Mind & Psychology · Emotions & motivation
Intrinsic and extrinsic motivation
Some things you do for their own sake and some for a payoff. Learn how the kinds of motivation differ, when a reward kills interest and what people need to stay motivated.

What you will learn
- Tell intrinsic from extrinsic motivation by the reason behind an action
- Describe the range of extrinsic motivation from pressure to personally valued reasons
- Describe the nursery school drawing study and what it showed about expected rewards
- Explain which kinds of reward tend to undermine interest and which don't
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
Doing it for the joy or for the payoff
Watch a toddler stack blocks, knock them over and stack them again. Nobody pays the toddler. Psychologists call this intrinsic motivation, doing something for the satisfaction built into the activity. Richard Ryan and Edward Deci point out that people are curious and playful from birth without needing incentives.
Extrinsic motivation means acting for a separate outcome, such as a grade, money, praise or staying out of trouble. The test is the reason, not the activity. Two people can bake the same cake, one for the pleasure of baking and one to sell it.
Intrinsic motivation lives in the match between a person and a task, so not everyone enjoys the same things. Most of what you do mixes both kinds, and the mix can change over time.
Plenty of things worth doing aren't fun, like flossing or learning spelling. Ryan and Deci's self-determination theory says outside reasons still differ. They line them up by how much the reason feels like your own.
At the controlled end is external regulation, acting only for a reward or to avoid a punishment. Next comes introjected regulation, acting to avoid guilt or to protect your pride. Then there's identified regulation, where you've accepted the reason as personally important.
The most self-directed is integrated regulation, when the reason fits with your other values. It's still extrinsic, because the goal sits outside the activity. A boy who learns spelling lists because he wants to write has an identified reason.
These kinds behave differently. In one study of schoolchildren, more external reasons went with less interest and effort. Guilt-driven reasons went with more anxiety, and identified reasons with more enjoyment of school.
Try to recallWhy do Ryan and Deci still count a valued, self-chosen goal, such as studying hard to become a nurse, as extrinsic motivation?
The reason is an outcome separate from the activity itself. Studying is a means to the career, even when the student fully endorses it. That makes it identified or integrated regulation, self-directed but still extrinsic.
You can now sort a reason as intrinsic or extrinsic, and place outside reasons on a line from pure pressure to goals you've made your own.
Lessons in this topic
Doing it for the joy or for the payoff
Learn how psychologists tell intrinsic from extrinsic motivation, and why outside reasons range from pure pressure to goals you've made your own.
When a reward kills the fun
See how a nursery school drawing study showed that an expected prize can shrink interest, and learn which rewards tend to backfire.
Autonomy, competence and connection
Learn the three psychological needs at the heart of self-determination theory and how meeting or blocking each one changes motivation.
The fight over rewards and the question of culture
Follow the decades-long dispute over whether rewards really harm interest, and what studies in other cultures say about autonomy and choice.
Three quick stories from this topic
The drawing certificate
Preschoolers promised a certificate for drawing later chose to draw less in free play
Children who got the same certificate as a surprise didn't lose interest. The drop came from drawing to earn it, which seems to recast play as something done for a payoff.
Three groups
Mark Lepper, David Greene and Richard Nisbett split keen young artists into expected-award, surprise-award and no-award groups, then watched free play two weeks later.
The overjustification effect
An outside reason for something you already enjoy can make the activity feel done for the reward, so interest falls once the reward is gone.
The adult who ignored them
Children lost interest in an enjoyable task when the adult beside them ignored them
In a 1976 study, an adult stranger who didn't respond to children's attempts to engage left them with very low intrinsic motivation. Self-determination theory reads this as a missing sense of connection.
Three needs
Self-determination theory holds that people need autonomy, competence and relatedness, and that motivation sags when any of them is blocked.
A secure base
Plenty of people enjoy solo hobbies. What seems to matter is a background sense of connection, much as a securely attached infant explores more.
Extrinsic but your own
Learning spelling lists because you dream of being a writer counts as extrinsic motivation
In Richard Ryan and Edward Deci's scheme, anything done for an outcome beyond the activity is extrinsic. When you've adopted the reason as your own, though, it tends to bring more enjoyment and better coping than pressure does.
A line of reasons
Outside reasons run from pure pressure, through guilt and pride, to goals you value and goals woven into your other values.
Why it matters
Schoolchildren with more pressured reasons showed less interest and effort, while those who valued their work enjoyed school more.
Sources
- Intrinsic and extrinsic motivations: classic definitions and new directions, Contemporary Educational Psychology (Richard Ryan and Edward Deci, 2000), Center for Self-Determination Theory
- Psychology 2e, section 10.1 Motivation, OpenStax, Rice University
- Overjustification in a token economy, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (David Greene, Betty Sternberg and Mark Lepper, 1976), University of Western Macedonia course copy
- Self-determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation, social development, and well-being, American Psychologist (Richard Ryan and Edward Deci, 2000), Center for Self-Determination Theory





