Business & Organizations · Business models & strategy

Revenue, costs and a business model

See why MoviePass had 3 million subscribers and still ran out of money. Follow a repair shop from who pays, to what one job leaves over, to how many jobs it takes to break even.

4 short lessons · about 17 minutes · 6 sources · updated November 2026

What you will learn

  • Tell the person using a service apart from the party paying for it.
  • Explain why a product feature on its own isn't a complete business model.
  • Calculate contribution per sale from price and variable cost.
  • Explain why a positive contribution isn't the same as overall profit.

Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min

Who uses a service and who pays for it

Before you readMoviePass let subscribers see a movie every day for $9.95 a month and passed 3 million subscribers in a year. What happened to it in September 2019?

Correct.Not quite. The answer is It shut down.

It shut down, even though people loved the product. This lesson is about what a loved product can still be missing.

In August 2017 MoviePass cut its price to $9.95 a month. For that, a subscriber could see a movie in a theater every day. Within a year it had more than 3 million subscribers. In September 2019 it shut down.

People loved the product, so what was missing? A business model. That's the account of how an organization creates value for someone, delivers it and brings in enough money to keep going.

Say a bicycle-repair service promises commuters a working bike by the next morning. The commuter's real problem is getting to work. "We have a repair app" names a feature. It doesn't say who pays.

Ask who has the problem and who pays to solve it. A commuter might pay directly, say $45 a repair. Then the user and the customer are the same person.

Or an employer might buy repairs as a staff benefit. Say a firm with 400 employees pays $3 per employee each month. That's $1,200 a month, whether or not anyone books a repair.

If 30 employees book in a month, the service earns $40 a repair, a little under its retail price. But the money is steady and it arrives before the work. The employer is the customer, and the employees are the users.

The value proposition is the specific benefit you offer a defined customer. These two customers want different things. The commuter wants to reach work tomorrow. The employer might want fewer late arrivals, or a perk that helps it hire.

Each proposition stays a hypothesis until evidence shows that enough of those customers value it, at a price that keeps the service running.

Check yourselfAn employer pays for a bicycle-repair service that its employees use. Which statement describes the roles correctly?

Correct.Not quite. The answer is The employer is the customer and the employees are the users, and each may value the service for different reasons.

The employer decides to buy and pays for the service. The employees are the people whose problem it solves, so they're the users. Calling the employees the customers ignores who holds the budget. Calling the employer the user forgets that the benefit has to reach the employees, or the employer stops paying.

The model also needs delivery. That means skilled repairers, spare parts, booking, collection and enough capacity at the right hours.

Each way of charging sets different incentives. Charging per repair earns more when more bikes break. A flat employer fee earns the same either way, so the service does best when bikes need few repairs. At 60 repairs a month, the same $1,200 works out to $20 a repair.

Heavy use sank MoviePass. Its fee was about the price of one ticket, and it paid theaters the full ticket price for every movie. So a subscriber's second movie of the month cost it more than that subscriber paid.

Try to recallWhy isn't "we have an app" enough to count as a business model?

It doesn't say whose problem is solved, who pays, how the value is delivered or whether revenue and resources cover the work required.

Lessons in this topic

  1. Who uses a service and who pays for it

    See why a popular product isn't yet a business, and tell the person who uses a service from the customer who pays for it.

    Essentials · 4 min

  2. Revenue isn't what a business keeps

    Separate the money a sale brings in from the cost of that sale and the overhead it has to help cover, then find the break-even point.

    Essentials · 4 min

  3. Why growing can break a business that works

    See why some costs jump as a business grows, and how a small test shows whether it can still keep its promise at a larger size.

    Deeper · 4 min

  4. How many sales it takes to hit a profit target

    Work out how many jobs a shop needs to reach a profit target, then see how a rent rise moves that number.

    Deeper · 5 min

Three quick stories from this topic

Webvan's $1 billion order

The online grocer Webvan ordered $1 billion of warehouses and was bankrupt by 2001

It began taking orders around San Francisco in June 1999 and hoped to reach 26 cities. In 2000, its best year, it took in $178.5 million and spent $525.4 million. Its investors had pushed it to grow fast to get ahead of rivals.

Growth changes the costs

A service that works for a few customers can cost far more to run for many. Warehouses, trucks and extra shifts arrive in big steps, often before the customers do.

Test small first

A short pilot shows what serving more customers really costs. At its peak Webvan served ten US areas.

Costco's membership fees

In fiscal 2026 Costco's membership fees equaled half of its operating profit

In the year to August 2026 Costco sold $297 billion of goods and collected $5.9 billion in membership fees. Its operating profit was $11.7 billion. The goods themselves cost Costco 89 cents of every dollar they sold for.

What the goods left over

After the cost of the merchandise and $27 billion of running costs, the goods left about $5.8 billion. The membership fees added another $5.9 billion.

Revenue isn't profit

Sales count what customers paid. What a business keeps depends on what each sale cost and on the costs of running the whole operation.

MoviePass's flat fee

MoviePass charged $9.95 a month and paid theaters full price for every ticket

The fee was about the price of one ticket and let a subscriber see a movie every day. So a second trip in a month already cost MoviePass more than the subscriber paid. It passed 3 million subscribers in 2018 and shut down in 2019.

A flat fee rewards low use

A flat fee brings in the same money however much a customer uses the service. The seller does well when use is low and loses when use outruns the fee.

The cash ran out

In July 2018 MoviePass borrowed $5 million to keep operating after a service interruption. The next month it limited subscribers to three movies a month.

Sources

This topic is part of From a useful idea to a working business, a guided path through related topics.

  • What Kodak's fall really shows

    Kodak built the first digital camera and still went bankrupt. Follow the money from film to digital, and compare Kodak with Fujifilm, which lived through the same collapse.

    4 lessons · 20 min

  • Competitive advantage

    Why some firms earn more than their rivals for years. See how lower costs or a product buyers pay extra for create an edge, and why an edge lasts only while rivals can't copy it.

    4 lessons · 16 min

  • Types of business ownership

    A business can be one person, a partnership, a company or a cooperative. See who owns each kind, who pays its debts when it fails, how each raises money, and why growing firms usually become companies.

    4 lessons · 16 min

  • Debt, equity and who stays in control

    A business can raise money by borrowing or by selling shares. Work out what each choice does to the owners' returns and to who controls the company.

    4 lessons · 20 min

  • Toyota and lean production

    Toyota learned to build cars with little stock and few defects by letting any worker stop the line. See how just-in-time and built-in quality work, where they came from, and what happened when others copied them.

    4 lessons · 16 min

  • Profit is not the same as cash

    Follow a small firm through credit sales, expenses and payments to see how it can make a profit and still run short of cash.

    4 lessons · 17 min

All business & organizations topics · Take the quiz