Business & Organizations · Entrepreneurship & innovation

Why good inventions spread slowly

The first smartphone went on sale in 1994. See what separates an invention from its adoption, and what sets the pace of its spread.

4 short lessons · about 20 minutes · 7 sources · updated November 2026

A street where one of four figures holds a bulky phone, and the same street later with three of the four holding slim phones.

What you will learn

  • Distinguish the date an invention appears from the pace at which people adopt it
  • Describe the S-shaped curve that the spread of a new product usually follows
  • Identify the five characteristics of an innovation that Everett Rogers said potential adopters judge
  • Explain why an innovation with a large advantage can still fail to spread

Lesson 1 of 4 · 5 min

The first smartphone went on sale in 1994

Before you readThe phone since called the first true smartphone went on sale in 1994. In 2011, what share of American adults owned a smartphone?

Correct.Not quite. The answer is 35%.

Only 35% of American adults had a smartphone in 2011. This lesson shows why the date something is invented says little about when people will use it.

In August 1994, BellSouth Cellular began selling a phone that could also send faxes and email. The IBM Simon had a 4.5-by-1.4-inch touchscreen, an address book, a calendar and a notepad. It has since been called the first true smartphone.

It cost $899 with a two-year contract, or $1,099 without one. Its battery lasted only an hour. BellSouth sold about 50,000 before the Simon was discontinued in February 1995.

Smartphones took a long time to become ordinary. When Pew Research Center first asked Americans about smartphone ownership in 2011, 35% of adults had one. In 2026 the figure was 91%.

So the date something is invented says little about when people will use it. Two terms help. Adoption is what one person does, from first hearing about an innovation to taking it up. Diffusion is the way an innovation spreads through a whole group, and it can take decades.

Economists Diego Comin and Bart Hobijn tracked 15 technologies across 166 countries over two centuries. On average, a country adopted a technology 45 years after it was invented.

Check yourselfThe IBM Simon smartphone went on sale in 1994, yet only 35% of American adults owned a smartphone in 2011. What does that gap show?

Correct.Not quite. The answer is An invention's first sale says little about when most people adopt it.

Invention and adoption are separate events, and the gap between them can be long. The Simon went on sale in 1994, but when Pew first measured smartphone ownership in 2011, only 35% of American adults had one. Weak sales of one early model can't show that people didn't want smartphones, since 91% of adults owned one by 2026. And the Simon did far more than make calls. It had a touchscreen, email and a calendar.

Plot the share of people who have adopted something against time, and the line usually traces an S. It rises slowly at first, climbs steeply through the middle, then flattens as it nears its ceiling. Researchers have measured S-curves for the radio, the refrigerator, the telephone, the personal computer and the internet.

Pew's smartphone surveys catch the steep middle and the flattening top. Ownership among American adults rose from 35% in May 2011 to 77% in November 2016, a gain of 42 percentage points in about five and a half years. By February 2021 it had reached 85%, a gain of just 8 points in a little over four years.

Growth slows near the top because fewer people are left who haven't adopted. Pew's figure was 91% in 2024, and 91% again in 2025 and 2026.

The same shape turned up in the study that made diffusion a field of its own. In 1943 Ryan and Gross studied how Iowa farmers took up hybrid corn seed. Adoption spread over more than ten years, and in their first years with the new seed most farmers planted only a fraction of their fields with it.

Try to recallPew found smartphone ownership among American adults rose from 35% in 2011 to 77% in 2016, then to 85% in 2021. Describe the shape of that adoption curve and explain why growth slowed.

It's the steep middle and flattening top of an S-curve. Ownership rose 42 percentage points in about five and a half years, then only 8 points in a little over four more years. Growth slowed because most adults already owned a smartphone, so fewer people were left to adopt one.

The fax machine waited longer than the smartphone. A commercial fax service ran between Paris and Lyon in 1865, 11 years before the telephone was invented. Fax machines became common in offices in the 1980s.

So when you hear that something has been invented, ask what it still costs people to use. For the Simon, that was $899 and a battery that died in an hour.

Lessons in this topic

  1. The first smartphone went on sale in 1994

    Find out why the first smartphone sold only about 50,000 units, and what shape the spread of a new product usually takes.

    Essentials · 5 min

  2. The five things people weigh before adopting

    People judge five things before taking up something new, and one bad answer can sink an innovation with a clear benefit.

    Essentials · 5 min

  3. How word of mouth makes the S-curve

    Use the Bass model to work out how many people adopt in a year, and see why yearly adoption rises to a peak and then falls.

    Deeper · 5 min

  4. Knowing about an invention isn't the same as using it

    See why navies, countries and firms can take decades to use something they already know about, and why adopting slowly isn't always a mistake.

    Deeper · 5 min

Three quick stories from this topic

A fax service in 1865

A commercial fax service ran between Paris and Lyon in 1865, before the telephone existed

The Italian physicist Giovanni Caselli opened it 11 years before the telephone was invented. Fax machines then stayed a niche product for over a century, and became common in offices only in the 1980s. An early invention date says little about when people take something up.

Invention isn't adoption

A study of 15 technologies in 166 countries found that, on average, countries adopted a technology 45 years after it was invented.

What people weigh

People judge a new thing by its advantage, how well it fits their habits, how easy it is, whether they can see it working and whether they can try it first.

The 1994 smartphone

The IBM Simon, since called the first smartphone, went on sale in 1994 for $899

It had a touchscreen, email, a calendar and fax, and its battery lasted an hour. BellSouth sold about 50,000 in six months. When Pew first measured smartphone ownership, in 2011, only 35% of American adults had one.

Smartphones came later

Pew's first survey of smartphone ownership, in 2011, found that 35% of American adults owned one. By 2025 the share was 91%.

Invention isn't adoption

A study of 15 technologies in 166 countries found that, on average, countries adopted a technology 45 years after it was invented.

48 years to use the cure

The Royal Navy took 48 years to act on an experiment showing citrus treated scurvy

Ship's surgeon James Lind tried different remedies on twelve sick sailors in 1747, and those given oranges and lemons did best. His account filled a few paragraphs of a long book and had little impact. The Admiralty agreed to issue lemon juice to all warships in 1795.

Knowing isn't adopting

Much of the delay in taking up an innovation comes after people already know about it. Evidence in print doesn't spread itself.

What changed in 1794

A warship supplied with lemon juice reached India after four months without scurvy. Fleet commanders then demanded the same, and the Admiralty agreed the next year.

Sources

This topic is part of Judging a business from the outside in, a guided path through related topics.

  • Testing whether a problem is worth solving

    See how Zappos tested its idea with photographs of other shops' shoes, and learn to turn an idea into a problem, an assumption and a small test that could change your mind.

    4 lessons · 17 min

  • Starting a business

    What it takes to go from a first sale to a firm that lasts. See who pays a new firm's debts, where its first money comes from, who founds businesses and how many are still open five years on.

    4 lessons · 16 min

  • Steve Jobs and Apple

    Steve Jobs co-founded Apple in 1976, was pushed out at 30 and came back in 1997 to a company in deep trouble. See what he did each time, what Apple borrowed, and how much of its success was his.

    4 lessons · 16 min

  • Revenue, costs and a business model

    See why MoviePass had 3 million subscribers and still ran out of money. Follow a repair shop from who pays, to what one job leaves over, to how many jobs it takes to break even.

    4 lessons · 17 min

  • Supply chains

    A cotton T-shirt can cross the Pacific twice before it's worn out. See how goods, orders and money move between the firms in a chain, why lead time sets how much stock you need, and how firms trade low cost against safety.

    4 lessons · 16 min

  • Pricing around value, costs and alternatives

    A price has to cover costs and still beat what the customer would do without you. See why a 20% discount can need twice the sales, and what a retailer's cut leaves the maker.

    4 lessons · 17 min

All business & organizations topics · Take the quiz