first

Fader and Hardie's model gives each customer a fixed chance of leaving that differs from person to person. High-churn customers drop out early, so the group that's left stays longer.

Why simple curves miss it

Curves fitted to seven years of data on a second group of customers missed year 12 survival by 30% to 92%. The sorting model missed by 4%.

Sources

This topic is part of Judging a business from the outside in, a guided path through related topics.

  • Pricing around value, costs and alternatives

    A price has to cover costs and still beat what the customer would do without you. See why a 20% discount can need twice the sales, and what a retailer's cut leaves the maker.

    4 lessons · 17 min

  • Negotiation

    What decides who gets the better deal. See why your best option without a deal sets your power, how to find trades that leave both sides better off, and what experiments say about the first offer.

    4 lessons · 16 min

  • The sales funnel

    Few strangers become customers in one step. See how a sales team moves people from first contact to a signed deal, how to read the numbers at each stage, and how selling to a business differs.

    4 lessons · 16 min

  • Why teams need clear decision rights

    Tell advice apart from the authority to decide, work out which decisions belong near the work, and keep a clear decision-maker open to the facts.

    4 lessons · 21 min

  • Competitive advantage

    Why some firms earn more than their rivals for years. See how lower costs or a product buyers pay extra for create an edge, and why an edge lasts only while rivals can't copy it.

    4 lessons · 16 min

  • Bottlenecks and the pace of a system

    Find the step that limits a production line, see why a desk that never stops working can still fall behind, and use the same thinking to find the tasks that set a project's finish date.

    4 lessons · 17 min

All business & organizations topics · Take the quiz