Arts & Culture · Cultural traditions & heritage

Who decides what heritage to preserve?

UNESCO's heritage list has an entry for the baguette, and what it protects is the bakers' know-how. See what living heritage is, who gets a say in safeguarding it, how a tradition can change and still carry on, and what the three UNESCO lists are for.

4 short lessons · about 22 minutes · 9 sources · updated November 2026

What you will learn

  • Explain what makes a practice intangible cultural heritage under the 2003 convention
  • Tell documenting a practice apart from helping people keep passing it on
  • Sort examples using the convention's domains, and say what falls outside its scope
  • Explain why practitioners' participation matters in identifying living heritage
  • Tell an international listing apart from the full work of safeguarding
  • Spot whose participation a project is missing, and what evidence of it would look like

Lesson 1 of 4 · 6 min

Why UNESCO protects the baker's skill, not the baguette

Before you readUNESCO's 2003 convention protects what people do, not things. A cathedral stands in a town. Which part of it could that convention protect?

Correct.Not quite. The answer is The music sung inside it.

The convention could protect the music sung there, the craft that maintains the building and the festivals around it. The structure belongs to a different convention.

Picture a handmade instrument in a museum case, safe from damp and careless hands. In the community it came from, the workshop where people learned to make and play it stands empty. Nobody is left to teach the music.

The object has survived. The practice around it may not.

UNESCO wrote a convention in 2003 for that second kind of loss. It covers intangible cultural heritage, meaning the practices, knowledge and skills that communities recognize as part of their heritage.

In 2022 UNESCO added the French baguette to its list of this heritage. The entry's name is "Artisanal know-how and culture of baguette bread." The loaf gets eaten. What's listed is what bakers know and do.

UNESCO's description is all practice. A baguette has only four ingredients, and bakers shape it by hand and mark it with shallow cuts, the baker's signature. The skill is passed on through training that combines school with work in a bakery.

Intangible doesn't mean cut off from things. The convention includes the instruments, objects and cultural spaces tied to a practice. But its subject is the living part, which passes between generations and which the objects alone don't contain.

Check yourselfUNESCO's 2003 convention covers intangible cultural heritage. Which of these is the clearest example of what it means by that?

Correct.Not quite. The answer is The skills bakers use to shape and bake a baguette.

The convention covers practices, knowledge and skills that people keep doing and passing on. A printed recipe is a record and an oven is an object. Both can be tied to the practice, but neither one is the living skill itself.

The convention's word for protecting this heritage is safeguarding, and it means more than keeping records. It means keeping the practice viable, able to continue. The measures it lists run from documentation and research to education, transmission and revitalization.

Transmission is passing the practice on. A recording keeps evidence of one performance. On its own it can't provide teachers, time to learn, materials or a place to practice.

UNESCO puts the priority plainly. What matters most is the knowledge and skill handed from one generation to the next, more than the performance or the object itself.

For the instrument tradition, a safeguarding project might pair recordings with lessons, planned together with the people who still play. The recording keeps one performance. The lesson passes the skill to new players. They do different jobs.

Museums and archives still matter. The useful question is what this particular practice needs to continue, and storing one object or file rarely answers it.

Try to recallWhy is a recording of traditional instrument-making useful, but not enough on its own to keep the practice alive?

It documents parts of the process, but keeping the practice going may also take teachers, learners, materials, time and community settings where the instruments are used and the skills passed on.

The convention also sketches where living heritage shows up. Article 2 names five domains.

They are oral traditions and expressions, the performing arts, social practices with rituals and festive events, knowledge and practices concerning nature and the universe, and traditional craftsmanship.

Article 2 introduces the five with a phrase meaning among others, so the list stays open. UNESCO guidance mentions cooking traditions, traditional games and sports, and traditional medicine as things a country could add.

Real practices rarely fit in one box. Take a harvest festival. It's a social practice and a festive event. It usually includes performing arts. It may depend on knowledge about seasons and land, and the objects carried through the streets may be traditional craftsmanship.

Sorting still helps, because it makes you ask which parts are actually getting support. A project that films the procession but ignores who still knows when to plant has covered one domain and missed another.

The domains also mark a boundary. Monuments, buildings and sites belong to a different UNESCO convention, the World Heritage convention of 1972.

So a cathedral as a structure isn't the subject of the 2003 text. The music sung in it, the craft that maintains it and the festivals held around it can be.

One place can involve both. Start by asking which convention applies, because one protects a thing and the other protects what people do.

Check yourselfA state wants support for the seasonal knowledge that tells fishers when and where to fish, which older fishers teach to younger ones. Which domain in Article 2 of UNESCO's intangible heritage convention fits it most directly?

Correct.Not quite. The answer is Knowledge concerning nature, because that's what is passed on.

What's being passed on here is knowledge about the natural world and how to act on it. Article 2 names that domain knowledge and practices concerning nature and the universe. Gear making and demonstration may be part of the picture, but they describe how the knowledge is used and taught. The heritage itself is the knowledge.

A museum can keep an object and an archive can keep a record. Living heritage is kept by the people who practice it and pass it on. That's why UNESCO's baguette entry lists the bakers' know-how, and why safeguarding asks what a practice needs to keep going.

Lessons in this topic

  1. Why UNESCO protects the baker's skill, not the baguette

    Living heritage is the knowledge and practice behind an object. See how UNESCO's 2003 convention defines it, what safeguarding takes beyond a recording, and where its five domains stop.

    Essentials · 6 min

  2. Who gets to say what counts as heritage

    UNESCO says nobody can decide for a community that a practice is its heritage. See what real participation by practitioners looks like, and how to spot when it's missing.

    Essentials · 5 min

  3. How a tradition can change and still carry on

    Safeguarding doesn't mean freezing a practice. See how to judge a change by what it does to passing the practice on, and where the convention draws limits that age can't override.

    Deeper · 6 min

  4. What UNESCO's three heritage lists are for

    One list gives living heritage visibility, one calls for help and one shares methods that work. See which fits a practice with few people left, and how a Vietnamese singing tradition came off the urgent list.

    Deeper · 5 min

Three quick stories from this topic

The baguette on UNESCO's list

What UNESCO listed as heritage in 2022 was the know-how of baguette bakers

The entry is named "Artisanal know-how and culture of baguette bread." UNESCO's lists of living heritage are for practices people pass on, so the entry describes the shaping, the scoring cuts and the apprenticeships. Monuments and sites fall under a separate convention.

What the entry describes

Four ingredients, shaping by hand, shallow cuts that UNESCO calls the baker's signature, and training that combines school with work in a bakery.

Why know-how

UNESCO says the importance of living heritage lies less in the cultural product than in the knowledge and skills passed from one generation to the next.

The carnival UNESCO delisted

UNESCO removed a 600-year-old Belgian carnival from its heritage list in 2019

The Aalst carnival, listed in 2010, had repeatedly shown images that mocked groups and insulted memories of genocide and slavery. It was the first element ever taken off the list. Under the convention, being old doesn't exempt a tradition from mutual respect.

Who asked

Belgium requested the removal on 5 December 2019, at the request of the city of Aalst. UNESCO's committee decided the same month.

The rule behind it

Article 2 of the 2003 convention considers only heritage compatible with human rights instruments, mutual respect among communities and sustainable development.

Off the urgent list

A Vietnamese singing tradition recovered enough for UNESCO to take it off its urgent list

In 2009 only 7 of Xoan singing's 31 oldest artists could still teach the old songs, and UNESCO listed it as needing urgent safeguarding in 2011. By 2017 its guilds had trained 62 successors and nearly doubled their membership, and it was moved to the Representative List.

What the urgent list is for

It holds practices that their communities and states consider need urgent measures to stay alive. Being inscribed helps mobilize international cooperation and assistance.

Who did the work

A safeguarding project trained singers and restored performance spaces. UNESCO's decision says it was the guilds' own knowledge and continuing practice that made the revival possible.

Sources

This topic is part of How form shapes an experience, a guided path through related topics.

  • What a tattoo can say

    Ötzi's 5,300-year-old tattoos may have been a pain treatment, a Māori moko was carved with a chisel, and tattooed ancestors once traded for muskets are coming home from museums.

    4 lessons · 23 min

  • Museums and contested objects

    How museums came to hold objects from all over the world, how provenance traces an object's owners, and where the fights over the Parthenon sculptures and the Benin Bronzes stand.

    4 lessons · 16 min

  • The Seven Wonders of the Ancient World

    Which seven buildings and statues Greek writers called sights worth the journey, what each one was, why only the Great Pyramid still stands, and whether the Hanging Gardens ever existed.

    4 lessons · 17 min

  • Impressionism

    Why a group of Paris painters in the 1870s showed their work without the Salon, painted light in quick visible strokes, and were mocked for it before their pictures became museum favorites.

    4 lessons · 16 min

  • Why fashions change

    Why hemlines, colors and silhouettes keep changing when the old clothes still work, how Paris couture set the pattern, and how styles now come up from the street as often as down from the catwalk.

    4 lessons · 16 min

  • How oral poets composed epics

    Singers built long epics from ready-made phrases as they performed. Recordings made in 1930s Yugoslavia suggest Homer's poems took shape the same way.

    4 lessons · 20 min

All arts & culture topics · Take the quiz