Mind & Psychology · Thinking & decisions
Anchoring and availability, two shortcuts in judgment
A number you've just seen pulls your estimate toward it, and whatever comes to mind easily feels common. See the experiments behind both shortcuts and what helps against each.
What you will learn
- Describe the anchoring effect using the experiments that first demonstrated it
- Explain why knowing about anchoring doesn't protect you from it
- State the availability heuristic and the experiment that named it
- Explain how coverage of an event changes what people believe about its frequency
Lesson 1 of 4 · 6 min
How a random number drags your estimate toward it
In 1974, Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman spun a wheel of fortune in front of people. It looked random. It was rigged to stop on either 10 or 65. Then they asked what percentage of African countries were in the United Nations.
Among people who saw the wheel stop on 10, the middle answer was 25%. Among those who saw 65, it was 45%. A carnival wheel had moved their beliefs about world politics by 20 points.
That's the anchoring effect. A number in front of you, the anchor, pulls your estimate toward it, even when the number is plainly irrelevant.
The anchor can also be your own first step. Two groups of high school students had five seconds to estimate a product. One saw 8 x 7 x 6 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1. The other saw the same numbers running up from 1.
The first group's middle guess was 2,250 and the second's was 512. The answer is 40,320. Each group started multiplying, ran out of time and stayed near where it began.
Prices work the same way. In a demonstration by Dan Ariely, people wrote down the last two digits of their Social Security number, then bid on wine and chocolate. Those with high digits bid 60% to 120% more.
Surely a warning protects you. In one study, people saw an anchor and then guessed how many physicians were in the local phone book. They were told outright that the anchor would contaminate their answers and that they should correct for it. Every warned group still guessed higher than a group that saw no anchor. Other studies find a warning can shrink the effect. None of these removed it.
Absurd anchors work too. Students were asked whether Mahatma Gandhi died before or after age 9, or before or after age 140. Neither can be right. Yet the first group then guessed he died at 50 on average, and the second at 67.
Paying for accuracy didn't reduce the effect in the wheel study. Expertise is no shield either. Real estate agents shown a house with different listing prices denied the price had influenced them. It moved their valuations as much as it moved students'. Experienced legal professionals have been swayed by arbitrary anchors unrelated to the case.
One strategy has the best record, called consider the opposite. You deliberately think of possibilities that run against your first impression. That gives your mind a rival to work from, where "just ignore it" gives it nothing.
Why anchoring happens is unsettled. Researchers agree it's easy to demonstrate and hard to explain.
Try to recallYou know perfectly well that the first price named in a negotiation is an anchor. Does knowing about anchoring protect you from it? Give evidence.
Largely not. People who were told an anchor would contaminate their phone-book estimates, and asked to correct for it, still guessed higher than a group with no anchor. Real estate agents denied that a listing price had influenced them, yet it moved their valuations as much as students'. What has helped most is to consider the opposite, which means deliberately thinking of possibilities that run against your first impression, so the anchor has a rival.
So when someone names a number first, in a price, a salary offer or a forecast, expect it to pull you. You won't feel it happen. Before you answer, think of reasons the right figure could be far from theirs.
Lessons in this topic
How a random number drags your estimate toward it
A rigged wheel of fortune shifted people's guesses about the United Nations by 20 points. See why warnings, money and expertise barely loosen an anchor's grip.
Why vivid dangers seem more common than they are
When you ask yourself how often something happens, your mind checks how easily an example comes to mind. See where that goes wrong, from the letter K to causes of death.
Why listing more evidence can make you less sure
People asked for twelve examples of their own assertiveness ended up feeling less assertive than people asked for six. See why the effort of recalling counts as evidence too.
How to tell anchoring from availability
Each shortcut swaps a hard question for an easier one, and each needs a different fix. Then learn how far to trust the story behind any bias.
Three quick stories from this topic
The wheel that moved the answer
A wheel of fortune rigged to stop on 10 or 65 changed what people believed about the UN
Asked what percentage of African countries were in the United Nations, people who had just seen the wheel stop on 10 gave a middle answer of 25%. People who saw 65 said 45%. The number plainly had nothing to do with the question, and it pulled their estimates anyway.
An anchor of your own making
Students given five seconds to estimate 8 x 7 x 6 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 x 1 typically guessed 2,250. Students shown the same numbers running up from 1 guessed 512. The answer is 40,320.
Hard to shake
People told outright that an anchor would contaminate their answers still estimated higher than a group given no anchor. Paying for accuracy didn't reduce the effect in the wheel study either.
Ten complaints, better ratings
Students asked for ten criticisms of a course rated it higher than students asked for two
At Duke University, 64 business students filled in a mid-course evaluation. Most of those asked for ten improvements listed no more than two. Struggling to find faults seems to have made the course look better. Their ratings averaged 5.52 out of 7, against 4.92.
Ease counts as evidence
People judge by how easily examples come to mind as well as by the examples themselves. When faults are hard to find, the difficulty reads as a sign there aren't many.
The original experiment
In 1991, people who recalled twelve examples of their own assertiveness rated themselves as less assertive than people who recalled six. Twelve was harder to reach.
Homicide against stroke
People judged homicide as common a cause of death as stroke, which killed 11 times as many
The finding comes from 1970s studies of how Americans estimate causes of death. Two newspapers checked at the time ran about three times as many articles on homicides as on deaths from disease. Disease killed almost 100 times as many people. The estimates followed the coverage.
The shortcut behind it
Asked how often something happens, people check how easily an example comes to mind. Psychologists call this the availability heuristic.
A caution from the authors
The link between coverage and belief is a correlation. The researchers noted that readers' fears may also shape what newspapers choose to cover.
Sources
- Anchoring effect, Wikimedia Foundation
- Judgment under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases, Tversky and Kahneman, Science, 1974 (copy hosted by the University of Washington)
- Availability heuristic, Wikimedia Foundation
- The availability heuristic in the classroom: How soliciting more criticism can boost your course ratings, Craig R. Fox, Judgment and Decision Making, 2006
- Facts vs. Fears: Understanding Perceived Risk, Slovic, Fischhoff and Lichtenstein, Decision Research, 1980 (University of Oregon Scholars' Bank)





