Technology & Computing · Digital life & society

Online advertising and free services

Search, maps and social apps cost nothing because advertisers pay for your attention. See how one ad slot is auctioned while a page loads, how ads get targeted and measured, and where fraud and blockers bite.

4 short lessons · about 16 minutes · 6 sources · updated November 2026

What you will learn

  • Explain what users give in exchange for ad-funded services and who pays the bill
  • Compare the ad-funded model with a subscription and say whose interests each serves
  • Explain how real-time bidding sells one ad view while a page loads
  • Explain why a search ad auction ranks ads by quality as well as bid

Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min

Who really pays for free apps and websites

Before you readIn 2019, what share of the UK's search advertising money went to Google?

Correct.Not quite. The answer is Over 90%.

Google earned more than 90%. The lesson shows what makes that business work when the searches are free.

On October 27, 1994, the website HotWired put up the first banner ad it sold, paid for by AT&T. It was sold by impressions, meaning each time the ad was shown. The web's free pages have run on that deal ever since.

Search, maps, video and social apps charge you nothing. The UK's competition regulator, the CMA, described what happens instead. In exchange for searching, watching or chatting, you provide your attention and data about yourself. The platform combines the two to show ads that advertisers will pay a lot for.

The money still comes from you, by a longer route. The CMA put UK digital ad spending at about £14 billion in 2019, or £500 per household. Advertisers fold that cost into the prices of hotels, flights, books and insurance.

Check yourselfAccording to the UK's CMA, how do consumers end up paying for "free" search and social media?

Correct.Not quite. The answer is Through higher prices for advertised goods.

Advertisers pass their ad spending into the prices of what they sell, about £500 per UK household in 2019.

A subscription works the other way round. You pay, so you're the customer, and the service has to keep you satisfied. In the ad model, the advertiser is the customer. The service earns more from more of your time and more data about you, because both make its ads worth more.

Many companies now run both. Alphabet earned $82 billion from Google ads in the last quarter of 2025, about 72% of its revenue. It also had over 325 million paid subscriptions, led by Google One and YouTube Premium.

Some places now push for a real choice. In November 2023, Meta gave EU users two options for Facebook and Instagram. They could consent to personalized ads or pay monthly to see none. In April 2025, the European Commission ruled that wasn't enough and fined Meta €200 million. Users must also get a free version that uses less of their personal data.

Try to recallHow do the incentives of an ad-funded app differ from those of a subscription app?

A subscription app is paid by its users, so it does best by keeping them happy enough to keep paying. An ad-funded app is paid by advertisers, so it does best by holding more attention and gathering more data. Those goals can overlap, but they aren't the same.

Free services are paid for with your attention and data, and the ad bill returns in the prices of goods. A subscription makes you the customer, while ads make the advertiser the customer.

Lessons in this topic

  1. Who really pays for free apps and websites

    See what you hand over for free search and social apps, who ends up paying the advertising bill, and how the ad model differs from a subscription.

    Essentials · 4 min

  2. The auction that runs while a page loads

    Follow one ad slot from the moment you open a page to the winning bid, and see why search ads rank by quality as well as money.

    Essentials · 4 min

  3. How ads find you and how anyone knows they worked

    See how advertisers pick who sees an ad, from search words to lookalike audiences, and why proving an ad changed anything is harder than counting clicks.

    Deeper · 4 min

  4. Fake clicks, ad blockers and other ways to pay

    See how fraudsters sell ads to bots, why so many people block ads, and what tracking limits and paid options change.

    Deeper · 4 min

Three quick stories from this topic

The £500 ad bill

Free search and social media cost each UK household about £500 in 2019, through prices

The UK competition regulator put digital ad spending at about £14 billion that year. Advertisers fold that cost into what they charge for hotels, flights, books and insurance, so shoppers pay it at the till.

Paid another way

You pay for free services with attention and data, and the ad money comes back through prices.

Why it may be too much

The regulator thought these costs were likely higher than they would be in a more competitive market.

eBay's pointless ads

eBay found its ads on searches for "eBay" had no measurable short-term effect on sales

People searching for eBay were heading there anyway, so the ad just intercepted a visit that would have happened. Standard click counts had credited those ads with sales they didn't cause.

How they tested it

eBay switched ads off in some places and compared sales against places where ads kept running.

The wider lesson

Clicks and purchases go together, so only a comparison group shows what an ad really adds.

Bots watching ads

One fraud scheme used 570,000 bots to "watch" up to 300 million video ads a day

The Methbot operators built fake sites named like famous publishers, so advertisers paid premium prices for views no person saw. Estimates put their takings at $3 million to $5 million a day at the peak.

Paid by the view

Advertisers paid for each view, so every fake one turned into real money.

Why it worked

The bots mimicked normal users, which made the fake traffic hard to tell from real readers.

Sources

  • How recommendation feeds decide what you see

    Follow how a feed narrows billions of items to a screenful, what its score rewards, and how the design of a screen steers the choices you make.

    4 lessons · 17 min

  • How cookies let websites remember and track you

    A cookie is a small note a server asks your browser to keep and hand back. See why the web needs them, how one company can use them to follow you across sites, and what browsers do about it.

    4 lessons · 25 min

  • Social media

    See how social networks grew from friend lists into feeds of strangers' videos, why they cost nothing to use, why the leading app differs by country, and what experiments say about their effect on politics.

    4 lessons · 16 min

  • Binary, bits and bytes

    Everything a computer holds is a pattern of on and off. Learn to count in binary, see what bits and bytes are, and find out why one pattern can be a number, a letter or a shade.

    4 lessons · 16 min

  • How a database keeps records consistent

    See how transactions, built-in rules and isolation levels keep records right when a server crashes, two buyers want one seat or two updates collide.

    4 lessons · 17 min

  • Passwords, passkeys and account security

    See how passwords get stolen, how a passkey signs you in with nothing to steal, and why account recovery needs as much care as sign-in.

    4 lessons · 17 min

All technology & computing topics · Take the quiz