Arts & Culture · Games & digital culture
Rules that create a game's experience
Change what a game rewards and players choose differently. See how scoring, tradeoffs, playtests and feedback loops shape play, from the board game that became Monopoly to Mario Kart.

What you will learn
- Tell an action a player can take apart from the goal used to judge it
- Explain how a change in scoring can change what players are rewarded for
- Explain how different costs and outcomes create a tradeoff
- Explain why an action's value depends on the current state of the game
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
Change the scoring and the best move changes
In 1903 Lizzie Magie applied for a patent on The Landlord's Game, a board game about rent and property. It came with two sets of rules. Under one, every player was rewarded when wealth was created. Under the other, the goal was to build monopolies and crush your opponents.
The board and pieces were the same for both. The cutthroat version caught on, and it inspired Monopoly.
A smaller game shows how. Your token moves one space per turn, picks up a coin when it enters a coin space and finishes at an exit. One route goes straight there. A longer one passes the coins. Which is better depends on the scoring.
Say the only goal is to leave in the fewest turns. Then a trip for coins is wasted time. Now say the goal is to collect the most coins before you exit. The same detour pays off.
Nothing on the board moved. Only your reason for choosing a route changed.
The game designer Ian Schreiber states it as a rule of thumb. Change even one element of a game, such as its goal, and you can get a very different game.
Now add a turn limit, with a bonus for reaching the exit before time runs out. Coins still score. But every detour spends turns you may need to get out.
So each coin now has a price. You weigh one more coin against the turns you have left. Designers call that an incentive, a push the game gives you toward one choice.
It doesn't force anyone, and some players will still chase every coin.
The theme is the story painted over the rules. Call the token an explorer and the coins artifacts, and the board looks like an expedition. The moves and the scoring haven't changed.
A game can even hide inside another. Two players take turns picking numbers from 1 to 9, and the first to hold three that add up to 15 wins. It looks like arithmetic, and it's tic-tac-toe.
Write the nine numbers in a square where every row, column and diagonal adds up to 15. Three numbers that make 15 are then three in a row.
So look past the theme. Ask what players can do and what the game rewards.
Try to recallIn a board game with a turn limit, how could a bonus for exiting in time change a player's decision about collecting one more coin?
The detour might gain a coin but risk missing the exit bonus. The player has to weigh the extra coin against the time it costs and the bonus they could lose.
A game's rules for moving tell you what's allowed. Its goal and scoring tell you what's smart. Change the scoring and the same board becomes a different game.
Lessons in this topic
Change the scoring and the best move changes
One board can be two different games. See how a change in what earns points changes the route players take, in a small coin game and in the game that became Monopoly.
Why some game choices are dull and others are hard
A choice in a game gets interesting when you give something up to get something else. See why Battleship and Trivial Pursuit offer so few of those choices, and how the score you need changes the right move.
Why designers test a rule before they trust it
A rule is a guess about how people will play. See how a paper prototype and a playtest that changes one thing show whether the guess was right.
Why some games help the leader and others the loser
Some rules make a lead grow and others pull the pack back together. Learn to tell positive from negative feedback loops, and predict what each does to a game's length and its comebacks.
Three quick stories from this topic
Monopoly's other rule set
The game that became Monopoly had a second rule set where everyone gained from new wealth
Lizzie Magie applied to patent The Landlord's Game in 1903, with two sets of rules for one board. The other set told players to build monopolies and crush their opponents. That's the version that caught on.
Same board, different game
The board and pieces were the same under both rule sets. What changed was the goal, and with it what players did to each other.
What Magie was paid
When Monopoly took off in the 1930s, Parker Brothers bought her patent. For it and two other game ideas she reportedly received $500 and no royalties.
Tic-tac-toe in disguise
A game about picking numbers that add up to 15 is tic-tac-toe in disguise
Two players take turns choosing numbers from 1 to 9, and the first to hold three that total 15 wins. Arrange the nine numbers in a square where every line sums to 15, and each pick becomes a mark on a tic-tac-toe grid.
Why it works
In a 3 by 3 magic square of the numbers 1 to 9, every row, column and diagonal adds up to 15. Three numbers total 15 only when they lie along one of those lines.
Rules under the surface
The game designer Ian Schreiber uses the pair to show that two games can look different and share the same underlying rules. He notes that most people don't see the match until they've played both.
Mario Kart's item rule
Mario Kart hands its best items to the drivers at the back of the race
A driver near the bottom of the field is likely to get an item that sharply boosts their speed, while the leaders mostly get weaker ones. Designers call that a negative feedback loop. It makes every lead harder to keep, so the pack stays together.
Why it's called negative
In Schreiber's usage, negative means the effect weakens each time around, and it has nothing to do with harming the player. The loop makes it harder for a leader to extend the lead and harder for a trailing player to fall further behind, which pulls the pack together. Schreiber says that keeps racing more interactive.
The tradeoff
Negative loops stabilize a game, make it last longer and shift weight to the late game. They can also feel unfair, as if success were being punished. Schreiber's way to find out whether players will accept a loop is to playtest it.
Sources
- Level 3: Formal elements of games, Ian Schreiber, Game Design Concepts
- Level 7: Decision-making and flow theory, Ian Schreiber, Game Design Concepts
- Level 2: Game design, iteration and rapid prototyping, Ian Schreiber, Game Design Concepts
- The secret history of Monopoly: the capitalist board game's leftwing origins, The Guardian
- Number Scrabble, Wikimedia Foundation
- Level 5: Mechanics and dynamics, Ian Schreiber, Game Design Concepts
- Dynamic game difficulty balancing, Wikimedia Foundation





