Mind & Psychology · Habits & behavior
Willpower and self-control
Is willpower a fuel that runs out, or mostly a matter of dodging temptation? See what the marshmallow test and its re-runs found, and what people with good self-control do differently.

What you will learn
- Describe self-control as a conflict between a present desire and a longer-term goal
- Explain how a preference reversal makes the sooner reward win up close
- Describe what the marshmallow test asked of children and which waiting strategies worked
- Explain why a larger 2018 study shrank the link between waiting and later success
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
Why the cake beats the plan at the last moment
In one study, 205 adults carried beepers for a week. Each time it went off, they noted whether they wanted something just then. People reported a desire about half the times they were beeped, and the most common ones were food, drink and sleep.
Most of those desires caused no trouble. Wanting a sandwich at lunchtime clashes with nothing. A desire turns into a temptation only when acting on it would cut against a goal you hold, like the sandwich at 4pm when you're trying to eat less.
That clash is where self-control comes in. Psychologists use the term for steering your thoughts, feelings and actions when an impulse pulls against something you care about more. Roughly half the desires in the beeper study involved that kind of inner conflict.
Psychiatrist George Ainslie asked people a pair of questions. Would you rather have $50 now or $100 in six months? Many took the $50. Would you rather have $50 in three months or $100 in nine months? Now most waited for the $100.
The gap is six months both times. Only the distance changed. This flip is a preference reversal, and it happens because people shrink the value of a reward steeply over short delays and more gently over long ones. So a reward right in front of you feels far bigger than the same reward a few months off.
That explains the common pattern. On Sunday you plan to skip dessert all week. On Wednesday the cake arrives, and the sooner reward suddenly outweighs the goal. Rats and pigeons show the same reversal, so it isn't a quirk of human culture.
Try to recallSomeone plans on Sunday to skip dessert all week, then eats cake on Wednesday. How does a preference reversal explain the change?
People shrink a reward's value steeply when it's close and more gently when it's far away. On Sunday both the cake and the goal are distant, so the goal looks bigger. On Wednesday the cake is right there, its value balloons, and the sooner reward wins.
Self-control is the work of siding with a goal when a nearby desire pulls the other way. That work is hardest up close, because a reward in reach feels much bigger than it did when you made the plan.
Lessons in this topic
Why the cake beats the plan at the last moment
Learn what psychologists mean by self-control, and why a choice that looks easy from a distance flips when the reward is in front of you.
What the marshmallow test really predicted
Learn what Walter Mischel's preschoolers did while they waited for a second treat, and what a much larger re-run found about the link to later success.
Does willpower run out like fuel
Learn the idea that self-control drains with use, the radish study that launched it, and what happened when dozens of labs tried to repeat it.
People with good self-control resist less
Learn why people high in self-control report fewer struggles with temptation, and the strategies that stop an impulse before it grows.
Three quick stories from this topic
The shrinking marshmallow link
A re-run of the marshmallow test with 10 times more children found half the famous link
Tyler Watts and colleagues followed 552 children from a US study. Waiting longer at age 4 predicted better test scores at 15, but the link fell by two thirds once family background and early abilities were counted.
The original
Walter Mischel's follow-ups tracked 35 to 89 children, mostly from the Stanford community, and linked waiting to higher SAT scores.
Why it shrank
A bigger, more varied sample showed that much of the link reflected a child's circumstances, not willpower itself.
The radish study re-tested
Thirty-six labs tested whether willpower runs out and found no reliable effect
The project, led by one of the idea's own champions, tested 3,531 people in 2021. An earlier project across 23 labs had also found almost nothing.
Where it began
In 1998, people who ate radishes instead of chocolates gave up sooner on impossible puzzles, which suggested self-control drains with use.
Why it's still argued
Defenders say the tasks may not have tired people enough. Critics say a strong effect would have shown up with so many people.
Self-control without struggle
People with the most self-control try to resist temptation less often than others
In a week of tracking 7,827 everyday desires, high scorers felt just as many desires as others. Theirs were weaker and caused less inner conflict, so there was less to fight.
Habits do the work
People high in self-control tend to have helpful routines, which explain part of their better grades.
Settings matter too
They also report fewer tempting situations, which suggests they choose where they spend their time with care.
Sources
- Everyday temptations: an experience sampling study of desire, conflict, and self-control, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (Wilhelm Hofmann, Roy Baumeister, Georg Forster and Kathleen Vohs, 2012), PubMed abstract
- Already struggling to keep your New Year's resolutions? Here's the first detailed study of daily temptation, British Psychological Society Research Digest
- Self-control, Wikipedia
- Hyperbolic discounting, Wikipedia
- Revisiting the marshmallow test: a conceptual replication investigating links between early delay of gratification and later outcomes, Psychological Science (Tyler Watts, Greg Duncan and Haonan Quan, 2018), PubMed Central full text
- A multisite preregistered paradigmatic test of the ego-depletion effect, Psychological Science (Kathleen Vohs and colleagues, 2021), PubMed abstract
- A multilab preregistered replication of the ego-depletion effect, Perspectives on Psychological Science (Martin Hagger and colleagues, 2016), PubMed abstract
- More than resisting temptation: beneficial habits mediate the relationship between self-control and positive life outcomes, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (Brian Galla and Angela Duckworth, 2015), PubMed Central full text





