Arts & Culture · Cultural traditions & heritage
Museums and contested objects
How museums came to hold objects from all over the world, how provenance traces an object's owners, and where the fights over the Parthenon sculptures and the Benin Bronzes stand.

What you will learn
- Explain how private collections of curiosities became the first public museums
- Describe what a museum is for and why big museums hold objects from all over the world
- Explain what provenance is and how researchers trace it
- Distinguish objects that were bought, given, excavated or seized, and explain why 1970 matters
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
From private wonder rooms to public museums
In 1634 two gardeners, John Tradescant and his son, opened a room in Lambeth, London, that they called the Ark. It held plants, minerals, animals and objects from their travels, including a stuffed dodo. One visitor said you'd see more curiosities there in a day than in a lifetime of travel.
Rooms like this were called cabinets of curiosities. They spread through Europe in the 1500s and 1600s, mixing shells, art, antiquities and supposed monsters. Most belonged to rulers, aristocrats and rich collectors.
Then collections went public. Elias Ashmole gave his collection, built on the Tradescants', to Oxford University, and in 1683 the Ashmolean opened as Britain's first public museum.
In 1753 Parliament founded the British Museum around Sir Hans Sloane's 71,000 objects, bought for £20,000. It opened in 1759.
In 1793 revolutionary France opened the Louvre. Most of its art came from the king's collection, and the rest from property seized from the Church and from nobles who had fled. A king's treasure became the nation's.
So what is a museum for? In 2022 the International Council of Museums voted for a definition. A museum is a not-for-profit, permanent institution in the service of society that researches, collects, conserves, interprets and exhibits heritage, open to the public.
The job starts with collecting, and big museums grew as their countries grew. The Ashmolean itself says much of its collection was obtained as a result of colonial power.
Under Napoleon, the Louvre filled with art seized across Europe and from Egypt. Much of it went back after his defeat in 1815, though not all. That's how a few cities came to hold objects from everywhere.
Try to recallWhy do museums like the British Museum and the Louvre hold objects from all over the world?
Collecting is part of a museum's job, and these museums grew along with their countries' trade, wars and empires. The Ashmolean says much of its collection came through colonial power. Under Napoleon, the Louvre filled with art seized abroad, and some stayed after 1815.
Private cabinets of curiosities became public museums from 1683 on. They exist to collect, care for and show heritage, and the biggest grew with their countries' trade, wars and empires.
Lessons in this topic
From private wonder rooms to public museums
See how rich collectors' rooms of curiosities became the first public museums, and why the biggest museums ended up holding things from everywhere.
Provenance, the life story of an object
Learn how researchers trace who has owned an object, and why the way it reached a museum matters as much as where it came from.
The Parthenon sculptures and the Benin Bronzes
Hear each side in the dispute over the Parthenon sculptures in London, and see why the Benin Bronzes, taken in 1897, are a different kind of case.
The laws and deals behind returning objects
Find out which laws govern returns, what has actually gone back since 2017, and how big museums defend keeping what they hold.
Three quick stories from this topic
Loot auctioned for costs
Britain auctioned the Benin Bronzes to cover the cost of the raid that took them
British troops captured Benin City in February 1897, looted the royal palace and burned much of the city. The Admiralty sold the booty, and some pieces were up for sale by May that year.
Several thousand works
The Bronzes are plaques and sculptures, mostly brass, made for the palace mainly in the 1400s and 1500s. The British Museum holds about 900.
Now going back
Germany agreed in 2022 to hand over 1,130 and returned the first 20 that December.
Klimt's Adele goes home
A Klimt portrait stolen by the Nazis was returned to the family's heir in 2006
The Nazis took Klimt's 1907 portrait of Adele Bloch-Bauer in 1941, and it hung in Vienna's Belvedere for decades. Her husband's niece, Maria Altmann, fought Austria up to the US Supreme Court and won it back through arbitration.
Sold for $135 million
Altmann sold the painting in June 2006 to Ronald Lauder, who put it on show at the Neue Galerie in New York.
A fair solution
In 1998 governments agreed non-binding principles asking for just and fair solutions for art the Nazis confiscated.
One collector's 71,000 objects
The British Museum began with one collector's 71,000 objects, bought for £20,000
Sir Hans Sloane left his collection to the nation on condition that Parliament pay his heirs. Parliament founded the museum in 1753 to hold it, and the first galleries opened in 1759.
Cabinets before museums
Collections like Sloane's grew from cabinets of curiosities, which mixed shells, art, antiquities and supposed monsters.
First in Britain
Oxford's Ashmolean had already opened in 1683 as Britain's first public museum, built on the Tradescants' Ark.
Sources
- History of the Ashmolean, Ashmolean Museum, University of Oxford
- Cabinet of curiosities, Wikipedia
- British Museum, Wikipedia
- Louvre, Wikipedia
- Museum Definition, International Council of Museums
- Benin Expedition of 1897, Wikipedia
- Benin Bronzes, Wikipedia
- Portrait of Adele Bloch-Bauer I, Wikipedia





