Business & Organizations · People & management
Leadership in organizations
What leaders do and how much they matter. Tell leading apart from managing, see why no style fits every situation, and weigh what studies say about how far one chief executive moves a company.

What you will learn
- Tell leading apart from managing by where each gets its power
- Explain why most people in charge need both task and relationship skills
- Describe the directive, participative and hands-off styles and what each tends to produce
- Explain why the right style depends on the task, the time and the team
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
Leading and managing are different jobs
Say a team has a manager named on the org chart. Yet when something goes wrong, people turn to Priya, who has no title at all. Both of them have influence, and it comes from different places.
Managing is planning, organizing, directing and controlling work. Managers are appointed, and their power comes from the company's chain of authority. They often motivate with outside rewards such as pay, reviews and deadlines.
Leading is influence that followers grant. A leader often emerges from the group, because people accept them for their expertise, character or relationships. Leaders tend to motivate from the inside, by making the work feel worth doing. Lose the followers' trust and the leadership is gone, title or not.
Most people in charge need both. A good manager who can't win commitment ends up policing people. A good leader who can't plan leaves an inspired team without a schedule. Few jobs let you pick only one.
Studies at Ohio State, begun in 1945, found two kinds of leader behavior. Initiating structure is the task side, setting goals and deciding how work gets done. Consideration is the relationship side, building trust and caring about people.
Neither one worked best everywhere. The effects changed from one situation to the next, which is why the next question is about fit with the situation.
Try to recallWhat are the two kinds of leader behavior found in the Ohio State studies, and why does a person in charge usually need both?
Initiating structure is setting goals and organizing tasks. Consideration is building trust and caring for people. Without the first, a willing team drifts. Without the second, a well-planned team does the minimum.
Managing comes with the job title, and leading comes from the people who choose to follow. You can now tell the two apart and say why a person in charge needs task and people skills.
Lessons in this topic
Leading and managing are different jobs
Learn what separates leading from managing, why one person can be good at one and weak at the other, and why most jobs need both.
Giving orders, sharing decisions or stepping back
Meet the three leadership styles first tested in 1939, see what each tends to produce, and learn why the best one depends on the task and the team.
When a magnetic leader hides a failing company
See what charisma is, why struggling firms hunt for inspiring chiefs, and how one charismatic founder kept a broken company afloat for years.
How much does one chief executive really matter?
See how researchers separate a leader's effect from the company's, what a CEO's hospital stay reveals, and why we may credit leaders with too much.
Three quick stories from this topic
Leadership tested on boys
One of the first experiments on leadership styles studied clubs of 11-year-old boys
In 1939 Kurt Lewin and his students ran boys' clubs with leaders who gave orders, shared decisions or stood back. Their three labels are still the standard names for these styles.
Three ways to lead
Authoritarian leaders decided, democratic leaders let the group decide, and laissez-faire leaders left the boys alone.
No single winner
Later research found each style fits some situations, so there's no one best way to lead.
The boss in hospital
Firm profits fall when the chief executive lands in hospital, but not for other executives
Researchers used hospital stays to remove only the leader while the firm stayed the same. Profitability and investment fell during a chief executive's absence, which other senior executives' absences didn't cause.
Why hospital stays
Strong firms hire strong chiefs, so normal comparisons mix the leader with the company.
What it shows
Chief executives do move results, even if credit for them often runs ahead of the real effect.
The $9 billion promise
A blood-testing startup reached a $9 billion valuation with tests that didn't work
Theranos was founded in 2003 by 19-year-old Elizabeth Holmes. A celebrated board and huge investments came before anyone showed the tests worked as claimed. Holmes was convicted of fraud in 2022.
How it held up
Backers trusted a magnetic founder and a famous board instead of independent proof.
Why charisma works
Weber saw charisma as belief that followers grant, so it can run ahead of the evidence.
Sources
- The Nature of Leadership, OpenStax, Principles of Management
- Behavioral Approaches to Leadership, OpenStax, Principles of Management
- Leadership, Wikipedia
- Leadership style, Wikipedia
- Do CEOs Matter? Evidence from Hospitalization Events, Journal of Finance (Bennedsen, Perez-Gonzalez and Wolfenzon, 2020)
- Theranos, Wikipedia





