Business & Organizations · People & management
Motivation at work
Pay matters, and so do the work itself and fair treatment. See what makes a job motivating, how its design changes the effort people give, and why fairness and mood can matter as much as the amount.

What you will learn
- Explain Herzberg's finding that satisfaction and dissatisfaction at work come from different factors
- Tell movement, which needs a fresh push each time, apart from motivation that comes from the work
- Name the five job features in Hackman and Oldham's model and say why autonomy and feedback weigh most
- Explain how meeting a person their work had helped changed the effort of fundraising callers
Lesson 1 of 4 · 5 min
Why fixing complaints doesn't make people keen
In the 1950s the psychologist Frederick Herzberg asked 203 engineers and accountants around Pittsburgh to describe two moments. One was a time they felt exceptionally good about their job. The other was a time they felt exceptionally bad. The two sets of stories didn't mirror each other.
The good stories were about the work itself. People talked about achievement, recognition for it, responsibility and growing in the job. The bad stories were mostly about the setting around the work. They named company policy, supervision, colleagues, working conditions, pay, status and security.
Herzberg called the first group motivators and the second hygiene factors, so his idea became the two-factor theory. Hygiene here means upkeep. Fair pay and decent conditions stop complaints, but they don't make anyone keen. In his words, the opposite of job satisfaction isn't dissatisfaction. It's simply no job satisfaction.
Later studies pooled 1,685 employees in 12 investigations. Of the things behind their best moments, 81% were motivators. Of the things behind their worst moments, 69% were hygiene factors.
Herzberg had a blunt name for the usual ways of getting work out of people. He called them KITA, an acronym for kicking someone in the rear. Threats were negative KITA. Bonuses, perks and promotions offered in return for effort were positive KITA, and most managers he met called that motivation.
He disagreed. A kick or a reward gets movement. You do the task, and when the boss wants it done again, the boss has to kick or pay again. He compared it to charging a battery that keeps running flat.
Motivation, in his sense, is a generator inside the person. It runs on the motivators, so the way to get it is to change the job. Give people responsibility for their own results, a whole unit of work, direct feedback and harder tasks to master. He called this job enrichment.
Try to recallWhy did Herzberg argue that a bonus for extra effort produces movement rather than motivation?
A bonus works from outside the person, so once it's paid the push is gone. To get the effort again, the boss has to offer another bonus, like recharging a battery. Motivation in Herzberg's sense comes from the work itself, such as responsibility and achievement, so it keeps going without a fresh push.
Pay, policy and decent conditions keep people from being unhappy at work. The wish to do more comes from the work itself, so making people keen means changing the job.
Lessons in this topic
Why fixing complaints doesn't make people keen
See why the things that make people unhappy at work and the things that make them want to do more sit on two separate lists.
What makes a job worth the effort
Learn the five features that make a job motivating, and how meeting the people it helps changed the effort of a team of fundraising callers.
Why fair pay can matter more than the amount
See how people judge their pay by comparing it with their peers', and what happened when university staff could look up what colleagues earned.
Do happier workers really get more done?
Find out how strongly job satisfaction tracks performance, why that link can't show which causes which, and how a study used the weather to test it.
Three quick stories from this topic
Five minutes with a student
Five minutes with one student more than doubled callers' fundraising a month later
University of Michigan fundraising callers who met a scholarship student spent 142% more weekly minutes on the phone and raised 171% more each week. Callers who only read a letter from the same student showed no significant gain.
A thankless job
The callers read from a script, heard far more no than yes, and most quit within two months.
Why it worked
Seeing one real person the money helped made the job's impact concrete, which knowing it in principle hadn't done.
Rainy weeks, fewer sales
Gloomy local weather made call-center staff less happy, and their sales fell with it
At 11 BT call centers, weekly happiness ratings dropped when local weather turned bad, and sales dropped too. Calls came from across the UK, so weather near one center didn't change demand there.
A natural experiment
Because sales can't cause the weather, a weather-driven drop in mood lets researchers test whether happiness drives sales.
Working better, not longer
Happier staff made more calls per hour and closed more of them, while attendance and breaks stayed the same.
The salary lookup experiment
When a newspaper put university salaries online, lower-paid staff grew less satisfied
Researchers told a random group of University of California staff about a 2008 salary website. Those paid below their department's median reported lower job satisfaction and more job hunting. Those paid above the median felt no better.
One-way news
Learning you earn less than peers hurt, while learning you earn more added nothing staff reported.
Why it matters
People judge pay by comparing themselves with peers, so the same salary can feel fine one day and unfair the next.
Sources
- Two-factor theory, Wikipedia
- Frederick Herzberg, Wikipedia
- One more time, how do you motivate employees? (Herzberg, 1968, Best of HBR reprint 2003), Harvard Business Review, copy hosted by East London NHS Foundation Trust
- Work and the art of motivation maintenance, Adam M. Grant, The Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania
- Impact and the art of motivation maintenance (Grant and others, 2007), Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, via University of Minnesota Experts
- Does employee happiness have an impact on productivity? (Bellet, De Neve and Ward, CEP Discussion Paper 1655, revised 2020), Centre for Economic Performance, London School of Economics
- Inequality at work: the effect of peer salaries on job satisfaction (Card, Mas, Moretti and Saez, 2012), American Economic Review, hosted by UC Berkeley





