Mathematics & Logic · Change & calculus
Limits
A limit is the value something closes in on, whether or not it ever gets there. See how the idea answers Zeno's runner, why 0.999... is exactly 1, and how calculus finally got a solid footing.

What you will learn
- Explain how infinitely many shrinking steps can add up to a finite total
- Explain why 0.999... with nines forever equals exactly 1
- Read a limit from a table of inputs and outputs closing in on a point
- Explain why the value at the point itself doesn't affect the limit
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
Zeno's runner and the endless steps that still finish
Around 450 BC, the Greek philosopher Zeno of Elea posed a puzzle. A runner heading for a bus stop must first reach the halfway point. Then she must cover half of what's left, then half of that, and so on forever.
That's infinitely many stretches to run. Zeno argued that infinitely many tasks can never be finished, so the runner never arrives. In fact, he said, nothing can ever move.
But look at the distances, a half, a quarter, an eighth, a sixteenth. Add them up as you go and the running totals are 0.5, 0.75, 0.875, 0.9375. Each one gets closer to 1, and none ever goes past it.
The value a list of numbers closes in on is its limit. The limit of these totals is 1, the whole distance. The times shrink the same way, which is the point Aristotle made, so the whole run takes a finite time.
Now try 0.999..., a decimal point followed by nines that never stop. Most people feel it must be a hair less than 1.
But 0.999... names the limit of the list 0.9, 0.99, 0.999 and so on. Each entry is closer to 1 than the one before. The gap shrinks to a tenth, a hundredth, a thousandth, past any size you name.
So is there a number between 0.999... and 1? Try to name one, and some entry on the list is already closer to 1 than your number is. There's no room left between them, so they're the same number. 0.999... is exactly 1.
Try to recallWhy is 0.999... with nines forever exactly equal to 1, not slightly less?
0.999... means the limit of 0.9, 0.99, 0.999 and so on, and those numbers get as close to 1 as you like. If 0.999... were less than 1, some number would fit between them. But any such number is passed by an entry on the list, so there's no gap, and the two are equal.
Infinitely many pieces can add up to a finite total when they shrink fast enough. The total is the limit the running sums close in on. That's why Zeno's runner arrives and why 0.999... is exactly 1.
Lessons in this topic
Zeno's runner and the endless steps that still finish
See how infinitely many shrinking steps can add up to a finite distance in a finite time, and why 0.999... is exactly 1.
Closing in on a value without landing on it
Read a limit from a table of values, and see why what happens exactly at the point doesn't change the answer.
Jumps, blow-ups and wobbles where no limit exists
Meet the three ways a limit can fail, and see why the endless sum 1 minus 1 plus 1 minus 1 has no total at all.
The challenge that put calculus on solid ground
Learn the challenge-and-response definition of a limit, and why calculus needed it after Berkeley mocked its ghosts of departed quantities.
Three quick stories from this topic
Ghosts of departed quantities
In 1734 a philosopher mocked calculus as built on ghosts of departed quantities
George Berkeley asked whether calculus's vanishing amounts were finite, infinitely small or nothing. Mathematicians kept using them anyway, and an exact fix took until the 1800s.
The fix
Cauchy rebuilt calculus on limits in 1821, and Weierstrass gave the definition its modern form in 1861.
The ghosts return
In 1966 Abraham Robinson showed infinitely small quantities can be made rigorous too, in what he called non-standard analysis.
A sum with no total
Adding 1, then subtracting 1, forever gives no total at all, not even zero
The running totals flip between 1 and 0 and never settle. Group the terms one way and you seem to get 0, another way and you seem to get 1.
Why grouping fails
An endless sum's total is the limit of its running totals. When they never settle, there's nothing for any grouping to find.
Undefined by design
Cauchy's theory of infinite sums, from the 1800s, gives a half plus a quarter plus an eighth a total of 1 and leaves this sum undefined.
0.999... is exactly 1
The decimal 0.999..., with nines that never end, is exactly equal to 1
It isn't a hair below 1. The endless decimal names the value that 0.9, 0.99, 0.999 close in on, and no number fits between that value and 1.
No room between
Two different numbers always have another number between them. Any number you try is passed by some entry on the list.
Two names, one number
Every ending decimal has a twin like this. 8.32 can also be written 8.31999 with nines forever.
Sources
- Zeno's Paradoxes, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Zeno's paradoxes, Wikipedia
- 0.999..., Wikipedia
- The Analyst, Wikipedia
- Limit of a function, Wikipedia





